HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
£18MILLION PLANNING FEE AVOIDANCE IN SALFORD STATES SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY REPORT
 

Star date: 26th February 2018

SALFORD COUNCIL DEVELOPER FRIENDLY POLICIES LED TO £18MILLION FEE AVOIDANCE AND LOSS OF OVER 2,000 AFFORDABLE PROPERTIES

A new report by Dr Jonathan Silver at Sheffield University has echoed Salford Star research that developers are avoiding millions of pounds in planning fees, while the city is losing thousands of affordable properties.

This research looked at 26 sites in the city that had planning permission, and concluded that over £18million had been avoided in Section 106 payments plus the provision of over 2,000 affordable properties. Salford Star research has shown that, over all Salford sites, the figure is around £50million.

Full details here...


New research by Dr Jonathan Silver at Sheffield University has shown that £18,103,201 has been avoided by developers over 26 sites studied in Salford, and that Salford City Council's developer friendly policies has also led to the loss of 2,194 affordable properties.

This echoes and supports Salford Star research over the last few years that shows, over all sites in Salford, around £50million has been lost to the city through planning fee avoidance, plus thousands of affordable properties.*

Silver's report, titled From Homes to Assets: Housing financialisation in Greater Manchester, looks at the overall context of development in the area, and how housing is now treated as a 'commodity for accumulating wealth' by both global and local developers.

He writes about a "developer-friendly approach" that "has involved allowing planning permission for most new buildings overriding concerns about heritage, neighbourhood impact, affordable housing, design and other gentrification"...a "supportive context for housing developers" that is "most noticeable through reducing financial contributions from developers through Section 106 contributions and affordable housing requirements."

The Salford sites investigated include Middlewoood Locks, the ECf's Stanley Street and Slate Yard, Adelphi Street, loads of developments on the Quays, and Fred Done's Blackfriars blocks.

While £18,103,201 was avoided by developers "through manipulating 'viability assessments'", only £4,875,373 was collected in Salford. And, while an estimated 2,194 affordable housing units were lost via the same process, across the sites studied, only five affordable properties were provided.

Manchester fared even worse, with only £834,000 collected in contributions and no affordable housing gained across the 53 sites studied.

The report also looks at how state aid from the likes of the Government, Greater Manchester Combined Authority and Salford City Council has directly subsidised many of these private developments. It's been done by either allocating and providing public land, or through cheap loans totalling £265million, with average financial support at £29,719 per unit, "none of which are designated for affordable or social housing".

Middlewood Locks, for instance, is cited in the report, with £35million in subsidy, while Fred Done's Blackfriars development had £17million, although the Star showed how this figure was subsequently increased to £22.5million (see here).

Across the Salford sites studied, the report shows how 86% are being marketed abroad, as the developments become part of a huge network of worldwide investment, "including large institutional investors involved in development finance, companies based in 'secrecy jurisdictions' and smaller investors purchasing one or two units, as part of savings and pension schemes for the growing, global middle class...

"...It means new housing units being built in Greater Manchester are already sold
'off-plan' before they even become available for local residents" the report shows. However, it adds, with the average cost of an apartment in one of the Salford sites £167,046, on top of other housing related bills a local person would have to be earning £3,000 a month to be able to afford one.

As well as the financial exclusion involved in actual buying one of the properties, renting one is also out of reach of the local community, with rent increases averaging 22.4% in Greater Manchester between 2014 and 2015.

Particularly galling is the growth of the Private Rental Sector, or PRS – "This sector can be understood as housing developments that are built for rental purposes by institutional investors" the report explains...

"This can include developers holding onto the housing units or selling them on to various financial institutions and actors, aimed at the rental sector and importantly as tradable assets that can be sold on to other institutional investors" it adds "This new financial 'product' is the key means through which housing financialisation has taken place and allows institutional investors to purchase apartments, often at scale (so for instance a whole building or urban development site), creating both ongoing rental income and a traceable asset.

"Encouraged by new national guidance and favourable fiscal conditions, thousands of PRS apartments are in development, intended to capitalise on the rising rents in the housing market" it states "The opportunities to profit from the PRS have therefore differed considerably from the past because it is now straight-forward for large financial actors to invest in housing in Greater Manchester."

While international investors and local developers are cashing in, where does this leave the community?

As Salford City Council might argue, and the report estimates, in the very long term, as much as £13million per year in Council Tax from the new properties might be collected. But increased population leads to strains on services like schools, doctors, refuse collection, transport and more, which haven't been addressed because of the huge losses on Section 106 fee collection.

Other impacts include "important parts of the historic built environment being destroyed in the name of developer profit and the privatisation of public space" (as can be seen in Chapel Street and Salford Quays), the report concludes.

It also concludes that "Local Authorities are failing to create balanced communities. The result is that there is increasing economic segregation within Greater Manchester city-regional centre and surrounding areas, creating ghettos of rich and poor".

The report begins with the truism that "Amongst the cranes and construction workers, new towers and luxury accommodation, the numbers of homeless both hidden and on the streets continues to grow. It has become perhaps the city-region's most pressing political and social issue as hundreds of rough sleepers struggle for survival everyday in Manchester and Salford."

This most pressing and shameful political and social issue is nowhere near to being resolved...


From Homes to Assets: Housing financialisation in Greater Manchester
The Salford Star recommends that readers check out either the full report or its 'executive summary' – click here for the link on Greater Manchester Housing Action website with an intro by Jonathan Silver

*See also previous related Salford Star articles...

Salford Housing Crisis – The Causes – click here

£42million Planning Scandal Mushrooms as Salford Mayor Asks What's Going On – click here

Only Two Affordable Properties For Over 4,000 Flats and Houses Built in Greengate and Chapel Street - click here

Salford In UK Top 10 Greedy Property Speculator Hotspots - click here

9 Year Waiting List For One Bed Affordable Flat in Salford - click here

Salford Star print issue 10 has a huge article detailing the background and ruses behind the planning scandal – click here for electronic version

John Smith wrote
at 13:57:47 on 01 March 2018
Lemmings! When will Salford wake up?
 
Phil wrote
at 00:15:13 on 01 March 2018
Bob, why all of this vitriol against the Mayor? You seem to have a pathological hatred for the guy. Okay, so the tenants at Albion Towers will see their rent NOT go up. Guess what, I live in a Salix Tower block and my rent doesn't appear to have gone up either. I don't get people like you, and Mary and Joe. All that you ever do is complain. And Steve from the Star, he's a good journalist, but he reminds me of Tom Courtney in The Loneliness of The Long Distance Runner. Crossed with James Deane in Rebel Without A Cause. It's laughable. We live in the real world where hard decisions have to be made. Not in some Fantasy Socialist Utopia. If the money isn't there, then it isn't there. That's just how it is. Now either accept it and get on with it, or maybe we should all pay a bit more Council Tax and then there would be more money in the pot to pay for nurseries and meals on wheels etc. Just stop complaining all of the time and being so negative. It smacks of bitterness. For my opinion the Council and Mayor Dennett are doing a good job.
 
Bob the regular wrote
at 18:56:58 on 28 February 2018
Well ,re Bob and Kevin below, can we also add, the mayors rent is not going up this year on his block,Albion Towers.This is the well managed tmo block run by Dennets mates . I think Dennet was on the board there before he was made mayor. Its a nice little click for Dennets lefty pals. It works out well for the residents. I also would like to live on a block like this, but they wouldn,t have dissident types like me in there. (or Mary or Joe)
 
Salford Star wrote
at 18:25:57 on 28 February 2018
See Kevin's comment below...Correction: Paul Dennett wasn't yet Mayor when he got the property, just a councillor.
 
Kevin wrote
at 18:24:03 on 28 February 2018
Wow it would seem that Dennett is ripping off Salford citizens good and proper. Maybe he can move into one of these expensive flats on his salary instead of hogging social housing he wouldn't have got if he hadn't been mayor.
 
bob wrote
at 17:31:11 on 27 February 2018
I keep seeing the Phrase "Affordable Housing". It seems different councils have different meanings. What do Salford call affordable because some of their properties run by City west and Salix are almost and in some case in excess of £100.00
 
Gareth L wrote
at 07:02:04 on 27 February 2018
Is this the Salford Star being proved correct again? Great work
 
Felsey wrote
at 07:01:18 on 27 February 2018
Exactly why we need to implement a Mayor directive to claw back Section106 lost levy from an auditor past seven years by a directive examining where any properties were financially viable as shown in the developers' accounts. On top of this we do need to implement a Waterways Mooring Levy, based on fixed fees for every 20 yards stretch. Claw back at seven years can see the biggest waterfront land owners in Salford facing a levy of up to £400million. Enough cash to ensure Salford Council Services are fit for purpose. I would not hesitate to fully implement.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SECRECY REIGNS AT SALFORD CITY COUNCIL OVER FUTURE OF SWINTON, PENDLETON, CHARLESTOWN, LOWER BROUGHTON AND ORDSALL
Transparency??? Wasn't when I worked for them isn't now. Precinct a joke. Going into such decline and 5he powers that be are letti... [more]
article: SECRECY REIGNS AT SALFORD CITY COUNCIL OVER FUTURE OF SWINTON, PENDLETON, CHARLESTOWN, LOWER BROUGHTON AND ORDSALL
Is it me or is it getting darker around swinton with ALL these shady dealings going on. There is no Democracy in the labour party... [more]
article: DEMOLITION TEAM MOVES IN ON SALFORD DIRTY OLD TOWN GASWORKS
Maybe the gasworks could have been saved and put into a Salford theme park or a living "Life and Death in Salford" museum. They co... [more]
article: SALFORD MP SHOULD BE DESELECTED AFTER KEEPING TORIES IN POWER SAYS CONSTITUENT
Time to get rid of these Tory stooges - no one believes in a Tory Brexit anymore!... [more]
article: CHINESE TO TAKE OVER AJ BELL STADIUM AND LAND, WHILE INVESTING IN BUILE HILL MANSION SALFORD PUBLIC MEETING HEARS
Mr.Rossi, You really are an appalling character. Faced with a comment that provides facts which clearly refute your allegations a... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SECRECY REIGNS AT SALFORD CITY COUNCIL OVER FUTURE OF SWINTON, PENDLETON, CHARLESTOWN, LOWER BROUGHTON AND ORDSALL

Star date: 17th August 2018

SWINTON 'TRANSFORMATION'...PENDLETON 'PHASE 2'... CHARLESTOWN 'OPTIONS' AND MORE ALL BEING DECIDED BEHIND CLOSED DOORS

Did you know that there's a 'Masterplan' for Swinton's 'Transformation'? Or that there are plans proceeding about development in Charlestown, Pendleton, Ordsall and the Cambridge Industrial area in Lower Broughton? No? We're not surprised.

It's all happening behind closed doors at Salford City Council; the same council that prides itself on so-called 'transparency'.

Full details here...

WORKPLACE PARKING LEVY ONE OF THE OPTIONS AS GREATER MANCHESTER CONSIDERS CLEAN AIR ZONES

Star date: 16th August 2018

GMCA TRIES TO AVOID VEHICLE CHARGES FOR CLEAN AIR ZONES

Today, Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) is meeting to discuss options for reducing air pollution in the region. The Government has identified charge based Clean Air Zones as the benchmark, and unless the GMCA can come up with an alternative plan to reduce emissions quickly, charging polluting vehicles will be on the cards. A 'workplace parking levy' is one of the options.

Full details here...

CHINESE TO TAKE OVER AJ BELL STADIUM AND LAND, WHILE INVESTING IN BUILE HILL MANSION SALFORD PUBLIC MEETING HEARS

Star date: 15th August 2018 

BUILE HILL MANSION SUPPORT GROUP MEETING HEARS OF 'CHINESE' PLANS FOR SALFORD

Over the last few months, rumours of a Chinese buyout of the AJ Bell Stadium and its land, hand outs for the Buile Hill Mansion and a possible plan for a Salford Red Devils takeover have been louder than bombs. At last night's meeting of the Buile Hill Mansion Support Group, these plans were aired in public for the first time.

Full details here...

DISTRAUGHT SALFORD DAUGHTER CAN’T GET TO FAMILY GRAVE AT ST PAUL’S CHURCH IN KERSAL

Star date: 14th August 2018

A TALE OF TWO CUSSONS, HIGH BRAMBLES AND IMPERIAL LEATHER

At the front of St Paul's Churchyard in Kersal, the first neat and tidy grave you come across is that of Alexander Cussons and famous family. However the grave of the less famous William Evans, who produced the first ever bar of Imperial Leather soap, is at the very back of the yard and totally inaccessible, literally buried beneath 6ft high weeds and brambles.

William Evans' great granddaughter, Lesley Northall, is distraught as she wants to add her mother's ashes to the site but can't get near it. This isn't just the tale of two Cussons gurus but also of a church struggling for resources.

Full details here...

SALFORD ROAD CHAOS LOOMS FOR A YEAR

Star date: 13th August 2018

JOURNEY TIMES TO DOUBLE AS £15MILLION 'IMPROVEMENT SCHEME' BEGINS

On 29th August, the £15million Manchester and Salford Inner Relief Route improvement scheme begins which is set to last a year and double journey times around Regent Road, from Oldfield Road to the Mancunian Way, which will see roads reduced to one lane in places.

The work is expected to have knock-on delays to other routes including around the M602, East Lancs Road and Trinity Way.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx