Star date: 23rd November 2016


Greater Manchester Housing Action Public Meeting
Thursday 24th November 7pm-9pm
Central Hall, Oldham Street, Mcr

Tomorrow night, Greater Manchester Housing Action is hosting a public meeting that will discuss the housing crisis, from the lack of social housing to homelessness and spiralling rents. The results of the discussion will be fed into the GM People's Plan to be presented as demands to candidates standing for Mayor of Greater Manchester.

Speakers include Angela Barratt of Salford Street Support, Betsy Dillner of Generation Rent, and Stephen Kingston editor of the Salford Star. As an intro, here the Salford Star presents a huge article on the causes of the housing crisis in Salford.

Full details here...

Speculator Profits Salford
click image to enlarge

Last week, at the full meeting of Salford City Council, both the City Mayor, Paul Dennett, and Paul Longshaw, Lead Member for Housing, gave speeches commendably backing the Homelessness Reduction Bill and bemoaning the lack of affordable housing in the city...

"To end the homelessness epidemic we need more socially affordable housing at fair rents" said Dennett "There is a chronic market failure in housing and we can't keep looking to profit based solutions to solve this problem..."

Paul Longshaw added "Fundamental to tackling homelessness is an increase in supply, and this means ensuring that there are enough genuinely affordable homes for people..."

Meanwhile, last Sunday night there was a documentary on BBC 2 about superyachts, the play things of the rich costing up to £30million each. The bloke on the programme, who was flogging them at Cannes and the Southampton Boat Show, said this had been a record year for sales...

...When asked why there was this increase he explained that, while the super affluent had their normal businesses, they were also making what he called "toy money" from property.

When he says "property" he isn't talking a few buy-to-let flats. For that amount he's talking towerblocks full of luxury apartments - just like the ones being planted all over the Salford border with Manchester.

And while the speculators have been making `toy money', the Salford Star has estimated over £40million in planning payments that they have avoided or evaded by stating that their developments wouldn't be `viable' if they had to cough up the money.

Using this ploy, the Salford Star estimated, based on Salford City Council's own figures, that the speculators have also avoided providing over one thousand affordable homes. Indeed Salford Council policy was changed only 18 months ago to make this easier for them, with developers being allowed to make up to £24million profit before `viability' calculations were made (see illustration with profits highlighted in yellow).

Now Salford Council has admitted (kind of) that it got it horribly wrong. In the Council's new Local Plan, that's currently out for consultation, it states "There is clear evidence that the high density apartment market is very successful in Salford", and that, "in response to changing levels of viability...it is anticipated that there will increasingly be the potential to deliver affordable housing as part of such schemes".

The only problem is that the new policy doesn't come into force until 2019 – by which time there won't be a scrap of Salford land near Manchester that hasn't already got planning permission with the old `viability' get-out clauses attached (see previous Salford Star article for full details – click here).

At last week's Council meeting Paul Longshaw, quite rightly, also said that "Locally we have a dysfunctional housing market...households in the city are facing a reduced range of affordable housing options..."

Again, the Salford Star has been documenting for over ten years the social engineering, or `social cleansing', that has been taking place in central Salford – in Broughton, Seedley and Langworthy, Ordsall, Pendleton and Lower Kersal and Charlestown – which was deliberate Salford Council and previous Labour Government policy. The aim was to dilute areas of predominantly social housing.

Huge swathes of the city have been basically handed over to private developers, like Countryside Properties, Urban Splash and LPC Living, to carry out the policy, which was partly known as Pathfinder and backed by Tony Blair, John Prescott and other previous Cabinet ministers.

Indeed, Countryside Properties, which has created `New Broughton', put it in black and white in a report to the Council's planning panel in October 2014, as it successfully tried to justify evading provision of affordable housing for its new private housing estate on The Meadows...

Boasting of how, at the end of its current phases of building, the `tenure split' would be 36% affordable and 64% non-affordable, or private `market accommodation', the property company stated: "It was a key aspiration of the Development Agreement to significantly reduce the proportion of affordable housing and this scheme will help achieve that aspiration..."

An area that was once made up of almost 100% houses that were affordable to the community will now be 64% unaffordable for that community.

Not only do these schemes clear vast proportions of the old community out of the area, they also mask the poverty and problems that still exist in the area. Countryside Properties, in its original planning application for `New Broughton' stated quite clearly that "By introducing more market housing, which is generally occupied by a greater proportion of economically active people, there is likely to be an overall improvement in the health of the residential population of the area."

Pendleton, on the doorstep of the University of Salford and MediaCityUK, is currently undergoing a 15 year, PFI (Private Finance Initiative) `transformation'. In the first £40million phase of the Pendleton Together project, only 110 of 300 new properties are affordable and for rent. In the overall £430million scheme, only around 500 homes out of 1500 being built will be affordable. This compares with 885 affordable properties being bulldozed.

The Business Case that went off to the Government to get the PFI grants stated that the final plans for Pendleton "will lead to a dilution in the current concentration of economically inactive households" by "young professionals and individuals who wish to live in Pendleton". 

The chief Council architect of the Pendleton `regeneration' was Paul Longshaw, previously head housing officer for Salford Council before becoming a Labour Party councillor and very quickly, Lead Member for Housing and Neighbourhoods.

When asked for a comment on Facebook, Paul Longshaw responded... "Central Govt housing policy and investment through the decade and reacting to that locally ...blimey - loads have tried to nail that down and to make sense of it all."

Over the last decade the Salford Star has consistently called for a public inquiry into Pathfinder (see here) which has consistently fallen on deaf ears.

Salford Council has also backed the privatisation of council housing in the city, firstly with the City West Housing `stock transfer', and lately with the Salix Homes sell off. These companies are now almost completely out of the control of democratic accountability, with City West admitting in its recent accounts that it's looking to "maximise existing return through both good asset management but also changing the tenure and use of available stock" (see here).

The company reveals that 91 of its properties have been converted to `market rent', while its board has "has approved the acquisition of 154 PRS [Private Rent Sector] new build properties in Ordsall". In other words, the social rent charity, City West Housing, is helping to fuel unaffordable rents in the city.

All of these short-sighted Salford Council, previous Labour Government and current vicious Tory Government cuts and policies have led to an affordable housing crisis in the city, mirrored elsewhere in Greater Manchester and beyond.

Salford Council now states that it needs 734 additional affordable houses per year to head off the crisis. Last week the Council passed its `Refreshed Housing Strategy Delivery Plan', which offered few solutions in relation to affordable housing.

It stated that it would `Pilot innovative housing for under 35s' - in April 2017 - to try to stave off barbaric Government cuts to housing benefit for those under 35; that there would be one thousand affordable homes developed by 2021 (which is 200 a year, leaving a shortage of 534 affordable houses); that it will `Develop a Housing Partners Salford Pledge to ensure Right to Buy replacement ratios are effective'; and that it would be `Delivering 1,000 private sector homes, including empty privately owned homes, into the management of or leased to Salix Homes by 2020'.

The Council also stated that it will be adopting an Affordable Housing Strategy – in a year's time, December 2017!

Meanwhile, at last week's Council meeting, the Mayor declared that there would be "Council owned homes at living rent built in our city, distributed according to social need and placed outside of Right to Buy". He added that "It will not solve housing need in the city but it will be part of an overall solution."

Another solution proffered by Planning Lead Member, Councillor Derek Antrobus, at the Council meeting was the doubling of the requirement by developers to provide affordable housing, from 20% to 40% - but only on green belt land near Irlam and Cadishead, which is proposed in the city's Local Plan... "We will seek to remedy the injustice of the housing market which is denying so many young people access to the homes that they need" he thumped.

Except that the affordable homes `that they need' won't be anywhere near central Salford. They will be well out of the way in Irlam and Cadishead, with echoes of Little Hulton in the 50s and 60s, where people had travel back into the city to work.

All this social engineering is nothing new to Salford. It was seen in the 50s, 60s, 70s and, way further back, Salford based social commentator and revolutionary Friedrich Engels wrote about it 145 years ago...

"The growth of the big modern cities gives the land in certain areas, particularly in those which are centrally situated, an artificial and colossally increasing value" he explained "The buildings erected on these areas depress this value instead of increasing it, because they no longer correspond to the changed circumstances. They are pulled down and replaced by others. This takes place above all with the workers' houses which are situated centrally and whose rents...can never increase above a certain maximum.

"The result is that workers are forced out of the centre of towns towards the outskirts; that workers' dwellings...become rare and expensive and often altogether unobtainable" he added "For under these circumstances the building industry, which is offered a much better field for speculation by more expensive houses, builds workers' dwelling only by way of exception...They will provide new dwellings for hardly more than a quarter of the workers actually evicted by the building operations."

It's a lesson that should have been well learned by the current crop of Jeremy Corbyn supporters at Salford Council. But it's not.

"Plus ηa change, plus c'est la mκme chose", or `the more things change the more they stay the same' – quote by Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr in 1849, roughly the same time that Engels was writing about `the housing question' in Salford and Manchester.

Tomorrow, Thursday 24th November, Greater Manchester Housing Action is hosting a public meeting on the housing crisis in Greater Manchester, as part of a programme of events organised by The GM People's Plan.

It's at Methodist Central Hall, Oldham Street, Manchester M1 1JQ and runs between 7pm and 9pm. The event is an opportunity to discuss how issues of housing and homelessness are affecting Greater Manchester, and will be led by Stephen Kingston, Editor of the Salford Star, Betsy Dillner, of Generation Rent, and Angela Barratt of Salford and Manchester Street Support.

After the initial speakers people will then split into working groups to discuss in greater detail specific areas of policy and their potential solutions. Areas to be discussed include planning priorities, social housing, regulation of the private rented sector, homelessness and alternative housing provisions.

The results of the evening will feed directly into The People's Plan. This is a free event and everyone – including Salford councillors – is welcome, although people are being asked to book tickets - click here

For further details see the Facebook event page - click here


Mr b. r exit wrote
at 1:48:51 AM on Saturday, November 26, 2016
Could't agree more with all the people who mentioned immigration, it is the elephant in the room, but I suppose were all racists for mentioning it.
Disalousioned socalist. wrote
at 9:31:11 AM on Wednesday, November 23, 2016
The propaganda fed to the masses over the sale of social housing, the ability for speculators to flout the rules on affordable homes, the massive rises in buy to let properties have all caused key failures in supply not forgetting right to buy. Add to that a council that in reality as engineered a program of social cleansing and a mayor that jumps the housing supply criteria helps little. But why in the article does it omit the number of migrants today taking homes ?. If we fail with adding this to the equation then we fail in our task to debate a serious issue getting worse by the day. Task the issue but I ask in fairness to add all the ingredients
Gareth L wrote
at 9:30:13 AM on Wednesday, November 23, 2016
It is a surprise that with so much new build needed in offical stats as a direct result of immigration. That it is ignored - it is an elephant in the room peope are scared to talk about. As is the rampant profitering and social cleansing going on in the city.
Alice wrote
at 6:02:54 AM on Wednesday, November 23, 2016
What a comprehensive report! Would like to go to the meeting but it clashes with the East Salford Community Meeting. However, the remark by Paul Dennett gives me hope. Do I see a move to change the way things have been operating. It would be welcome change indeed and must continue. The profiteering developers have had too much of their own way at the expense of Salford community. Our Councillors must get back control on the grounds of social justice.
The Fat End of the Wedge wrote
at 6:02:49 AM on Wednesday, November 23, 2016
Nothing to do with excess immigration then? Get out from behind your desks Mr. Mayor and Star and take a stroll around the 'social housing' estates of Salford and Manchester and you will see why there is a lack of said housing. Or we can just blame old people. And you really want us to just keep building and building to house the artificially high population? I thought you were for protecting green spaces? Oh well, all this building keeps the unemployment figures artificially low I suppose, not that there is any future in most of those jobs.
Please enter your comment below:
Salford Live Events
Salford Star contact
Salford Star
Salford Star print
Deli Lama
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
Recent comments
Mary, you clearly have never ever contacted Salford Trafing stamdards about buying a dodgy car! Once again you are failing to not... [more]
Mary ferrer, going and doing spot checks won't help. They know how to get around all that. What is needed is changes to the licens... [more]
Right,Salford lad. I will try another view on this. Let's forget we are talking about puppies.Let's say it's a car,LOTS of cars,A... [more]
Mary Ferrer you are comparing apples and pears. Cigarettes and alcohol are not living organisms! Dogs fall ill particularly puppie... [more]
just wanna thank salford star for standing by us ting n ting ... [more]


Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome


More articles...


Star date: 24th September 2017


Fighting Unemployment, Poverty and Austerity
Saturday 30th September 1pm-3pm free
Working Class Movement Library

On the eve of the Tory Party Conference, the Mary Quaile Club is running a public meeting at Salford's Working Class Movement Library on Fighting Unemployment, Poverty and Austerity, with speakers Sean Mitchell, author of the book Struggle or Starve about Belfast riots, and Tameside Against The Cuts activist Charlotte Hughes.

Full details here...


Star date: 24th September 2017


Films and Conversation with Ken Loach and Friends
Thursday 23rd November 4pm-midnight
Moston Miners' Centre £20/£10

Ken Loach, director of top films like I, Daniel Blake, Cathy Come Home and Looking For Eric, is to star in a fundraiser for Salford Unemployed and Community Resource Centre on Thursday 23rd November. Joining him are JB Barrington, Ricky Tomlinson and more, with tickets on sale now.

Full details here...


Star date: 23rd September 2017


Cornerstone Open Day and Salford Histories Festival
Saturday 30th September 10am-4pm
Langworthy Cornerstone free

Well over a dozen local history groups and community organisations have joined together for a Salford Histories Festival and Langworthy Cornerstone Open Day next Saturday, with competitions, activities, food and more.

Full details here...


Star date: 23rd September 2017


Old Ground
Thursday 28th September to Sunday 8th October
Kings Arms £10/£12

Organised Chaos bring Old Ground to the Kings Arms this week. It's a dramatic account of a specific moment in the horrific story of the Moors Murderers: Myra Hindley's disturbing attempt to deny involvement in the gruesome crimes in a bid for freedom, and Ian Brady's effort to exact revenge on his ex-lover, as Ian Leslie reports.

Full details here...


Star date: 23rd September 2017


In July 2016 the Salford Poverty Truth Commission was launched to drive home some real life honesty to those shaping the city's present and future, and hopefully change something. Has it achieved anything? On October 6th, Commission members will be sharing some results in a free open event that anyone can attend.

Full details here...


written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx