Star date: 11th January 2011



`You've given a £22m loan to the Salford Reds stadium, £3million to the BBC, £150,000 to opera at The Lowry and things – now when you come along and say `We're going to have to cut this service or that service', what do you think people are going to say?'

Over the last decade, Salford's had hundreds of millions of pounds of public money pumped into its regeneration – so where's it all gone? And why is Salford Council still funding prestige projects around MediaCityUK while making savage cuts to public services?

Here, Salford Star's editor quizzes Salford Council Leader John Merry about all this and more…


Two days before Christmas, Salford City Council Leader, John Merry, agreed to an hour long interview with Salford Star editor, Stephen Kingston, to talk about the state of Salford and the upcoming £40million+ cuts. The session went on for over two hours and covered everything from the Salford City Reds stadium deal to Tesco, to the Council's control of community media, to the whole of the city's regeneration.

In this first part we look at whether Salford is developing a two tier city – on one hand money being pumped into prestige projects like MediaCityUK, opera at The Lowry and a new stadium for Salford City Reds, while on the other hand there's a hidden poverty stricken Salford.

We've kept the interview almost unedited, and only changed a few things for legibility.

`Don't you think you'd be better off spending £3million on a bus to Media City?'

Stephen Kingston (SK): When it was the General Election I was getting interviewed by media all over the place saying, `Well the Labour Government hasn't done much for Salford has it?'. I was saying `Well actually that's not quite true because the Labour Government put hundreds of millions of pounds into Salford' – the problem hasn't been the Labour Government because it did put the money in but if you walk around the place, nothing has happened. God knows where that money has gone…

John Merry (JM): I don't accept that. I think changes have taken place and I think on the whole the changes are for the better. If I came in with my statistical report about the new houses that have been built, about the new people who have been brought into Salford and about the fact that we've managed to keep, on the whole, the existing population - because the population of Salford, for the first time, is showing an increase.
SK: It's all very well bringing in new people to dilute the figures - because that's exactly what's happened and they've admitted it…*
JM: Sorry, `dilute the figures', I don't quite get that…
SK: `Dilute the figures' basically means that if you've got poverty on a mass scale and you bring in so-called economically active people, then those people will push down the percentage of things like poor education, health…

JM: Well that's not what I'm looking at. I'm looking at things like improving our schools which did need improving in some respects. And I've been looking at the action we've been taking to improve the proportion of people who are economically active in terms of people who are economically inactive at the moment because that's what I want to try and achieve in Salford.

There's a video that the BNP made which consists of all the Lowry paintings and it said `This is what Salford Council is trying to destroy' – and I actually plead guilty. I am trying to destroy the idea of kids with rickets in the streets, outside toilets and all the rest of it. I want Salford to be a prosperous place for everybody and that's what I'm trying to create
SK: But child poverty levels are 60% (see here)...
JM: Yes but we've just been through a very difficult period
SK: This was happening before that…
JM: We were showing that the percentage of people unemployed was coming down and all the rest of it
SK: The poverty figures and employment statistics we use are your figures (see here)
JM: I can show you other statistics which show an enormous increase in attainment in terms of our young people, an enormous increase in terms of young people going onto university, staying on at 16, all that is actually happening. And the fact remains that what I want to try and achieve is to extend that to everyone to make sure that there are opportunities for everybody.

I can't do that by saying that Salford simply has to stay the same, as I keep repeating to you, and you keep not taking the bait. £8million a year coming into Salford as a result of regeneration activity, £8m in council tax a year, which is £8m a year I can spend on Adult Social Care which I couldn't have spent if the money wasn't coming in.

SK: Come March, or before March, you're going to hold your hands up and say `The Tory Government has cut all the money, we're in a recession, help…'
JM: I'm going to say what this Tory Government is doing to the people of Salford and you'll agree with us as well…
SK: Come March you're going to be saying that there's no more money but then you're going to be writing a cheque out to the BBC Philharmonic Orchestra for £3million plus a cheque for opera at the Lowry for £150,000 (see here)
JM: Well wait and see, yeah…
SK: You've given a £22m loan to the Salford Reds stadium, £3million to the BBC, £150,000 to opera at The Lowry and things – now when you come along and say `We're going to have to cut this service or that service', what do you think people are going to say?
JM: Let's deal with them one by one. Yes we are giving £150,000 on commissioning a world famous opera or whatever you want to call it…
SK: I'm not getting at the actual production
JM: Exactly, and I think it will be something that will actually help in terms of promoting the International Festival and promoting the BBC and promoting Salford in particular. And what we're trying to do…
SK: But if you're going to have to close down this or that or the other, and you're supporting opera…
JM: This is the fundamental difference between us, and I'm always quite surprised by it. I think the BBC coming to Salford is going to make an enormous difference to the local economy of Salford. You don't think so do you?
SK: We're not against it and have never said that, just the way it's being done…
JM: I don't think you're against it but I don't think you think that it will have the effect I think it's actually going to have, a galvanising affect…
SK: I think that MediaCityUK is going to be an island and everything I've seen so far shows that – you can't even get a bus there. Wouldn't you be better off spending £3million on a bus?
JM: We actually want to make money out of the BBC's link with Salford, of course we do, and we think that this is an investment that is worthwhile in order to bring the BBC to Salford, and I think we're already beginning to see that. I know you said the Coronation Street studio is not coming but everything else is coming to Media City – the BBC, new properties are being built as we speak on the Quays which bring in council tax.

I was optimistic that we'd get the business rates from the properties on the Quays, the government didn't give us it but Eric Pickles says he is going to give us the business rates from new properties. But even if we don't, the employment opportunity that has been created will bring Salford people jobs. You challenged me about the 1500 jobs – I produced statistics to show the 1500

SK: We put it on the website and got comments about loads of people from East Europe working there – did they all have Salford addresses?
JM: Whatever, the fact remains that I'm telling you 1500 people with Salford addresses were working on that site and I'm telling you that there will be thousands eventually who will be working at Media City – and people like yourself will benefit from it. I'll come back to you in ten year's time and ask you if you've benefitted
SK: Ten years? I'll probably be dead by then given the mortality rates here…
JM: Ok five years time, and ask you if you've benefitted from the BBC being down here because I think you will.
SK: Not me. Maybe my kids but I can't see that and neither can they....

`Let's take Ordsall...'

SK: If you look at where all the Council's resources are going you've got the Ordsall Waterfront, Irwell River Park , the greening of Guy Fawkes St – a ridiculous amount of money, over £200,000
JM: Look, we get a lot of money in additional grants and the fact remains that all of that will bring economic development along that front.
SK: What you've got in Ordsall…
JM: Actually LPC [developers] have got a good reputation in Ordsall when I talk to people down there – have you not found that?
SK: What I'm trying to say is that people will see...particularly in Ordsall, you've got a triangle and around the outside you've got multi coloured houses and the waterfront and all that, and the new Oasis Academy and Media City on the other side. But in the middle of all that you've got one of the most deprived communities, certainly in Salford. It's almost like you're hiding them in the middle…(see here
JM: I want to see them benefit from the activity that's going on around them – I don't see it as hiding them. I see them as being part of what is being created down there and I don't think LPC think otherwise either. I think Warren [Smith- chairman of LPC Living] is absolutely committed to the idea of Ordsall as a place and trying to promote that
SK: On one hand you're going `Cuts cuts cuts, it's going to be awful' and on the other all this money is going towards these prestige projects.
JM: Let's take Ordsall for example. Yes the fact that we're having these cuts is awful but we can get access to some money still for capital development to take place so we can't just stop that. If we stop that then Salford stops growing and Salford will go backwards and that's what we're concerned about. So no, I don't think it's contradictory. I think it's part and parcel of what we're trying to do – we're trying to give the place a future in the end.

`Let's look at the Salford Reds Stadium...'

SK: Let's look at the Salford Reds Stadium - you've given it land worth £6.7m, a £22m loan, and the North West Development Agency has given them £4m for land remediation…that's over £30m quid, yeah?
JM: Right
SK: The £22m loan is unsupported borrowing or prudential borrowing but Salford is now up to its peak of unsupported borrowing – is it £100m?
JM: Something quite high…
SK: …but the government was saying on the telly the other night – `Oh councils can always use their unsupported borrowing to get their way out of the recession'
JM: Yea
SK: Yet now you've got no slack at all
JM: No – that's perfectly true but can I just explain on the unsupported borrowing, right, we're expecting the stadium company to reimburse us for that unsupported borrowing, so they will be paying…
SK: You're assuming people are going to go and watch them… [more on this later]

"Do we look at reduced opening hours or do we even close the odd sports centre or the odd library to actually make the saving?"

SK: So when the cuts come and you have to make a decision…
JM: We've made £19m of decisions already and I'm moving onto the next stage of it now. In the £19m there are things that are a reduced level of service for things like recycling, cutting back only once a month. There's a number of people who have taken early voluntary retirement. And all of the stuff we've been providing for support in schools, an awful lot of that is at risk, because the government has cut back on Area Based Grants.

All of that work, and a lot of work we've been doing on diversionary activity on law and order the government has cut all that, and we're trying to see what we can rescue from the wreckage. So there's some huge tranches that have already gone and what we're trying to do is, having got that £19m, is we're going to have to go for the next £21m.

Some of those things you might welcome. Things like cutting back on marketing and cutting back on some of the events we sponsor, all of that will have to go. But even when I take that out it's still a drop in the ocean in comparison to what is actually going to happen at this next stage.

And there are things like social care – how do we wrestle with the dilemma of social care, because I know you've said that parts of this have been a crap service (see here) and I do agree incidentally that we've not provided the best possible service in all of the providers that we've used. But nevertheless the criteria that we use…Let's take Trafford, for example. Trafford only deal with severe and critical cases, we deal with people who have moderate problems which means we start at a far lower base in terms of intervention than Trafford. And I think that's right. And I'm fighting like mad to keep that to see what economies we can make to keep it.

The decisions we're going to have to take are `What are we going to do about the youth service? What about social care? What do we do about what remains of the support we provide for schools? What do we do about cleaning the streets? What do we do about environmental health?' All those are questions that we're pondering at the moment.

SK: I've seen a letter from Salford Community Leisure talking of 30% reduction in libraries and sports?
JM: We've taken a chunk of money out and the question is what does that mean? Do we look at reduced opening hours or do we even close the odd sports centre or the odd library to actually make the saving?
SK: The mobile library?
JM: I'd like to keep it going but again it's something that's problematic. One thing we've done is cut back 10% on community committee budgets
SK: Again, people are going to say that you've cut back on social care yet you're giving the BBC orchestra £3m – have you cut back on that?
JM: It's one of the things we are discussing at the moment. There is a change in the sponsorship arrangement, wait and see.
SK: You've cut £100,000 off The Lowry – and then given £150,000 for an opera there. So what would you say to people in Salford about the government cuts?

JM: They said we'd only have to cut by 8.9% this year. It's nonsense because they also took off something called the Area Based Grant. They chopped all of that with a few exceptions so our cuts look like 11.5-12% this year and that's where the real damage has been done. And basically if you look at that compared to say Surrey – Surrey is getting a rise in its income and we're getting a 12% cut.

SK: You're going to lose quite a lot of money personally from this because a lot of the quangos where you were a paid director have been chopped.
JM: I'm not complaining about what I lose personally and at the Council I don't think I've seen a pay rise for three years. One of the things we're looking at, for example, is car parking charges for staff and we're going to relate it to people's ability to be able to pay.  And I will pay more for that, so yes there is a significant loss of income for me too.
SK: Sad…

* Countryside Properties, in its planning application for `New Broughton' stated quite clearly that "By introducing more market housing, which is generally occupied by a greater proportion of economically active people, there is likely to be an overall improvement in the health of the residential population of the area."
Does the health of the people who used to live in `Old Broughton' improve? No. Do the statistics improve? Yes. It's called diluting a community and its problems. (taken from Salford Star Dec 2009 see here)

Photo of John Merry at MediaCityUK with Peter Mandelson, Hazel Blears, John Whittaker (Peel Holdings), Brian Gray (MediaCityUK) and apprentices, by Steven Speed

See The John Merry Interview: Part 2 here

The John Merry Interview Part 3 here

The Truth wrote
at 18:26:22 on 25 February 2011
Just thought I would post on here and ask John Merry or other council big wigs what they think of the story of BBC breakfast moving to Salford? It is stated that "up to 50% of staff are undecided about moving to Manchester (not even Salford?) and I quote "the ill feeling is so bad among staff that they have arranged a "Salford or F... it" party on March 31-the last day they have to make a decision"
Brian Francis Kirkham wrote
at 04:47:55 on 26 January 2011
I think its high time people woke up to what's happening in parts of this city. Mr Merry and his team have been playing (on their respective computers) and thought what next for the people of Salford. Its something reminiscent of the Age of Empires game - Land Grab Yes, Ordsall still exists, much to chagrin of the councillors in Swinton. Whilst they've been living peaceful lives developing the other side of the road, they sold off major parts of the council estate or let the rest go to rack and ruin. When the private developers were planning their scheme they grabbed as much land as they possibly could - knocking down major parts of the estate as they could lay their hands on. A lack of policing at the time aided their cause. It didn't matter about those living there, crime was rife due to a few kids thinking they were the Next Big Thing - the people moved on and developers got their plot of land (seriously, I would love to know how much was paid for it!!!) They did up a few houses - very well IMHO - but then you look at the masterplan - new school - inspired! paid in part by the developers - on the site of the Old Estate. Napier Green - where my late Grandad once lived has been given a lick of paint...Too late for him i'm afraid but hey , at least it's colourful. And the rest of the plan? A bit much of a patchwork Quilt, where once the public was talking of a new health centre, I read on billboards a Morrison Supermarket is being put there. If that's going there What's happening to the remains of Robert Hall St? AKA the district centre? If there's one saving grace for all of this - The Hall remains in place and actually being conserved... This is a GOOD Thing. However, Mr Merry - I humbly suggest you walk down that stretch of land between the two schools - Its something akin to walking between the two halves of the Berlin wall! Actually if you could just fix the pavements where you left off - it would be a start
Watering The Town Hall Flowers ...£££ wrote
at 06:36:27 on 16 January 2011
May I ask if John Merry will clarify the process and cost of Watering the Town Hall flowers in Swinton ? It is evident that Salford City Council uses private contrac£ors to Water these flowers with a water tank behind a Nissan Navara Pickup truck. How much does this cost per year £xx ? Whats wrong with a hosepipe or rain? Is it for Elf'n'safety reasons? So are the flowers going to be abandoned during this period of austerity? ..and it's not very eco friendly is it ? Its shameless that you allow other parts of salford particularly Pendleton to severely deteriorate whilst atthe same time using extravagent methods of watering these town hall flower beds.
haveuheardowt wrote
at 17:23:12 on 15 January 2011
http://www.ukwheeliebins.com/wheelie-bins.html A bit more than that Albert.
Albert wrote
at 11:59:29 on 15 January 2011
The bins cost around £27 when I enquired 18 months ago. Even so, why would you crush £27?
haveuheardowt wrote
at 15:14:24 on 12 January 2011
I have two general waste wheelie bins,i only put the two out about three times a year such has after xmas or if i have a clear out.Anyway i put the two out this morning,the bin men turned up,emptied the two bins then threw one of the bins into the crusher of the bin wagon.I asked the bin man why he had crushed one of my bins, he said "your only allowed one bin". Now thats fair enough but im guessing that a wheelie bin costs at least £200 quid a go,i told a few people of my experience abd they said it's happened to them or they knew someone it had happened to.So what i'd like to know is it council policy to literally crush at least £200 quid nilywilly.
Bad Wolf wrote
at 18:11:42 on 11 January 2011
It looks to me like all Salford do is to keep applying for different pots of money. I wonder if all the things that they are pumping money into will end up like the Celtic Tiger, where grants were given and a lot of business,s followed the grants? The grants stopped and the business moved on. Ireland also had the house bulding boom and that has gone bust as well. Is all this just "feet of clay"? Pumping money into the flashy stuff and forgetting the basics?
T.J. Chakotai wrote
at 18:11:37 on 11 January 2011
Well none of what John Merry said made any sense to me. The real facts are that social housing within the Salford area, has gone down hill fast. The Chapel Street development that never happened. I think that John Merry should spend a whole winter in a social high rise flat i.e. Canon Hussey Court, and be put on Means Tested Benefit, throughout the period he stays at that flat, and he will learn very quickly, that life in Salford for people living in Social Housing, is no laughing matter. All of the financial statistics in the whole of Salford, is not going to change that fact. In general the Salford Council have cut back on many of the Social Housing Services so things would now appear to look even worse for low income family's. So John Merry, lets stop spending money on things that may make Salfords financial and social pecentages look good, and start spending it on what counts the most. Yes Mr. Merry spend it on the very people whom live in the City of Salford.
Andy Walker wrote
at 17:20:26 on 11 January 2011
Shame you didnt ask John Merry about the pain he and countryside properties have created for first time buyers and council tenants who have moved into the worst built propertys in "new broughton".
Please enter your comment below:
Salford Star CD
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
Recent comments
He who controls history controls the future. And like fellow old boy Mike Leigh says, this is our history. This film will no doubt... [more]
Slurp,your comments about "rabble and dross",matches exactly what the upper classes said about working people in 1819! I hope you... [more]
Interesting review, but why the casual, stereotyping racism about'yanks'? I'm sure a few Americans will like this film, just as... [more]
It's a pity the Manchester and Salford Yeomanry aren't still around. They could sort out all the rabble and dross that plague Picc... [more]
Dear Sir I wish to help with the cause of Save the Crown Theatre in Eccles. At the moment, I have no money to give but I would ... [more]


Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome


More articles...


Star date: 19th October 2018


Three earth tremors have been recorded by the British Geological Survey near where Cuadrilla has begun fracking in Fylde..."The problem for Cuadrilla is that if it carries on regardless, bigger earthquakes may well be triggered" says David Smythe, Emeritus Professor of Geophysics at the University of Glasgow.

Full details here...


Star date: 19th October 2018


EDL Protest
Saturday 20th October 12:30pm
Piccadilly Gardens, Manchester

Having abandoned plans to march in Didsbury this weekend, the fascist EDL is instead holding a rally in Manchester tomorrow, and Stand Up To Racism and Unite Against Fascism have called for a counter demonstration, backed by politicians and trade unions... "The EDL are never welcome in our city" says Kate Green MP "We stand together against division and hate."

Full details here...


Star date: 18th October 2018


Peterloo, the movie, starring Maxine Peake, was premiered in Manchester last night at Home. The Salford Star was not invited but we did manage a non-exclusive twenty second interview with Salford director Mike Leigh on the red carpet, and a viewing at the peasants' overflow on Deansgate. Is it any good? Read our review and that crucial interview with Mike Leigh.

Full review here...


Star date: 17th October 2018


As Theresa May was locked in Brexit talks in Brussels, this morning Salford City Council, Bellway Homes and Swinton residents' Saving Our Neighbourhood group were meeting to try and resolve horrendous problems around the Campbell Road natural green space, where the developer is attempting to build 241 houses.

The Council and Bellway have been brought to the table after constant protests by residents..."I think that's the only way we're going to get anywhere" said Barry Woodling of Saving Our Neighbourhood as residents demonstrated yet again outside the Civic Centre.

Full details here...


Star date: 16th October 2018


Salford and Eccles MP, Rebecca Long-Bailey, slated the Tory Government in Parliament yesterday, pointing out "What a terrible irony it is that the first day of Green Great Britain Week is the day that fracking is due to commence..."

Today, Vivienne Westwood performed a break dance to Abba's Dancing Queen on Cuadrilla's 'draconian injunction line' outside the Preston New Road site in a dig at Theresa May's hopeless jig at the Tory conference and to stand up for the right to protest.

Full details here...


written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx