HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US   LINKS      
 

 
SALFORD ROYAL HOSPITAL MATERNITY CLOSURE
 

Star date: 2nd November 2010
A Salford Star Exclusive

SALFORD DOCTORS BACK HOPE CLOSURE DESPITE SAFETY CONCERNS

It looks like Salford's doctors are supporting the closure of Hope Maternity Unit even though they have concerns about "arrangements for safe transfer of patients" from Salford to other units.

In papers seen by the Salford Star before the meeting to discuss Hope's fate, the doctors are reported as stating that despite these safety concerns the decision to shut the Maternity Unit is the "right one for women and children in Greater Manchester".

So far, not one single doctor in Salford has accepted an invitation by the Keep Hope Maternity Open campaign to discuss the decision face to face.

Full story here…


SALFORD DOCTORS ABORT HOPE MATERNITY UNIT

In the ironically named `Making It Better' programme which is attempting to shut Salford Royal Hospital's Maternity Unit, health bosses at the NHS have produced their evidence for the Government's review in support of the decision.

Making It Better had to meet four tests for the review, one of which was `Support From GP Commissioners', or Salford's doctors. This was "explicity sought" by the Government and, according to papers seen by the Salford Star… "GP commissioner bodies agreed that the Making It Better model of care was the right one for women and children in Greater Manchester".

This was despite doctors raising concerns about "arrangements for safe transfer of patients" and the "sustainability of the workforce". The doctors' bodies appeared to be putting finance above safety, as they had "concerns over high costs of backtracking on the original decision".

As reported in the Salford Star last week (see here), the GP commissioner body for Salford – the Salford and Trafford Local Medical Committee - has tried to distance itself from the Hope Maternity closure by submitting a letter in response to the review stating that health bosses "must make it clear that it was not Salford GPs who led the decision to close consultant led maternity services".

These new papers show that doctors have now clearly supported that decision. Furthermore, not one single Salford doctor has accepted an invitation to meet with Keep Hope Maternity Open group to explain their stance. An e-mail sent to the Salford and Trafford Local Medical Committee (LMC) by the Salford Star, asking it to explain its decision on the Hope closure has also met with no response. And neither did the LMC show up at last week's Keep Hope Maternity Open meeting where the issues and evidence were discussed.

Health bosses have also, apparently, pulled out of a meeting with midwives and mums from the Keep Hope Maternity Open group due for Wednesday evening. Yet Part 2 of the Government review `Tests' was for "strengthened patient and public engagement"…

"The campaign group are extremely disappointed that they have been exempt from these meetings and that their concerns appear to have gone ignored" says Heather Rawlinson "We will be pressing Mr Lansley [Government Minister] to honour his promise of `no decisions about me without me'. The criteria he mentioned was that the public should be supportive and the public are not in this case."

The papers seen by the Salford Star merely state that health bosses "recognise the concerns of local people who are particularly affected by the changes."

Apart from the clinical evidence (Test 3) presented by the Keep Hope Maternity Open group at last week's meeting, mums and midwives were constantly making the point about both the travel implications of having to go to Manchester, Warrington or Bolton for maternity care, their safety concerns related to this and the fact that they wanted their babies to be born in Salford. Test 4 of the review was about "Patient Choice"…

The papers state that while it is "recognised that not all Greater Manchester families will have their first choice of service, it is clear that location is but one factor, and not the most important factor, in the selection of services"…

As midwives and mums pointed out last week, the location is infinitely tied in with safety. A point that was also made by the doctors themselves with their concerns about "arrangements for safe transfer of patients" from Salford to other units.

In the end, however, doctors appear to have put cost as the most important factor. Yet the `reconfiguration of services in Greater Manchester' doesn't come cheap.

"In this current economic climate" says Heather Rawlinson "a spending bill of £120 million with a further £41million seems excessive when money can be saved by retaining the first class service delivered at Salford Royal."

Unless something dramatic happens, and Ryan Giggs weaves some hospital wing magic in his support of the Keep Hope Maternity Open campaign, it looks like the decision to shut Hope will be ratified. It will leave Salford with just a small midwife led birth unit, which will only allow an estimated 20% of Salford babies to be born here.

It's just what the Salford doctors have ordered…

The decision on Hope Maternity was supposed to take place on Wednesday but the Star has now learnt that it has been postponed until December 1st, pending more reports. So there's still plenty of time to `Dog Your Doctor'...

See the `Dog Your Doctor' campaign here

See previous Salford Star feature here


See also www.keephopematernityopen.com

Photo by Gareth Lyons

 

dave morrison wrote
at 5:05:38 PM on Saturday, November 06, 2010
I left a comment that the final decision to close hope had been put back to the 1st of december, why was the decision "leaked" to the manchester evening news on saturday the 6th of november. this is a common tactic to release bad news when the general public are looking the other way . if the tragady in Irlam had not happened I dont think this would have "leaked" out. it shows what contempt the decision makers hold for the people of Salford Bury and Rochdale. the group fighting to keep hope maternity open needs the help of Salford people. I will do my part , come on Salford people get involved, show these arrogant bean counters that behind a page full of numbers its real people,s lives that will be affected for this and generations to come . save the salfordian......
 
dave morrison wrote
at 12:41:45 AM on Thursday, November 04, 2010
I have just learnt that the final decision to close hope hospital maternity and neonatal unit has been put back until 1st december. this is our last chance to let the decision makers know that to close hope is wrong, go to the keephopematernityopen .com web site ,its a user group opposed to the closure. dont forget once its gone its gone for good . come on mums,dads,grandparents get involved save our city. dont put future babies lives at risk , keep maternity services local...
 
dave morrison wrote
at 10:27:33 AM on Tuesday, November 02, 2010
this decision is wrong, anyone with any brains can see this. because of the longer distance to travel a baby or mother or possibly both will die , they said it will save babies lives ( not salford babies ). hope is in the top ten performing maternity and neonatal units in the country. which decision makers name do parents in salford put on the court papers when there baby dies . the government need to step in and reverse the closure. it really is time for the people of salford to contact there doctor and MPs , go to the keephopematernityopen site , it has a letter you can use , its very good. its never to late , we cant let this happen , where are the councillors what are they doing . its up to us the people of salford. 40,000 people have signed petitions to keep it open, if not our city will die, will the last one to leave please turn out the lights.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Chloride open day
Salford Star contact details
Deli Lama
Salford Star photo stories
Cornerstone advert
Mary Burns Publishing
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SALFORD PHOTO ARCHIVE GIVEAWAY
I was born in Auckland street Whit lane and went to Wellington street School my maiden name was Perry and went to St George's Chu... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL HOUSING TRANSFER VOTE NEARS WITH RENT HIKES ON THE AGENDA
Dear Dr Sharples, I have read what you have typed, however you have contradicted yourself that many times, your comments have now ... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL FOLLOWS TORY HOUSING POLICY ON STOCK TRANSFER
dr Steven Sharpels have you suffered at the hands of Salix homes answer yes or no...... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL FOLLOWS TORY HOUSING POLICY ON STOCK TRANSFER
It's unbelievable that the transfer is costing over £3million! I wonder how much of this is going to consultants. Once the stock h... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL FOLLOWS TORY HOUSING POLICY ON STOCK TRANSFER
Dear Dr Sharples, as always, your inappropriate conduct is confusing me. You state that the Salford Star is printing information t... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD TALENT SHINES FOR ALAN HENNING

Star date: 31st October 2014

BROUGHTON STAGES TALENT SHOWCASE

Last night, at St James Church in Higher Broughton, a talent showcase was staged featuring everyone from May Aston, who's been singing for fifty years, to young local rapper Stephen Miller.

Altogether over a dozen acts took part and all the money raised from donations on the night is set to go to the family of Alan Henning. Great evening, great cause...

Full details here...

SALFORD COUNCIL FOLLOWS TORY HOUSING POLICY ON STOCK TRANSFER

Star date: 30th October 2014

PUBLIC MONEY PRIVATE GAIN – THE IDEOLOGICAL ATTACK ON SALFORD'S SOCIAL HOUSING

The ballot on whether to transfer the remainder of Salford Council's housing stock ends on Monday November 3rd. If tenants vote `Yes' they will see the culmination of a massive ConDem Government attack on social housing in the city that will in future see more expensive rents, less secure and fixed term tenancies, and a social housing company acting like a private developer.

The vote isn't necessarily about the present rights of tenants, it's about the rights of future generations of Salfordians...

Full details here...

SALFORD COUNCIL HOUSING TRANSFER VOTE NEARS WITH RENT HIKES ON THE AGENDA

Star date: 29th October 2014

`SOCIAL RENT' OR `AFFORDABLE RENT' IF SALIX WINS TRANSFER VOTE?

As tenants are urged to vote `Yes' or `No' to the privatisation of 8,500 Council homes in Salford by next Monday, November 3rd, there's still question marks over the future ethos of Salix Homes, the company that intends to take over the properties.

A clue is given in the Business Plan which will see 120 properties that are currently `social rent' tenancies on the Beechfarm Estate in Swinton replaced by 106 `affordable rent' properties. `Affordable rent' is way more expensive than `social rent'.

Full details here...

THE SALFORD WALL MUST BE REBUILT

Star date: 27th October 2014

RECLAIMING CHAPEL STREET REGENERATION

As the blitz of old buildings in Chapel Street continues and bits of old Salford disappear to be replaced by unaffordable apartments and chain store shops, one project is kicking back.

The Salford Wall, a five year event almost, numbered and saved bricks when the Old Bank Theatre was demolished, and now aims to use those bricks to build a community monument near the original site. The project needs Salford people's ideas for what should be built and volunteers to help sort the bricks.

Full details here...

SALFORD OLD CLOTHES COLLECTION TO SEND KIDS TO BLACKPOOL

Star date: 26th October 2014

OLD CLOTHES AND STUFF WANTED FROM KERSAL, LOWER KERSAL, WHIT LANE AND BROUGHTON

WKD KOLLECT
Tuesday 4th November

A new community initiative will see a van touring around East Salford on Tuesday 4th November picking up clothes, shoes, belts, towels and curtains, recycling them and using the money to send local kids on trips to Blackpool.

WKD Kollect, with its slogan `Charity starts at home', will collect bagged up stuff or it can be left at set drop off points.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx