Star date: 13th May 2011


"This report does highlight a number of missed opportunities to help this child" Gill Rigg, Chair of Salford's Safeguarding Board

The Salford Safeguarding Children Board Serious Case Review into the murder of 12 year old Tia Rigg has exposed yet another catalogue of disasters and failings by agencies that are supposed to protect the city's most vulnerable children.

Salford Council Chief Executive Barbara Spicer was ultimately responsible for many of the criticisms by the Board which looked into the case. So will Barbara Spicer resign?

Full story here…

"Between October 2009 and March 2010 there were 7 separate incidents… whereby the local authority should have responded to incidents regarding the children by making enquiries to enable them to decide whether to take action to safeguard or promote the child's welfare. The failure to take such action and to hold strategy meetings between the Police, Children's Social Care and other key agencies was a significant feature in this case."

12 year old Tia Rigg was murdered by her uncle in 2010, right in the middle of the fall-out from the scandal surrounding the failure of Salford Children's Services.

Jill Baker, Head of Salford Children's Services had recently been sacked; OFSTED criticisms of Salford Council's failure to protect vulnerable children were piling up – and the reassuring words of Salford Council Leader John Merry were still ringing around the corridors of the council chamber… "We've made considerable improvements and addressed particular issues and concerns"…

And then a 12 year old girl was murdered who was known to Salford Council as vulnerable - and was within the very category that should have seen these "considerable improvements" made. The Salford Safeguarding Children Board serious case review, released today, makes some severe criticisms of Salford Council and related agencies…

The Review states that "Although there was a significant amount of historical information* known about Adult A (Tia's mum), "that information was never adequately analysed and used appropriately to help gain an accurate understanding of the level of risk to the children". Neither was that information always shared between agencies… "This effectively meant that there was only a partial understanding by many agencies about the full extent of problems within the family".

The Review adds that "There was substantial evidence that the child protection plans that were in place in 2008-2009 were ineffective and never fully implemented. Consideration should have been made at this time to safeguarding the children through legal proceedings."

It gives the examples of "incidents relating to the children being left at home alone, increased levels of violence in the community, out of control drug use and increased examples of disturbed behaviour at school by Child H (Tia)" .

The most damning paragraph in the Review states that "Between October 2009 and March 2010 there were 7 separate incidents when Section 47 Enquiries under the Children Act 1989 should have been undertaken whereby the local authority should have responded to incidents regarding the children by making enquiries to enable them to decide whether to take action to safeguard or promote the child's welfare. The failure to take such action and to hold strategy meetings between the Police, Children's Social Care and other key agencies was a significant feature in this case."

It adds that "The combination of drugs misuse, domestic violence and parental mental health alongside historical factors should have led to a much higher level of concern than was seen in this case."

While the Review concludes that "the death of Child H was not predictable or preventable" it adds that "the ongoing harm to Child H because of the poor quality of care offered by her mother was both predictable and preventable, if Child H (and her siblings) had been removed from their mother's care in 2008-2009 through legal proceedings".

In other words, there was a complete failure of Salford Children's Services in safeguarding Tia Rigg. And this after all the reassurances coming from Salford Council in the wake of the Demi Leigh Mahon case and constant OFSTED criticism of Salford's safeguarding being `inadequate' (see here).

Jill Baker, Head of Children's Services, was sacked before this tragedy happened (see here). The accountable elected Lead Member for Children's Services , John Warmisham, has subsequently been `moved' to Adult Services, and a few months after this case came to light, Michael Kemp, head of Salford's Child Protection Service resigned (see here

Yet, throughout all the safeguarding disasters at Salford Council one person with direct responsibility is still in post – Chief Executive Barbara Spicer.

Back in 2006, Salford Council drew up a list of exact roles and responsibilities for Safeguarding Children, and included the role of the Chief Executive

"Make sure statutory inter-agency arrangements are in place…and ensure there is an open culture between local agencies and good direct communications between senior managers so that they accept and address concerns brought to their attention" (click here for further information)

The Serious Case Board makes 105 recommendations for improvements across children's services, ranging from Salford Children's Social Care to Greater Manchester Police, to Salford Education to Great Places Housing Group. Many of the main recommendations cover the specific failures associated with Salford City Council Chief Executive's exact roles and responsibilities.

We asked Salford Council if Barbara Spicer will be resigning. It has been met with no response.

The Salford Star last called for Barbara Spicer's resignation in December 2009 after Jill Baker was sacked (see here) in the aftermath of the Demi Leigh case. How many more cases of inadequacy will it take before this highly paid official (see here) takes some responsibility?

Gill Rigg, Chair of Salford's Safeguarding Board said: "This report does highlight a number of missed opportunities to help this child and it is important all of the agencies involved learn from this so they can better protect children living in Salford.

"In Salford we have already implemented a multi agency action plan that is being monitored by the Safeguarding Board to ensure these changes happen. A lot has already been achieved but we are continuing to work to ensure all children living in the city are fully protected from harm."

John Merry, Leader of Salford City Council added: ""This is a tragic case and our thoughts remain with this child's family. No-one could have predicted what happened to her when she visited her uncle that day, but we know more could have been done during her childhood to support her in coping with her unstable home life.

"However, even if this child has been removed from her home, she would not have been prevented from having contact with her family as there was no indication she was at risk from her uncle and therefore no reason to stop her having access to him and other members of the extended family. Removing her from her home would therefore not have prevented her death.

"The serious case review has made a number of recommendations on what we need to do to improve safeguarding in Salford. We have already taken these recommendations very seriously and the feedback we have had from Ofsted is that we have a good grasp of what improvements needed to be made and we are making good progress with implementing them. This was further supported by a recent unannounced inspection from Ofsted which showed a marked improvement in this area.

"But I know we still have work to do and we are committed to continuing to improve the service we provide to protect children and young people living in Salford."

See the Executive Report of the Salford Safeguarding Children Board into this case: click here

* Historical information…
• Tia was placed on the Child Protection Register in a different local authority before she was even born, and was later, firstly categorised as "likely to suffer neglect", and then "likely to suffer physical abuse" due to her parental background.

• Tia was deregistered before she moved to Salford but a first visit by a Salford health visitor in 2000 revealed that her home had "no cooking facilities" and "no heating".

• In mid 2008, Tia's mother tried to commit suicide three times in front of her children. Tia and her three siblings were put on the Child Protection Register and Tia was looked after by her aunt for a few months but was returned to her mother after a "conflict".  This was supposed to be "an emergency measure" but "an absence of appropriate planning meant that this move became permanent".

• In May 2009 a Child Protection Review Conference made the decision to discontinue protection for the children… "This was a flawed decision and based on inaccurate information given to the Review Conference about the progress that Adult A (Tia's mum) was making".

• Throughout 2009 the Review states that there were … "Incidents of violence between family members, Continued problems with Adult A's illicit drug use, Incidents of the children being left `home alone', Child H (Tia) being given too much responsibility for looking after the younger children, Accommodation problems and Adult A's lack of cooperation with agencies"



Chloe julie good wrote
at 11:49:07 PM on Thursday, February 1, 2018
How does the head of child protection get to resign so he michael kemp can just move on with no stigma attached and later get roe as head of sen in rochdale, where kids who have ehc plans are cheated out of correct provision. These peole should not be allowed to get jobs supposedly supporting vulnerable kids ever again
Michael F in Felse wrote
at 5:02:14 AM on Sunday, January 3, 2016
@susan, I agree. I want every Council employee to be trained in safeguarding young children and vulnerable adults. I took that qualification with a Sports Lead Body. Essential for public servants to understand and to be skilled in this most important area. Having the lasting trauma from me being abused at age 9, 13 and 15 it is my priority to safeguard all young people.
susan hindle wrote
at 4:05:38 AM on Saturday, January 2, 2016
Some social workers need more training and need to get facts right before they act upon things and duty social workers need to do there jobs properly
anthony wrote
at 1:22:54 PM on Monday, May 16, 2011
The safeguarding of children is a statutory provision. It appears the voluntary agency involved has been involved in part of this statutory provision. However it also appears reading between the lines of the SCR that the observations of the staff from the voluntary agency were not recognised as having any impact on statutory overview. In short it appears that the voluntary organisation was not recognised in professional proceedings. SCC Ccannot pass on statutory provision to charitable organisations and then expect to share responsibility when it all goes wrong. When I am shopping in Manchester we are constantly approached by the likes of NSPCC, whose in attempting to secure a donation ask "would I like to help abused children" My answer is "of course, but I do not think charities should be responsible for doing the work the government has a healthy budget for" We are not yet a third world country so we should not have to rely on street collectors to keep children safe. It appears in this case (again) there is a lack of communications between agencies. Warmisham, Merry and Spicer now must have a higher intelligence than before as once again "Lessons have been learned" I have witnessed the intelligence of Warmisham, he cannot deviate from his prepared speeches as he has not got the nous to enter debate or come up with intelligent argument. Why he has continued to progress within the council is beyond my own intelligence. Grow a pair resign and stop taking money that this city can ill afford. Shame on these greedy grabbers who will continue as normal.
Bob Floiwers wrote
at 5:56:25 AM on Sunday, May 15, 2011
Spicer. merry and the rest of this gang of cretins should be joining the dole queue ,like me . Only difference is that I am decent,honest and honorable
Stick2twitter wrote
at 5:56:16 AM on Sunday, May 15, 2011
Amazing that when stories come up on here that are really bad, that Merry and Warmisham dont seem to read them. The only time Warmisham put up a comment was when someone put up a playful comment saying "what a pity the intelligent sperm were poor swimmers". Obviously Merry and Warmisham read the Salford star but maybe they have filters on so they don't see the really bad stuff? Didn't Warmisham get drunk a couple of years ago and send a racist comment to twitter by mistake? As they do not comment on things like this I think that the star should not post any more comments at all from them. Let the tweet away and get out the rose tinted specs for the LIFE magazine.
Mary Ferrer wrote
at 6:03:24 AM on Saturday, May 14, 2011
Over the last 4/5 years I have watched what has been happening within childrens services and again they have let another child down. I have just read the story in the MEN and the comments from the leader of Salford council John Merry,it was just like reading the comments over the case review of Demi Lea Mahom. When will someone take charge of our childrens services? In the last 3 years, 2 children have died and one has been looked up for murder all because our childrens services can't do the job.These children did not just appear, their problems had been brought to the attenting of Childrens services over and over and they did little or nothing. A few years ago the goverment were going to take over the running of this service and nothing happened,Mr Merry and Ms Spicer went to London and must have painted a very rosey picture and promised the earth,but we all know very little changed. About this time, 2008 Councillor Merry and Barbara Spicer took over the running of Childrens services and what happened it went from adequate to inadequate and it was while these 2 plus Warmisham were in charge of Childrens services that another 4 Children slippend through the net, because not only was Tia in danger, her brothers and sisters were also in danger. Read the life these children have had to put up with, if this was happening to an animal it would be removed and the person up in court,but it was not an animal it was happening to young children and the people in charge could not or would not take charge and do what they are there to do. LOOK AFTER THE MOST VUNERABLE MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY. I just hope that NOW someone takes charge who does care and will act when family,friends, neighbours police and other agencies tell them there is a big problem within a family. We must not allow this to happen again. When I was a Councillor, we were told "we were all corporate parents" I am now asking ALL our councillors what ever party, not to allow this to happen again and for each and everyone of you to take charge. Do not allow this to be brushed under the carpet. I also feel someone somewhere within this council should be made accountable for what has been allowed to happen to these children. How many more Children out there in Salford are also suffering like Tia and her brothers and sisters and nothing is being done???
Bunty Harding wrote
at 2:19:58 AM on Saturday, May 14, 2011
This pathetic clowncil , and their army of overpaid executives are incapable of getting anything right .What are we paying this gang of clowns for ? Sack them all .
Edgar Spendler wrote
at 10:33:42 AM on Friday, May 13, 2011
Spicer must be sacked NOW. Scary Spicer's obscenely grossly overpaid 'executive ' status is untenable .
Please enter your comment below:
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
Recent comments
I could name three from my ward that should be culled.... [more]
Is it possible the Star could get a hold of the facts and figures of how many times the Council has challenged developers (if at a... [more]
Here's an idea. On May 3rd you have a vote. Find out which councillor is on your side and vote for them. If they support this deve... [more]
Sorry if my little piece is slightly off, it's with me pissing my self reading Mr Dennett's love child complaining of bullying. T... [more]
Hi Paul. I lived for my first 8 or so years on Pine Street off Hough Lane in Lower Broughton (1966-74) All very long gone obvious... [more]


Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome


More articles...


Star date: 22nd April 2018


Yesterday, former miners, families and trade unionists gathered at the Agecroft Colliery monument to pay respects to those who lost their lives down the pits...

"Today means everything, it's the only way we can pay back what they did for you" said Jackie Rimmer, whose father died down Agecroft Colliery in 1963.

Full details here...


Star date: 22nd April 2018


Salford City FC became champions of the National League North yesterday, despite losing 2-1 to Boston United. Harrogate Town's defeat at Bradford Park Avenue means that no-one can now catch the Class of '92 club.

Full details here...


Star date: 22nd April 2018


An exhibition of ninety wood carvings, featuring everything from birds to animals, to wood spirits and politicians, has opened at the Salford Unemployed and Community Resource Centre.

The exhibition will kickstart a new Salford Unemployed Arts Club based at the Centre, where anyone who is unemployed or disabled can meet and try wood carving or any other creative activity.

Full details here...


Star date: 22nd April 2018


This week saw a trial 'clean comedy' night at The Vine Cafe in Irlams O' Th' Height, with five comics wowing the sold out venue, and not a swear word or lewd reference in earshot...

"It had to be right kind of acts" explained organiser Sally Griffiths, as the mix of new performers and professionals pulled off the clean comedy night with aplomb (ooh, er, missus...).

Full details here...


Star date: 21st April 2018


The name of the band kind of describes the sound of Cosmic Shambles, a band that released its debut single, All Over Now, via Salford City Radio. The Shambles range from grungy to psychedelia, as Ian Leslie discovers...

Full details here...


written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx