HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US   LINKS      
 

 
SALFORD COUNCIL MAD MAG COSTS
 

Star date: 26th January 2010
A Salford Star Exclusive 

COUNCIL MAG COSTS ALMOST £28,000 AN ISSUE…
as the Audit Commission states that "Claims about the value achieved by communication spending are not well supported by evidence"…

While the Salford Star struggles to get back into print, and the Salford Advertiser gives up free delivery to homes, we can reveal that Salford Council is spending almost £28,000 per month on its own Life In Salford magazine, the vast bulk of the costs being met by council taxpayers…

Full story here…


DEMOCRATIC STRIFE IN SALFORD

In the October 2009 issue of Salford Council's Life In Salford, a lady called Lyn, from Boothstown, wrote in saying that she'd like to see the magazine scrapped and the money spent on "necessities and not sending free magazines to all the households in Salford."

The reply, presumably from the Council, stated that "If we stopped producing the magazine we would not save any money as we would have to publish all our notices in a newspaper…and place adverts for events like Proms in the Park in local newspapers…"

Er, just one problem – for the vast majority of people living in Salford there is no `local newspaper' unless they're willing to fork out for it in local newsagents. Is it pure co-incidence that ten months on since Salford Council withdrew thousands of pounds worth of its advertising from the Salford Advertiser, the paper is no longer being delivered free to homes in Salford?

Figures obtained under the Freedom of Information Act show that over the eight issues of Life between March 2009 and October 2009, the Council spent just over £63,000 of its own advertising budget on Life in Salford magazine, as well as a further £36,664 subsidy to prop it up.

The average costs for actually printing and delivering Life in Salford over the eight issues were £107,719 (or £13,464 per issue). And while the Council says that it "does not hold records allocating staff costs to the publication", a report circulated to councillors as Life went monthly shows staff costs (`writing', photography, layout, graphics etc) at £1,870 per issue.

If our sums are right, the Council is spending an average of £15,335 per issue on actually producing the magazine, plus £7,879 from its own advertising budget which it puts down as `income', plus a subsidy of £4,583. This makes a total of £27,797 per month on Life in Salford magazine, or a yearly average total of £333,564.

Advertising income from outside the Council for these eight issues amounted to just over £19,000, most of it coming from publicly funded bodies like the NHS, The Lowry and government departments.

As the Council spends almost £28,000 per month on Life, an Audit Commission Review of Council Spending on Communication with the Public, published yesterday, states that "Claims about the value achieved by communication spending are not well supported by evidence"…

While the Review looked at `council periodicals' from a national perspective and therefore didn't come to any major critical conclusions, it did add that  "Councils need to assure themselves of the quality of their communications and the value of their communication spending".

Quality wise, some might say that Life has a lot to answer for – the current issue interviews the same businessman twice, the November issue carried two photos of Council Leader, John Merry, subliminally claiming responsibility for easing unemployment, and just over a year ago Lib Dem councillor Steve Cooke, resigned from Life's editorial board arguing that the magazine "provided a thin veneer of democratic respectability to an often misleading and relentlessly and unjustifiably upbeat publication".

We would argue that Salford Council spending £333,564 of Salford residents' council tax on its own publication has profound implications for democracy and accountability. While the Salford Star and the Salford Advertiser are only available free online, an estimated two thirds of Salford's population do not have access to the internet.

The only free printed information people are now getting about their city comes courtesy of Salford City Council and its Life in Salford magazine. With no criticism of the Council, no debate, no accountability, low quality content and bucket loads of public money showered all over it…

What Salford Council spends just on staff for Life magazine per month (£1870) would sustain the printing and production of the Salford Star indefinitely…

 


* The Salford Advertiser has stopped delivering to sections of postcode areas M4/M5/M7....while M3 never got it.

Brian wrote
at 3:00:48 AM on Sunday, January 31, 2010
David, i don't know if you know this but our dear SALFORD advertiser stopped delivering in our neck of the woods Many Many Moons ago(I call it Ordsall, They now call it Central Salford, Or the Quays - depending on who you talk to), . The Advertiser Group (part of GMEN plc) closed down the Liverpool St end of their operation when the reporter & advertiser amalgamated - till then they were a seperate organisation, with their own editor, sub-editor and area reporters and photographers Upon Merging they were flung to the five corners of the advertiser groups empire - Rochdale, Bury, South Manchester and all, if i recollect correctly the deputy ed ended up in Rochdale. Liverpool St Closed and a skeleton staff moved into Church St (Eccles). As a result Deliveries stopped in my area (Central Salford), but you could still get it for 30p (at last purchase)at your newsagent (And i Thought it was a freesheet!!!) Thing is now the Advertiser brand has been swallowed up by the Guardian Group, there's going to be no news on the local community unless theres somekind of political slant to it, and having heard our Humble leaders have got their pawprints truly and honestly on the newsprint, It no longer fits the purpose on which it was supposed to serve. In addition The 4 other S's on the city badge keep on insisting they're mancunian (or from bury/bolton/wigan - depending on the border) so they get the advertiser just to remind them where they are!!! Whats required is a freesheet that serves the people of the community of salford, giving news in an independant and fair view of the areas of salford. We had it in the Salford Star (till one or two decided to be a little overzealous and bit the hand that fed you), but this publication needs to be back in print - not just on here!
 
satnav2000 wrote
at 11:44:47 PM on Thursday, January 28, 2010
As Brian above has stated,i have also notest the advrtiser seem over the last 3 months that it sertenley seems (yery concerninglay) to be now giving a slanted view in favor of certain prominent council figers and MP why is this just of late one must ask? Should not a local paper take a neatrel stance? Or has it anythig to do with the forth coming elections.I am not alone on thinking this as outher Salford pople have also exsprest this to me.
 
Salford lad wrote
at 3:35:49 PM on Thursday, January 28, 2010
Just a thought - why don't you do a newspaper instead of a magazine? It is much, much cheaper.
 
David Henry wrote
at 2:25:26 AM on Thursday, January 28, 2010
Brian has a point, although it's great we can read the Advertiser online there are articles omitted from the web version, not to mention all the local classifieds which many smaller local businesses and trades-people rely upon... Those 2/3rds of Salford residents who do not have regular internet access or skills who will also no longer get a printed copy may be more understanding IF the Advertiser pledged to roll it out to ALL newsagents as they do with the M.E.N several times a day - especially in the areas that home deliveries have ceased. I've asked all the local newsagents within a mile and a half radius of M7, none of whom stock it (Broughton Wines on Great Cheetham Street tell me they stopped selling it in August as they stopped receiving it - but would sell it otherwise). Plus - where are we "peasant-folk" going to read the utterly interesting "Hazel Blears" column now?! :) Surely Hazel's office must be informed!
 
Brian wrote
at 12:30:58 PM on Wednesday, January 27, 2010
wouldn't it just be better for the council to just buy the advertiser off the guardian group ? All i can see at the moment are two publications with a council-slanted view of things. Of course, if the advertiser remembered they are a local newspaper and sent copy to all newsagents in the area, we might forgive its shortcomings.
 
Em 3 wrote
at 12:30:12 PM on Wednesday, January 27, 2010
this is scandlous! I'm interested that the Lowry are paying for adverts as they don't seem to have the money to offer their own staff proper contracts and any security at all. Some were very frightened of speaking out + even more frightened of getting ill or pregnant - because that would mean you'd lose your job! When will the council realise that a good council is one that invites both positive and negative comments. People want a paper that gives them a voice - not a glossy load of lies. Some of the real truth came out on the recent NEWSNIGHT. I hope the councillors felt their necks go red with shame when they watched it.
 
john wrote
at 11:55:46 AM on Tuesday, January 26, 2010
£28.000 and it goes straight in the bin why because there is not one derogatery remark in it how can this be true of salford council everything is sweetness and light according to there propoganda sheet . may i suggest the good people of salford write to the council asking them to scrap the the mag and knock the £333,564 off the next council tax increase
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
Salford Star photo stories
Cornerstone advert
Mary Burns Publishing
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: GREATER MANCHESTER CAMPAIGNS BAZAAR
Hello, is it too late for us to attend and showcase our campaign? Save Bury's Children's Centres. https://www.facebook.com/s... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL DANCING WITH DANGER TO ELDERLY
@Beryl Hawke, no Beryl I am afraid they can't, Salford councils so called "Community Committees" will no longer pay rents for exis... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL DANCING WITH DANGER TO ELDERLY
These ladies and 2 gentleman can apply to their Community Committees devolve budget for the rent of the Community rooms. Their com... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL DANCING WITH DANGER TO ELDERLY
If only their hobby was rugby league and not line dancing. SCC would have no problem financially supporting their community ventur... [more]
article: SALFORD COUNCIL DANCING WITH DANGER TO ELDERLY
So the failed ex leader of the council John Merry whose only claim to fame was that whilst in office he brought Scary "overpaid" S... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

GREATER MANCHESTER CAMPAIGNS BAZAAR

Star date: 22nd November 2014

CAMPAIGNING GROUPS FROM ALL OVER THE AREA ON SHOW

Greater Manchester Campaigns Bazaar
Thursday 27th November from 7pm
Manchester Academy 2 free

This Thursday, the Salford Star will join up to fifty community and campaign groups at a showcase organised by Manchester MULE at Manchester Academy 2. There'll be stalls, videos and talks by organisations ranging from Red Pepper to the Greater Manchester Living Wage Campaign to Save Our NHS and Art Emergency, with a debate on the state of local activism.

Full details here...

LOWER BROUGHTON CHILDREN’S CENTRE SALFORD SURVIVAL STORY

Star date: 21st November 2014

SALFORD COUNCIL WANTED IT CLOSED – IT'S STILL OPEN!

Last spring, Salford Council announced plans to shut Lower Broughton Children's Centre at River View School as part of cuts to Sure Start buildings all over the city. The parents ran a huge campaign to save their centre and today it's still open five mornings a week.

As the next round of Salford Council cuts begin to leak out, the parents are adamant that the community should fight to save services... "Without the campaign we wouldn't have what we have now" says Elaine Connolly.

Full details here...

SALFORD COUNCIL DANCING WITH DANGER TO ELDERLY

Star date: 20th November 2014

SALFORD COUNCIL IMPOSES ROOM CHARGES IN GATEWAYS

"For some of our most vulnerable and older people this club is a lifeline..." Councillor John Warmisham

Salford Council is being accused of letting down the old and the vulnerable after it introduced charges for community rooms in the Gateway Centre spaces it leases from the MaST LIFT Company, to which it pays extortionate rents.

At Pendleton Gateway, Salford Council's new huge room hire charges for groups like the Golden Girls line dancing class is threatening to isolate elderly people who use the activity to socialise and keep fit. Now the class may have to close or move.

Full details here...

SALFORD COUNCIL MEETING LIVE-STREAM BY SALFORD STAR

Star date: 18th November 2014

ROLL UP ROLL UP FOR THE SALFORD COUNCIL SHOW...

Tomorrow, Wednesday 19th November there's a full meeting of Salford Council which will be live-streamed by Salford Star from 9:30am to 12:30pm on its Bambuser Channel.

Roll up, roll up, for the amazing Housing Strategy for Salford, which pulled a massive four responses from the public after a long Council consultation. Thrill to a motion on the air quality that's killing us all. And take the Salford Star challenge to stay awake during the Salford City Mayor's verbal meanderings. Too good to miss?

7pm 19th November:: Full report and update and link to live-stream

Full details here...

IGAS SHARE PRICE TANKS AS TRAFFORD COUNCIL REJECTS FRACKING

Star date: 17th November 2014

FRACKING INDUSTRY FRACKED AS IGAS SHARES COLLAPSE

Fracking company IGas, which is determined to plough on with shale gas exploration in Salford, has seen its share price collapse from a high of 160 points in January to just 56 this morning.

Meanwhile, last week, Trafford Council voted to ban fracking `until proven safe', and all court cases regarding the Barton Moss protests have been postponed until the New Year pending investigations of the IGas site, the Salford Star understands.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx