HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US   LINKS      
 

 
SALFORD QUAYS CRANES PERIL
 

Star date: 13th October 2010 

HISTORIC QUAYS CRANES TO BE MOVED OR SCRAPPED

The iconic blue cranes at Salford Quays are to be moved out of the Quays or demolished completely.

An option to keep the cranes at the Quays was considered by Salford Council but it was decided that the locally listed Grade A structures would ruin the view!

Full details here…


SALFORD QUAYS CRANES IN PERIL SALFORD QUAYS CRANES IN PERIL SALFORD QUAYS CRANES IN PERIL
SALFORD QUAYS CRANES IN PERIL SALFORD QUAYS CRANES IN PERIL SALFORD QUAYS CRANES IN PERIL
click image to enlarge

As revealed last February by the Salford Star (see here), there is now a formal attempt to move the two iconic blue cranes out of Salford Quays, and plonk them at the end of the M602 as part of a £3million MediaCityUK roundabout tart-up.

If the Highways Agency objects to the re-location, or repair costs to the cranes go above budget, they could well be scrapped altogether. Indeed, there was a move in June 2009 to have the structures - Grade A listed on the Local List of Buildings Structures and Features of Archaeological, Architectural or Historic Interest - permanently `recycled'.

The old cranes, which were operational from 1966 at Dock 6 on the Quays, were moved to their current site in 1988 and basically left to rot until four years ago when bits of safety railings and ladders were so corroded they were removed to stop them falling on the heads of passing people.

Salford Council neglected its heritage and is now having to cope with the fall-out. Its own report states that "There is clear evidence of the lack of maintenance by the city over the period of time that the cranes have been located in their current position".

In 2007 Salford Council considered scrapping the cranes altogether, or retaining one and scrapping the other, or giving them to the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester. But it was decided to repair them and keep them at the current location on Ontario Basin because they were considered to be an "important local landmark" and "represent an important link with the heritage and history of Salford Quays".

Now, the Council is stating that the cranes can't be kept at Ontario Basin because of "difficulties regarding repair and future maintenance" and have to be moved.

Given that Peel Holdings own most of the old docks, now to be MediaCityUK, the only other site the Council has is at the front of the Lowry Outlet Mall. This option would "ensure that the cranes are retained in a location that is appropriate in terms of demonstrating their historic relationship with the Quays". But it was rejected because it might spoil the view for residents of the posh new flats. Or as the Council puts it, "The location of the cranes would detract from the local vista as one leaves the Lowry Outlet Mall and would spoil the open aspect. Although the cranes are symbolic of the past history of the Quays, they would increase the sense of clutter at this location."

It also states that the historic cranes would cause "Disruption to rhythm of the high quality boulevard currently in place" and "Disruption to nearby residents and businesses in terms of noise/dust during maintenance operations and impact on views likely to lead to objections".

Instead, the only Council option is to move the cranes to the roundabout at the end of the M602, although "This location is not ideal in terms of demonstrating the cranes' historic relationship with the Quays".

The £75,000 plinths to mount the cranes at the roundabout have already been paid for by the NWDA, and there's around £647,000 in the kitty from previous years to sort out the removal and repair of the structures. However, should costs exceed this sum there is a `medium risk' that the cranes could still be scrapped.

There's also a `medium risk' that the Highways Agency will object to the roundabout relocation which, a Council report states, "would require officers to identify an alternative site, which, in light of previous difficulties in identifying suitable sites, may mean that the option to scrap the cranes must be revisited".

The two blue cranes are almost the last remnant of the former Docks as Salford's history is being wiped away.

* The Lowry, as lead body for the Salford Quays Consortium, was recently awarded £424,000 from the Heritage Lottery Fund for its `Unlocking The Quays' project, a "community-led, activities project to improve interpretation and increase access to the history of Salford Quays".

£175,000 was paid to five artists to provide public art works to commemorate the history of the Docks. None of the five artists, paid £35,000 each, was actually from Salford. The final artworks appear to consist of a bench in the shape of a number 9 (for Dock 9); an `integrated seating and built in floor display' taking `inspiration from the Ship Canal'; stainless steel blades, representing `tales of bizarre animals and plant life' from the docks; and armless sculptures of women, representing `engineering and radio waves'.

The fifth sculpture of union cards, representing the struggles of dock workers, will actually be sited in Trafford, rather than in Salford. One local participant in the project whose family worked on the docks wrote to Salford Star earlier this year stating… "not one of the artists was from Salford, and to be honest, all but one of the designs were pretty crap. They showed no real knowledge of the area, or the dockers, or the way of life…"

On the removal of the cranes from Salford Quays, Cllr Derek Antrobus, Lead Member for Planning, says…

"Salford is a city of history and tradition, but is also a city that embraces change, as evidenced by the evolution of Salford Quays from docklands to a high quality, award winning residential and business destination. While the transformation of the Salford Quays area continues apace, with the initial phase of MediaCityUK almost complete, the council recognises the need to protect and respect its important heritage assets. The opportunity to relocate the cranes to sit within the modern Quays Gateway scheme encapsulates the city's eagerness to look towards the future, whilst paying respect to its historic roots".


 

 

 

 

 

Steve Middleton wrote
at 12:35:40 PM on Wednesday, November 03, 2010
As funding has now been withdrawn for Phase 2 of the Quays Gateway plan, it's highly unlikely that the cranes will be moved to the M602 roundabout as originally planned. I've blogged about this here: http://stevemiddleton.info/2010/11/03/how-should-our-community-spend-170000-you-decide/
 
Brian F Kirkham wrote
at 8:17:07 AM on Friday, October 29, 2010
Given the recent cut in Arts council funding, due to the budget deficit, would it not make sense for those behind the quays to develop their current buildings/structures for the greater good? The £175,000 spent on design and development of these artworks could have easily been spent on the fixing up of the cranes on their current site, with any surplus money available to other art projects elsewhere. I read with interest this article - and smiled at the fact that the artists had no connection to the area - probably re-inforcing a view that those in authority (on both sides of the canal) wish to maintain - the view of salford as a backwater suburb of manchester I am a local - i was born and raised in Salford and have lived here through its good and bad times. It seems to me that nobody in the grand spires at Peel Holdings/Mediacity decided to actually consult with residents before planning the implementation the changes But i could say that about the URC, The selling off of public buildings for private estates, clearing of council land for selloffs and all...I'll spare you a History Lesson. Q : Apart from urban cargoes, on the trafford side of the quays...where is the dockside connection with artworks? (waves - canal = tenuous link at best) Oh...BTW...Since when was the M602 Roundabout part of the Quays?
 
Sebastian W - Salford Quays resident wrote
at 1:56:05 AM on Thursday, October 28, 2010
An utterly TRAGIC! idea to remove the cranes, scrapping the last bit of the Quays heritage, I think it should be protested against! And as to that bright green "piece of art" erected next to the Lowry, covered with kids drawings and poems engraved on the pillars - it has completely ridiculed the Imperial War Museum North in front of which it sits, and obstructs the view of a world class piece of architecture that the IWMN is! How disappointing!
 
Jim Devine wrote
at 4:46:36 AM on Monday, October 18, 2010
Nice words Brian. I am originally from Belfast and the powers that be were going to knock down and remove David and Goliath the two iconic cranes that welcomes everybody into the city and who helped build the Titanic. The people of Belfast were outraged at this and made them reverse their decidion. Its really a question of symbolism and to me David and Goliath symbolised the strength and courage of every shipyard worker whoever worked or in many cases died there. It would be akin to future generations deciding to remove war memorials although I better not give Peel any more ideas.
 
Brian F Kirkham wrote
at 3:09:03 AM on Monday, October 18, 2010
Hi Stephen, Im sending you this as a memorial to the two grand old pieces of steel peel seem to want to get rid of They seem to forget where they are - the quays being the Docks! I call it Standing Statues : They stand side by side on the rail of the basin, dressed in their regal blue. The sky above as clear as day The sun reflecting their noble form Once Giants on the waters edge, Lifting treasures from passing ships The Ships have gone, No longer Passing, The Seagulls now their only friends New craft now occupy their basin, Their noble Arms no longer needed as the boats are much smaller than they could give aid.
 
RWL wrote
at 1:20:49 PM on Thursday, October 14, 2010
I've lived in many parts of the country and settled in Salford 10 years ago. Salford has a world class heritage and the council should have a duty to preserve it for its citizens. When Salford's heritage is gone, it's gone and nothing will bring it back.
 
Ed wrote
at 6:38:19 AM on Wednesday, October 13, 2010
Its amazing, all those millions being splashed around the quays, and what's the cost of a coat of paint every 3 or 4 years?. A message to Salford City Council, why not take some pride in the heritage of the former dock lands, and make a purpose built concrete platform out over the "historic waterfront" and place the cranes on it over looking the Ship Canal basin. A platform well away from all those posh appartements, buildings and metro trams, and that would make regular maintenance easy and safe.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Deli Lama
Salford Star photo stories
Cornerstone advert
Mary Burns Publishing
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: OASIS ACADEMY MEDIACITYUK SALFORD SLATED BY OFSTED
They should never have closed hope high down and moved it to its present position, everyone in the tootal and Claremont area knew... [more]
article: SALFORD PEOPLE SPEAK OUT AGAINST MEDIA STIGMA
Bernard, look at the participants then convince yourself that thi is not a reality checks stereotyping comes from fact salford is ... [more]
article: SALFORD PEOPLE SPEAK OUT AGAINST MEDIA STIGMA
Well said salford onion, this is the type of country we are fast becoming, where we care more for the plight of criminals than the... [more]
article: OASIS ACADEMY MEDIACITYUK SALFORD SLATED BY OFSTED
Disappointing news. I trust them wot seek Salford's MP seat will demand improvements. In fact what better time than today to get ... [more]
article: OASIS ACADEMY MEDIACITYUK SALFORD SLATED BY OFSTED
Well let's face it that although it is supposedly a replacement of Hope High that it is in fact a replacement of the old Windsor H... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD COUNCIL BENDS TO CHILDRENS CENTRE CAMPAIGNS

Star date: 22nd July 2014

SURE START CENTRES SURVIVE AFTER PROTESTS AND THOUSANDS SIGNING PETITIONS

Campaigners fighting for their Children's Centre sites to stay, after the Council proposed to close them, have won a substantial victory following protests and petitions.

The Council wanted to close three centres in Irlam, Walkden and Lower Broughton but it has now agreed to keep two of the centres in operation - Fiddlers Lane in Irlam and River View in Lower Broughton… "The campaign definitely has made a difference!" says Bek, one of the Lower Broughton campaigners.

Full details here…

OASIS ACADEMY MEDIACITYUK SALFORD SLATED BY OFSTED

Star date: 22nd July 2014

CONTROVERSIAL OASIS ACADEMY INADEQUATE AND PUT IN SPECIAL MEASURES

Oasis Academy MediaCityUK has been absolutely slated by Ofsted which ruled it `inadequate' on every scale that it has… `Achievement of Pupils', `Quality of Teaching'; `Behaviour and Safety of Pupils', and `Leadership and Management'.

The controversial Academy, hailed as a `flagship' for Salford,  was at the centre of a riot a few years ago as pupils objected to the mass sacking of teachers half way through exam courses.

Full details here…

SALFORD PEOPLE SPEAK OUT AGAINST MEDIA STIGMA

Star date: 21st July 2014

BENEFIT STREETWISE SALFORD PEOPLE HIT BACK

As the ConDem Government and its media chums try to bracket everyone on benefits or in poverty as `a drain on society', a new group called NICE has got its voice and is hitting back.

Last Friday members of the group held a media briefing and panel discussion where some truths were told by those hardest hit by welfare `reforms' and Salford Council cuts. As ex-offender Tony said, "If no-one says nowt, nothing's going to change."

Full details here…

HAPPY MONDAYS CHICO’S KICKIN CANCER FUNDRAISER

Star date: 20th July 2014

MONDAYS, HOOKY, GRAEME PARK IN FUNDRAISING SPECTACULAR

Chico's Kickin Cancer Fundraising Dinner Ball
Friday 25th July
Palace Hotel

This Friday sees the maddest thing ever, as Happy Mondays, Hooky and co perform at a one-off extra posh black tie dinner at the Palace Hotel in Manchester.

It's a fundraiser for both The Christie Hospital and Chico, the 12 year old son of Happy Mondays' Salfordian bass player Paul Ryder, who's currently in the USA kicking Rhabdomyosarcoma, a rare soft tissue cancer.

Full details here…

THE NEED FOR SPEED IN SALFORD

Star date: 19th July 2014

£3MILLION WORTH OF CARS COME TO SALFORD  

"I wouldn't drive one 'cos everyone would look at you and think `What an idiot'"...

Cuts? Poverty? Hard times? What the hell! When three million quid's worth of in yer face supercars come to town it's hard not to gawp. So we grabbed our junior reporter, cranked up the Salford Star banger and crossed through security into MediaCityUK to stroke the obscenely priced petrol guzzlers.

Here's 14 year old Mikey K's report on the rich man's joy toys…

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx