HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
‘BONKERS’ PLANNING DECISION SEES SALFORD COUNCIL APPROVE UNAFFORDABLE FLATS BUT REJECT AFFORDABLE FLATS
 

Star date: 6th July 2018

CANON GREEN COURT DEVELOPMENT THROWN INTO UNCERTAINTY AS COUNCILLOR SLATES 'BONKERS' PLANNING DECISION

At yesterday's planning panel of Salford City Council, councillors approved plans for almost 300 private rent flats in Lower Broughton, and then rejected plans from Salix Homes for over 100 affordable rent flats at Canon Green Court.

Councillor Peter Wheeler, addressing the panel, said the decision was "bonkers". It had, of course, nothing to do with Fred Done and Urban Splash developments nearby.

Full details here... 


Yesterday, councillors sitting on Salford Council's planning panel had two decisions to make on developments in central Salford.

The first was centred on Countryside Properties' scheme for 299 private rent apartments in Lower Broughton that contained no affordable housing.*

The second was centred on Salix Homes re-applying for planning permission for 108 rent to buy 'affordable' apartments in the grounds of Canon Green Court and Westminster House after the application was rejected at the previous planning meeting.**

The Countryside Properties scheme was approved. The Salix Homes application was rejected again, despite modifications, on design grounds at the bidding of panel chair Councillor Ray Mashiter, on a close vote of six to four.

While the Salix development isn't popular with some social rent tenants who live in Canon Green Court, and the future flats were to be targeted at 'young professionals', at least there was some kind of affordability linked to the scheme via a proposed rent-to-buy scheme.

The decision was described by some of those who attended the meeting as "odd" and "strange", and even Councillor Derek Antrobus, head of planning, voted in favour of the Salix application against the advice of Councillor Mashiter.

Councillor Peter Wheeler summed it up to the panel when he said "It's bonkers. One minute we're bemoaning the lack of affordable houses at a scheme in Broughton, and then within ten minutes we're turning down over one hundred affordable properties less than a mile away."

It's almost as if affordable housing near Chapel Street is not wanted by the powers that be. Very close to the Salix Homes scheme is Fred Done's Blackfriars blocks of unaffordable flats currently being erected, and the Urban Splash blocks of unaffordable flats that were granted planning permission at last month's meeting.

A cynic might argue that the Salix Homes block would undercut these schemes, with a more attractive financial offer to prospective renters/buyers. But that would be cynical. Meanwhile, Salix Homes is expected to appeal the decision, and is 'exploring options'...

"We are disappointed by the decision of Salford Council's Planning Panel to refuse planning approval for a development that would refurbish the homes of our tenants at Canon Green and Westminster Courts and provide more than one hundred new affordable homes in the city" Sue Sutton, executive director of operations at Salix Homes told the Salford Star.

"We've ensured that our residents have been involved with our development proposals every step of the way and we remain fully committed to the refurbishment of our existing units" she added "We will now be exploring our options with colleagues at the council to ensure this decision does not get in the way of the essential improvement work to the existing blocks."

For a full background see previous Salford Star articles...

* Developer Avoids Affordable Housing Provision in Lower Broughton – click here

** Salix Homes 108 Rent To Buy Apartments at Canon Green Court – click here and Salix Homes Canon Green Decision Deferred – click here

Mike wrote
at 09:57:03 on 01 August 2018
I see that Salix have resubmitted this application. Can anything be construed from this?
 
Former resident wrote
at 07:18:17 on 11 July 2018
I wonder if there is some sort of split going on in Salford Labour Party. Just think.Perhaps 2 or 3 at most Torys on panel.Which ever way they vote, it doesn't matter, and this site is miles away from their voters. Perhaps the ones in Labour who know this is not affordable, are the ones who voted against, perhaps in a bid to draw attention to the other ones who voted in favour, so as to expose their polocies on affordability. When it comes to backstabbing Labour can show the Tories a trick or two. The tories do it openly Labour don't.
 
Joey wrote
at 21:13:34 on 08 July 2018
To F.DONE "Esq" (though I doubt that is who you are) you state "Let us Rob your Communal Public Sector Grounds to Hive-Off to the Private Sector". When I was a child in the 50's the location of these proposed flats was a row of Victorian shops with flats above. They were demolished sometime in the 80's and the area given to the block of flats as communal grounds. So no, it is not Communal Public Sector Grounds, it is private land plundered and purloined using public money which was then fenced in for the benefit of a select few at Cannon Green Court. I have NEVER seen anyone use this part of the communal grounds, and it should be put to better use. Whether the proposed building and its new residents would be best use is debatable, but it should be built on, preferably to provide truly affordable homes. To SS, if it really was refused because of site permeability, that is preposterous. At the moment the whole site and Cannon Green Court are surrounded by an impenetrable metal railing perimeter.
 
bob wrote
at 11:28:05 on 07 July 2018
" rents would be 80% of free market rate which they said was around £800 per month". that around £200 per week, who can afford that?. Someone is living in fantasy land making statements like that.
 
Former resident wrote
at 06:59:53 on 07 July 2018
I cannot get my head round this one.I was dead against the scheme in the first place. It is an over development, and it is for sure not affordable. Salix said rents would be 80% of free market rate which they said was around £800 per month. After 5 years they said people could buy the flats. These would not have been at a discount. A 2 bed flat there would be £180k to £200k. They would rely on inertia of people not wanting to move out. A big rip off to fuel the big wages of the Salix high command. Rest assured though, this mad scheme will go ahead. That is unless there is some funny games going on between the council and Salix that we do not know about.
 
F.DONE "Esq" wrote
at 06:59:36 on 07 July 2018
"Sue Sutton" Executive Director of Operations at Salix knows that when a Flat in Canon Green becomes vacant, that Flat is TOTALY REFURBISHED then Let out to over 30 Year Old who must be Employed. Meanwhile the existing Tenants get "CHOICE" when asking for Decent living Standard regards the currents state & quality of the Flats they Pay Full Rent for & Live in now! Let us Rob your Communal Public Sector Grounds to Hive-Off to the Private Sector or you can go Whistle & keep Living in squalor... Democracy : two Wolves & one Sheep around the table debating what to have for Tea...
 
Salford Star wrote
at 06:58:46 on 07 July 2018
See Joey's comment below...That's because, until the minutes are produced, nobody seems to know the exact causes and reasons. Something to do with the permeability of the site, if that helps
 
Joey wrote
at 06:56:14 on 07 July 2018
What were the reasons given for refusal? It seems odd to refuse this scheme but not others. I would like to know why they refused it so that I can make my mind up whether I agree with them or not. The article doesn't give me enough information to adequately assess the decision.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: GOVERNMENT BLOCKS SALFORD CLADDING REPLACEMENT
Yes Ray, my concern also is to see the tennants safe so get the shit ripped off straight away,but why pay for new stuff and try an... [more]
article: LOST SALFORD STREETS EXHIBITION
Searching for a picture of Charlotte Street, Hr. Broughton, Salford 7. My sister and I were born there and would love to have a pi... [more]
article: GOVERNMENT BLOCKS SALFORD CLADDING REPLACEMENT
I have one question which has bothered me from the start. Why did they started taking the cladding from the bottom first. Surely ... [more]
article: GOVERNMENT BLOCKS SALFORD CLADDING REPLACEMENT
Bob the regular,my prime concern is keeping tenants safe. My worry is that without someone breaking the log jam,this cock up will... [more]
article: GOVERNMENT BLOCKS SALFORD CLADDING REPLACEMENT
With our anger, and rage, we have all lost the plot with this one, and I more than anyone. Apart from Bernard that is. What a sens... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

GIG FOR THE PETERLOO HIDDEN PROJECT AT MOSTON MINERS CENTRE

Star date: 22nd September 2018

BENEFIT FOR PETERLOO HIDDEN PROJECT

Gig at The Miners
Saturday 6th October 7:30pm
Miners Community Arts and Music Centre, Moston

On 6th October there's to be a special gig at the Moston Miners Centre to raise funds for Red Saunders' Hidden Project, which is re-creating the Peterloo Massacre in photo tableaus. Starring on the night will be Claire Mooney, Matt Hill, Free Radicals and Tony Harper,.

Full details here...

RHYL TO SALFORD WALK FOR CAMPAIGN AGAINST LIVING MISERABLY

Star date: 22nd September 2018

50 PEOPLE, SIXTY MILES, £50,000 TARGET

When three close friends of Daniel Hobbs took their own lives, he and others decided to do something about it, and have now organised a sixty mile walk from Rhyl to Salford to raise money for the Campaign Against Living Miserably, which is leading a movement against suicide in young men. They've got an ambitious £50,000 target. Can you help?

Full details here...

MIKRON THEATRE COMES TO SALFORD WITH REVOLTING WOMEN

Star date: 23rd September 2018

HOW LONG DID IT TAKE WOMEN TO GET THE VOTE?

Revolting Women
Wednesday 3rd October 7:30pm £11/£9
St Peter and Paul's Church, Park Road

The superb Mikron Theatre arrive in Salford with a story based around radical socialist suffragette, Sylvia Pankhurst, complete with songs, satire and top stagecraft, perfected over 47 tours. Vote with your feet and don't miss!

Full details here...

SALFORD MUSIC FESTIVAL TWO NIGHTS TWO VENUES

Star date: 22nd September 2018

REN HARVIEU...BLANEY...MARK E SMITH TRIBUTE

Salford Music Festival
Friday 28th September Cobden Works
Saturday 29th September Gilda Brook
£10 (or £6 per night)

The Salford Music Festival is packing loads of bands into a two night happening, with Ren Harvieu heading the bill on Friday and Blaney heading up the Saturday line-up. Ian Leslie chats to Ren, or the self-described "Salford pineapple up-do mess" about the hometown gig.

Full details here...

ST PAUL’S CHURCHYARD TRAIL SALFORD

Star date: 22nd September 2018

GRAVE INTEREST IN KERSAL

St Paul's Churchyard Trail
Sunday 23rd September 11:30am
St Paul's Church, Kersal

Tomorrow, Sunday 23rd September, there's going to be a churchyard trail at St Paul's Church on Moor Lane in Kersal to learn some of the history of the important and interesting people buried there.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx