HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
SALFORD PLANNING MAYOR FINALLY EXPOSES `PUBLIC SCANDAL OF IMMENSE PROPORTIONS’
 

Star date: 22nd January 2015

SALFORD ASSISTANT PLANNING MAYOR ACCUSES ERIC PICKLES OF ROBBING COMMUNITY TO LINE DEVELOPERS' POCKETS

Following Salford Star articles accusing Salford councillors of saying nothing about Government planning regulations that allow developers to escape paying millions of pounds to Salford City Council, Councillor Derek Antrobus, Assistant Mayor for Strategic Planning, finally let Tory Secretary of State Eric Pickles have it with both barrels at yesterday's full Council meeting.

It was "a public scandal of immense proportions that has seen Eric Pickles rig the planning regulations in order to deprive, to rob, local communities of its essential investment in order to line the pockets of landowners and developers" said Antrobus. And Salford Tory Leader, Karen Garrido, agreed that it was a "serious problem".

Full details here...


Is there a General Election in the air? Salford Star has been pointing out for ages how developers that are currently scarring the city with huge, ugly blocks of unaffordable, small apartments near Manchester City Centre and on Salford Quays have been getting out of paying £millions to Salford City Council, thanks to `viability' loopholes...

"While housing support services for the city's poorest people are about to get battered in the cuts budget, property speculators are cashing in on scandalous ConDem Government planning policy and a pathetically weak response from Salford councillors, rolling over every time a hand wringing developer cries poverty because their profit levels aren't high enough..." wrote the Star (see full article – click here).

At the following planning meeting, councillors of both the Labour and Conservative parties did respond, slagging off the loss of £4.4million of payments in applications for over 1,500 flats at Chapel Wharf and Clippers Quay.

"Now the challenge is for Salford councillors to take their grievances about the pathetic levels of Section 106 contributions and affordable housing out of the planning panel meetings and explain to their residents why the Council is losing £millions every month to back slapping developers – and more importantly to take a stand on it and campaign for change..." wrote the Star (see full article – click here).

Yesterday the scandal was finally brought out in public at the full meeting of Salford City Council – and Councillor Derek Antrobus, Assistant Mayor for Strategic Planning, didn't hold back.

"I think it is a public scandal of immense proportions that has seen Eric Pickles rig the planning regulations in order to deprive, to rob, local communities of its essential investment in order to line the pockets of landowners and developers" he spat "That is the reality of the position that we are in."

The `scandal' revolves around `Section 106' agreements, which are payments developers agree to make to Salford Council for things like `public realm, infrastructure and heritage', `construction training' and `open space', on a set scale. On large developments, they also have to provide affordable housing or make payments for `off site' affordable housing**.

Developers have always sought ways to get around these obligations - and usually do in Salford. Last time the Salford Star put in a Freedom of Information request (2013) there had been only one `off-site' sum paid for affordable housing in the previous five years! And that was for Ladywell Point on Eccles New Road – nowhere near Manchester centre or Salford Quays.

During this time there had been a change of Government, where Eric Pickles, Conservative Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, had made it even easier for developers to jump through loopholes, by changing the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) in respect of `viability' - creating an even bigger scandal than what was present before...

"Where it is considered that a development is not viable if a section 106 agreement is imposed then we've got to ignore the section 106 issues" explained Antrobus "The Government has determined that `viability' is where a developer is no longer able to make a 10% profit on it - I don't know of any other industry where that profit margin is guaranteed by the public sector."

Antrobus tempered his arguments by adding that the Council gets "some benefits through development agreements rather than section 106" and that developers that had secured land at too high a price from land owners "in some cases can't develop at prices that we need". He added that the Salford Star's estimate of £20million lost to the city through developer loopholes was a "fantasy figure" really? (see below*).

Conservative Leader Councillor Karen Garrido slated the amount of rented, as opposed to sold, flats being given planning permission and added that "We should be looking at the District Valuer" who appears to be regularly okaying the developers `viability' figures... "If this is a serious problem we should be doing something about it" she said, offering to pay her own train fare to go and see Eric Pickles with Councillor Antrobus to sort it out.

In the meantime, there are more huge planning applications in the pipeline, no doubt with `viability' issues which will let more developers off with more £millions.

Earlier in the Council meeting there was another scandal brewing, with the directly elected Mayor for Greater Manchester to be given powers over the Salford planning process.

This revolves around a thing called the Greater Manchester Spatial Framework, a document that sets out the region's needs for housing and commercial space. Councillor Karen Garrido, who had seen a copy of the consultation on the Framework, said that it "stated we needed more houses and land, and could be looking at green belt land too".

Normally the Framework would be ratified by the ten local authorities, including Salford Council, but the Greater Manchester Mayor will now be making the final decision, with the consent of his Cabinet, removing formal powers of ordinary councillors to challenge it.

"There may be legislative change which means that we would not have the power to approve it" Councillor Antrobus responded "That power will be somewhere else, and I can't give you any guarantees about that because we do not know what is in the minds of Members of Parliament".

The Council agreed the Greater Manchester Spatial Framework report which included the wording "The GM Agreement provides for a directly elected mayor with powers over strategic planning, including the power to create a statutory spatial framework for GM [Greater Manchester]."



• £20MILLION IN LOST PLANNING FEES A `FANTASY FIGURE'?

Scarborough Development Group - Middlewood Locks £6.412m
X1 Media City (if planning obligations not changed) £2.437m
Pinnacle Greengate £1.908m
Peel Holdings – MediaCityUK - £5.59m
Peel Holdings – Media City hotel etc £184,263
City Suites Greengate £476,781
Dock Office Salford Quays £251,098
Salford Town Hall X1 £250,000
Elan Homes – Ordsall £300,000
Amstone Ventures – Clippers Quay £1.677m

Total: £19.486

• Figures are only the ones documented by Salford Star
• Figures exclude any affordable housing
• Figures exclude Acroy/Dandara application which was deferred but would have been a loss of another £2.76m


** These `viability' issues haven't just been present under the ConDem Government. Back in 2007, under the Labour Government, the Salford Star documented every single planning application submitted to Salford City Council during a six month period at the height of the housing boom - only four schemes out of 19 submitted offered any affordable housing. From applications submitted for nearly 9,000 homes, only 175, or less than 2%, were officially classed as affordable - despite the Council having a policy in place that all new developments over 25 houses had to provide between 20% and 25% affordable homes. The loophole? The schemes would not be `commercially viable'?

For full report see Salford Star printed issue 4 Spring 2007 - click here for PDF

Update: 30th January 2015 -

Salford Council refuses to disclose secret viability figures under Freedom of Information Act - see here


Anon wrote
at 1:54:54 PM on Sunday, January 25, 2015
What's needed is for the government to say, in law, that these payments are compulsory, everywhere and in every circumstance. That way, with no loopholes the cost will be accounted for in the price the land and a fixed cost in developing a scheme. Still, it doesn't excuse SCC for not taking a tougher line. Anyone know the name of the planning officers who lead these negotiations? You also see the same planning consultants popping up time and again e.g. Deloite. These people must become familiar with each other over a period of time. I fear that without public scrutiny these closed shop negotiations lack rigour and critical analysis and risk becoming open to abuse.
 
Alice Searle wrote
at 7:33:58 AM on Friday, January 23, 2015
At last we are seeing some spirit and the expression of justifiable anger from two Councillors. I applaud this because the people of Salford have been waiting so long for their representatives to get up and protest at the Government's sneaky policies, which provide loopholes for business to avoid its social responsibility. We need to see more of this from other Councillors. The amount of money 'given' to the developers from our taxes Is astounding and is not acceptable by any standards. Many people in Salford have lost faith in this Council. They don't feel their needs are being really considered and many wonder who is 'calling the tune!'
 
Michael Felse wrote
at 7:33:07 AM on Friday, January 23, 2015
I accept these calculations shown by our trusted Salford Star as being correct. While it shows our Council loss at £20million, further explanation is important in that the increase in properties at the Band B creates £14million a year council tax income for Salford Council, every year. During a 30 year life span of the new builds it brings £420million. However this can be at least doubled, with further home building. The projection surly shows Salford Council can afford vulnerable people support and at the same time invest in sport, technology, health, community safety, jobs and social housing. Why is it local Councillors get stuck in the mud, banging on about Politics. I do not care about Pickles but I do care about elected Councillors being trusted to protect vulnerable people; The Labour Role?
 
Salford Lad wrote
at 8:05:05 AM on Thursday, January 22, 2015
Tut tut tut ! They are all in it together - in a pickle that is ! So why weren't these councillors having a go at Eric Pickles when the Pickled One was steamrollering over "localism" and trashing our cranes ?? Why do these people continue to keep having mayors ? It's gotta be time to have a Northern Republic and tell Westminster to do one isn't it ? Enough is enough
 
Scott cooper wrote
at 5:49:25 AM on Thursday, January 22, 2015
Makes me sick the amount of money Salford Council has lost through "waived" planning fees. Poor are getting poorer whilst the rich are getting richer. That sum of £20 that Salford Star says has been lost would lighten the blow on these cuts the council are making.
 
Anthony Dowd wrote
at 5:49:20 AM on Thursday, January 22, 2015
As you say "Election in the air?". Salford Council make no mention of why THEIR enforcement of old regulations was just as BAD as with the existing framework! A bad policy, enforced by weak Councillors?
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Live Events
Salford Star contact
Salford Star
Salford Star print
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SALFORD DOGS4US SEES PUPPY FARM AWARENESS DAY PROTEST
Mary, you clearly have never ever contacted Salford Trafing stamdards about buying a dodgy car! Once again you are failing to not... [more]
article: SALFORD DOGS4US SEES PUPPY FARM AWARENESS DAY PROTEST
Mary ferrer, going and doing spot checks won't help. They know how to get around all that. What is needed is changes to the licens... [more]
article: SALFORD DOGS4US SEES PUPPY FARM AWARENESS DAY PROTEST
Right,Salford lad. I will try another view on this. Let's forget we are talking about puppies.Let's say it's a car,LOTS of cars,A... [more]
article: SALFORD DOGS4US SEES PUPPY FARM AWARENESS DAY PROTEST
Mary Ferrer you are comparing apples and pears. Cigarettes and alcohol are not living organisms! Dogs fall ill particularly puppie... [more]
article: SALFORD STAR ENTERTAINMENT AWARDS 2017 OPEN FOR NOMINATIONS
just wanna thank salford star for standing by us ting n ting ... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD PUBLIC MEETING ON FIGHTING UNEMPLOYMENT POVERTY AND AUSTERITY

Star date: 24th September 2017

TAKE BACK MANCHESTER FESTIVAL SEES ANTI-AUSTERITY MEETING

Fighting Unemployment, Poverty and Austerity
Saturday 30th September 1pm-3pm free
Working Class Movement Library

On the eve of the Tory Party Conference, the Mary Quaile Club is running a public meeting at Salford's Working Class Movement Library on Fighting Unemployment, Poverty and Austerity, with speakers Sean Mitchell, author of the book Struggle or Starve about Belfast riots, and Tameside Against The Cuts activist Charlotte Hughes.

Full details here...

KEN LOACH STARS IN FUNDRAISER FOR SALFORD RESOURCE CENTRE

Star date: 24th September 2017

KEN LOACH, JB BARRINGTON, RICKY TOMLINSON AND MORE

Films and Conversation with Ken Loach and Friends
Thursday 23rd November 4pm-midnight
Moston Miners' Centre £20/£10

Ken Loach, director of top films like I, Daniel Blake, Cathy Come Home and Looking For Eric, is to star in a fundraiser for Salford Unemployed and Community Resource Centre on Thursday 23rd November. Joining him are JB Barrington, Ricky Tomlinson and more, with tickets on sale now.

Full details here...

LANGWORTHY CORNERSTONE OPEN DAY AND SALFORD HISTORIES FESTIVAL

Star date: 23rd September 2017

LOCAL HISTORY GROUPS AND CORNERSTONE GO BACK TO THE FUTURE

Cornerstone Open Day and Salford Histories Festival
Saturday 30th September 10am-4pm
Langworthy Cornerstone free

Well over a dozen local history groups and community organisations have joined together for a Salford Histories Festival and Langworthy Cornerstone Open Day next Saturday, with competitions, activities, food and more.

Full details here...

MOORS MURDER PLAY COMES TO KINGS ARMS SALFORD

Star date: 23rd September 2017

DRAMA OF EVIL KILLERS MYRA HINDLEY AND IAN BRADY

Old Ground
Thursday 28th September to Sunday 8th October
Kings Arms £10/£12

Organised Chaos bring Old Ground to the Kings Arms this week. It's a dramatic account of a specific moment in the horrific story of the Moors Murderers: Myra Hindley's disturbing attempt to deny involvement in the gruesome crimes in a bid for freedom, and Ian Brady's effort to exact revenge on his ex-lover, as Ian Leslie reports.

Full details here...

SALFORD POVERTY TRUTH COMMISSION TO REPORT FINDINGS

Star date: 23rd September 2017

HAS POVERTY TRUTH COMMISSION ACHIEVED ANYTHING?

In July 2016 the Salford Poverty Truth Commission was launched to drive home some real life honesty to those shaping the city's present and future, and hopefully change something. Has it achieved anything? On October 6th, Commission members will be sharing some results in a free open event that anyone can attend.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx