HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US   LINKS      
 

 
SALFORD QUAYS CRANES FINAL HOPES DASHED BY BIZARRE COUNCIL LOGIC
 

Star date: 20th June 2013

SALFORD QUAYS CARGO CRANES WON'T BE A COMMUNITY ASSET – `BECAUSE WE'RE GOING TO BULLDOZE THEM' STATES COUNCIL

A last ditch application by the Salford Quays Heritage And Nature Group to save the iconic Salford Quays cargo cranes by having them put on the list of Salford Council's `community assets' has been turned down. 

Despite agreeing with the Heritage Group that the cranes `further the social wellbeing or social interests of the local community' the Council adds that "in the not so distant future" they will not further these interests "because the cranes have been dismantled and removed from the site"

Full wacko details here…


The long running saga to try and save the iconic blue Salford Quays cargo cranes has finally run into a dead end, as a last minute plea by the Salford Quays Heritage And Nature Group to have the structures included on Salford Council's list of `community assets' has been turned down.

The cranes were previously included in the Council's Local List of heritage assets, but were recently omitted when a new list was drawn up. Under new legislation which allows the community to identify Assets of Community Value - Part 5, Chapter 3 of the Localism Act, and Assets of Community Value Regulations - the Heritage Group submitted an application to the Council to give the cranes some protection.

The Group claimed that the cranes have `industrial heritage value as they represent internationally important representations of the original use of the docks and stand as a testament to the dockers who grafted to make Salford the largest inland port in the world'.

Its application added that `the cranes are the last survivors of those which once served the docks of the port of Manchester and that they are iconic, well loved assets of the community who view the cranes with Salfordian pride and that saving the cranes has universal support within the Salford community'.

On the financial front the Group - taking its cue from Spain where similar style cranes are a cherished heritage centrepiece (see here) - reckoned that, with a bit of vision and imagination, there could be jobs created refurbishing the structures, and more jobs created as increased numbers of tourists were attracted to the Quays, especially as 120th anniversary celebrations of the Docks are due to take place in 2014.

While Salford Council "accepted that currently the siting/presence of the cranes has furthered the social wellbeing and interests of the local community as required by Section 88 (1) (a) of the Localism Act and therefore is of community value", it uses bizarre logic to turn down the Heritage Group's application, stating that "in the not so distant future, the cranes will not continue to further the social wellbeing or social interests of the local communityWhether this is because the cranes have been dismantled and removed from the site or whether they have fallen into such a state of disrepair that they can no longer be considered to be of value to the community."

In other words, `the cranes won't be of any community value because we're not going to refurbish them and we're going to bulldoze them instead'.

Thus, the Council concludes "the cranes do therefore not meet the requirements of Section 88 (1) (b) of the Localism Act and therefore it is recommended that the cranes are not added to the list of assets of community value".

Bizarre or what? And thus ends the six year old fight to save the blue Salford Quays cargo cranes – which will be demolished this summer.

PS: The Council report recommending that the cranes were not listed as community assets was circulated to every councillor in Salford - not even one single councillor bothered to respond.

 

For the whole Salford Star history of the trashing of the cranes see these articles…

* Cranes to move to M602 roundabout - click here

* Cranes to be moved or scrapped as they `ruin the view' - click here

* Cranes removed from Local Listing - click here

* Cranes to be demolished - click here

* Cranes Hope as English Heritage gets involved - click here 

* Cranes Doomed as English Heritage refuse to list cranes - click here

* Council omits cranes from new heritage list - click here

* Did cranes refurbishment funding get swallowed by £300,000 Biospheric `Pea Farm'? - click here

Jane Wood wrote
at 11:27:55 AM on Saturday, July 06, 2013
I wrote this poem about my opinions of the Cranes and valuing and wanting more people to recognise the hidden gem of a sculpture, Four Corners, just near the cranes on the walkway from the cranes to the Lowrey. This was made from the stories and creativity of dockers as the docks were closing. It is well worth searching it out. We at Ordsall Trust are making a film about the cranes and showing it on 20th July at the Deli Lama Cafe ( Chapel Street) 3-5. Four Corners Thanks to the Blue Cranes Symbols of the affluent Manchester Ship Canal Company now Peel Holdings Thanks to The Manchester Ship Canal Company for providing employment for the Hungry Dockers Thanks to the hungry Dockers For sharing their stories, spirited, companiable, fun and times on the LOW SILVER SCULPTURE near the HIGH ROTTING BLUE CRANES Four Corners
 
Beryl Hawke wrote
at 12:07:38 AM on Friday, June 28, 2013
After watching a programme about Bristol this evening especially the Dock area I would like to know why the Council are so short sighted. Their cranes have been kept and are a feature of the heritage of the area. A museum with an at least one article of interest from industry. Woodbines were made there, first I'd heard of that one. If at least one member of the Council has catch up on TV I suggest they watch this programme. Its never too late to learn.
 
not a brain dead labour voter wrote
at 11:53:20 PM on Monday, June 24, 2013
wonder if we can get Salford labour council grade two listed, then we could get rid of them as surplus to requirement, seems to work for listed buildings. on coans totem pole, lets hope the woodpecker population start to flourish, what the f*ck has a totem pole got to do with Salford history that's more important than these cranes, these cranes are historically more important to Salford than a poxy piece of carved wood from north America, I know lets protect every other countries historical pieces and lets destroy our own, the mind boggles.
 
wrote
at 3:08:02 AM on Monday, June 24, 2013
If Jonathan Drake, now employed Salix Homes, and all the SCC staff seconded to the quango that was the URC had done what they were paid to do and secured the funding/business interest in preserving the cranes we wouldnt now be in this position. Historical interest in the Salford docks site never came into it, the only thing left on Trafford Rd that warrents any historical interest now is the lock keepers tower on the old bridge. Even the old totem pole only got saved because Cllr Coen took an interest in it. Lets see whether that gets sited back on the docks where it belongs when it returns to Salford.
 
mary ferrer wrote
at 12:28:27 PM on Sunday, June 23, 2013
Just been reading John Warmisham's blog."41 Pubs closed, still standing, but for how long" I wonder how many of these buildings are old and of historical interest? I know if any are and this council have anything to do with it, they won't be standing for long. We all need to be vigilante, if you know of a building of historical interest that could become a target for our councils hit squad, speak out before all our heritage is lost forever.
 
Ivor B wrote
at 12:28:12 PM on Sunday, June 23, 2013
As the price of scrap metal rises you do tend to get undesirable scumbags seeking to steal what metal they can from others in the community for their own gain! Anyway enough about Salford council now. When do you start your new job at Peel Mike?
 
Alice Darlington wrote
at 8:16:50 AM on Sunday, June 23, 2013
Michael Felse, what an inane and scaremongering comment. Why would you want Salford Council to waste money on unnecessary fencing and deny the enjoyment of local fishers? The cranes are not currently a risk to the public. The council are saying they are dangerous so they can scrap them, don't you get it?
 
Michael Felse wrote
at 2:15:00 AM on Sunday, June 23, 2013
@Alice raises a valid point. Salford Council must immediately fence off the decking used by fishing enthusiasts and others. This risk has clearly now been highlighted here and Salford Safety Team must protect the public without delay or can be held responsible for any subsequent personal accident incident caused.
 
Bernard Brough wrote
at 2:14:33 AM on Sunday, June 23, 2013
Mr Felse, in this case the only hazard I can see is Salford Council.
 
Alice Darlington wrote
at 11:52:57 AM on Saturday, June 22, 2013
@ Michael Felse, haven't you noticed many tram lines have pedestrian access across them? It is common sense to keep an eye out for oncoming trams when walking across or between lines. There is absolutely no evidence that the cranes are currently a danger to the public, if this was the case the decking on the water directly below the cranes would have also been fenced off. The decking has remained accessible to the public during this ongoing saga. If the cranes are not maintained they will become a hazard as they continue to deteriorate but who's fault is that? I am wondering if the cost of the demolition (with overnight teams to prevent any disruption to Metro) will outweigh the cost of maintaining them. SC will have even more questions to answer if they overspend on this disgraceful plan.
 
wrote
at 5:55:48 AM on Saturday, June 22, 2013
@michael felse, that is quite a talent you have got there, you need to get your self on Britain got talent, you know, being able to speak while you've got your tongue up Ian Stewart arse.
 
Michael Felse wrote
at 10:53:04 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
Sorry to see the end of these iconic Cranes. Health and Safety would demand that something be done fast as they continue to block the footpath causing local people to walk between the metro tram lines. The sad truth is our Council has decided not to restore and it must now quickly remove what has become a hazard.
 
deBauch wrote
at 9:45:14 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
Cultural cleansing...thats the only logical conclusion that you can draw from this. Iconic industrial treasures such as the Salford cranes are jealously guarded by cities all over the World...this is a fact that can be demonstrated time and again. A legal framework was provided in this country for folk to challenge the destruction of things deemed by the people to be for the people. Objections were raised and the heartfelt pleas of the people were passed on to the council to be completely ignored. No consideration was given to any possible rescue attempt by the Community...no stay of execution to provide an opportunity to raise funds, not even a hearing to discuss such a possibility. The thing was a fait a complit from the getgo...we ALL knew that it stunk of that. You have to ask yourself why such determination and the only answer that I can come up with is that they don’t want “your sort” down there and the quicker that they can erase any semblance of evidence that you lot had anything whatsoever to do with the docks the better....and that’s cultural cleansing. There are many disgraceful things about this rape of a peoples culture but I think that one of THE most shocking and disturbing things about it is that it’s all being done by a Labour council. You could kinda understand it if it were the tories but to be turned over by your own kind is unforgivable....shame on everyone involved with the cranes destruction....tell your Grandkids about it one day.......
 
Gaetano Bresci wrote
at 9:44:58 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
If the people of Salford gave a damn about their heritage they would be marching in the streets, occupying the site of the cranes, protesting, like people do in the rest of the world. See Istanbul? People didn't want the mall, they wanted the public park to stay and they were prepared to fight to defend their city from speculators. Are Salfordians prepared to actually *do* something to defend their heritage from the appetites of speculators and the corrupt council? They are not. So, this is exactly what they deserve. The city to be destroyed and turned into a faceless, characterless, playground for obtuse yuppies.
 
Amber Sanchez wrote
at 3:49:20 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
I cannot even begin to express my bitter disappointment with the council. This is SO terrible for Salford.
 
Lee Craven MBE wrote
at 1:18:04 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
Like everything else in this City that have History & Culture behind it..."They Demolish" No Consultation as ever,makes me so Angry,I am one for keeping these, to show children about the History,I remember in the 80s this same council demanded they were to stay,,now they want to Demolish them because they were not bothered to look after them.
 
mary ferrer wrote
at 1:17:54 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
Yet another part of our history and heritage going on the scrapheap. The way things are going we won't have much left. Question I keep asking, where is the money that was ring fenced for the Cranes. Wonder whats next on their hit list.
 
Alice Searle wrote
at 1:17:02 AM on Friday, June 21, 2013
It strikes me that this decision is very short sighted and lacks imagination and awareness of the value of heritage. As a country we have spend millions dredging old ships from the ocean, spent decades preserving ancient long boats, and even here in Salford, millions, or was it billions, on renovating a Tudor farm house. I, and many others, have enjoyed and learned from these examples of former lives. It is these gems of the past that give us insight and appreciation of the struggles that have led to our current prosperity.The cranes are such examples and their value would increase with time. I suspect that those with an agenda for promoting the shiny and glitzy style of Media City could see them as an eyesore. Odd that I read in the 'Cultural Strategy for Salford Quays' that "history shapes the core idea at its heart." Has this been forgotten or were they just empty words?
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
Salford Star photo stories
Cornerstone advert
Mary Burns Publishing
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: John Cooper Clarke On Life In Higher Broughton.
Hi elsa, I worder if you remember that I used to visit you and your sister Irene at your shop on Gt Cheetham St some time after... [more]
article: SALFORD JOB CENTRE BENEFITS SANCTIONS PROTEST
Shocking how staff working there can be given instructions to follow, they can understand and not simply stick together as a commu... [more]
article: PAUL HEATON SLATES LOW PAY AS GMB WAGES WAR ON NEXT
Is this the same GMB who allowed salford council to reduce by thousand of pounds the wages of council staff during job evaluation ... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL £56MILLION CUTS OVER NEXT TWO YEARS
Well said salford onion, @ Royston the government are making cuts to all councils, it's up to councils to make cuts where they thi... [more]
article: SALFORD JOB CENTRE BENEFITS SANCTIONS PROTEST
I understand the staff at the benefits office, who are sanctioning people are "only following orders" But maybe they would be le... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

A PROPER SALFORD TRIBUTE TO SHELAGH DELANEY

Star date: 26th November 2014

SHELAGH DELANEY DAY AT SALFORD ARTS THEATRE

`A voice for the poor that is sadly no more
gone with the ships that sailed on the docks' JB Barrington

A lot of attitude, a bit of an edge and bucket loads of proper Salford summed up the top entertainment at Salford Arts Theatre last night to celebrate the city's first Shelagh Delaney Day.

From the Salford Arts Theatre Young Performers Company giving A Slice of Life that inspired the Duchy girl to theatrical heights, to JB Barrington's performance of his spiky, specially written Gone With The Ships, to Salford Theatre Company's mimed anti-materialism in Now and Then, Shelagh Delaney would have been proud.

Full review here...

SALFORD JOB CENTRE BENEFITS SANCTIONS PROTEST

Star date: 25th November 2014

SALFORD JOB CENTRE PUSHING PEOPLE TO FOOD BANKS

"It should be re-named Salford Sanction Centre because they don't seem to be helping people with jobs, just sanctioning people..."

Members of the newly formed Salford Unite Community Union protested outside Salford Job Centre, off Churchill Way, this morning to highlight the increasing use of sanctions to kick people off benefits. They also handed out leaflets to claimants giving information on how to challenge sanctions decisions.

Full details here...

HUGE PUBLIC SUPPORT IN SALFORD FOR NHS WORKERS STRIKE

Star date: 24th November 2014

NHS STAFF STRIKE AT SALFORD ROYAL HOSPITAL

"The public see us as angels but we're not, we need to live like everyone else"

There was huge public support for NHS staff at Salford Royal Hospital this morning as they went on strike for four hours against the ConDem Government's refusal to implement a 1% pay rise recommended by the independent Pay Review Body. The MPs' pay review body has recommended a 10% pay rise for them, which they are sure to take.

Full details here...

SALFORD COUNCIL £56MILLION CUTS OVER NEXT TWO YEARS

Star date: 24th November 2014

SALFORD COUNCIL TO WASH ITS HANDS OF YOUNG, ELDERLY, SICK AND VULNERABLE

Salford Council is to hammer the old, the young, the ill and the vulnerable in its new round of £56million cuts over the next two years, outlined today.

Over £5million is to be axed from adult health and social care budgets by farming the service out to the NHS and other organisations, while over £4million is to be slashed from Children's Services, including transport and looked after kids.

Meanwhile, over £4million is to be taken from budgets to support vulnerable and sick people, while Council staff face redundancies to `save' up to £500,000. And there's a special Council `turkeys vote for Christmas' consultation...

Full details here...

SALFORD SHELAGH DELANEY DAY 25TH NOVEMBER

Star date: 23rd November 2014

SHELAGH DELANEY DAY EVENTS AND EXHIBITIONS

"She had far more on her mind than 'how to be famous'" Charlotte Delaney

Shelagh Delaney Day finally arrives on Tuesday 25th November with a whole evening at Salford Arts Theatre of sold out plays, performances, art exhibitions and a poem specially written by top Salford wordsmith JB Barrington.

There's also a free screening of Delaney's A Taste of Honey at Eccles Town Hall on Friday 28th, a lantern display by pupils of Summerville Road Primary School in Duchy on the 28th and a photo exhibition at Salford Lads Club on the 29th and 30th.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx