HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
SALFORD STAR MARY BURNS AWARDS 2009
 

MARY BURNS AWARDS
DAY 20

THE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION OF THE YEAR AWARD PART 3

Are community consultations worth the paper they are written on? Do the community's views really count? The Mary Burns Community Consultation Awards not only ask these questions but also try and answer them.

In Part 1 we showed that the community's voice counted for less than 25% of the final decision, and in Part 2 we showed a group that didn't even exist being consulted, and an admission from the Leader of Salford City Council that the consultation, er, "hasn't been perfect". Now join us in Part 3 for twisted statistics and more…

Ladies and Gentlemen. THE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION OF THE YEAR AWARD PART 3…goes to…

Please do a drum roll and click here…


 


SALFORD CITY COUNCIL, SALIX HOMES and the CENTRAL SALFORD URBAN REGENERATION COMPANY – FOR THEIR FAB WORK ON THE ISLINGTON ESTATE.

Last February residents in Islington were asked to vote on five Options for the future of their estate. They voted for Options 2 and 3 with `a significant proportion of residents opposed to demolition', according to a report by consultants GVA Grimley.

What the residents eventually got was somewhere between Options 3 and 4, with significant demolition, because "the views of residents were then combined with additional stakeholder consultation, a financial appraisal and a review of the strategic regeneration criteria of the partner organisations Salford City Council, Central Salford Urban Regeneration Company (URC) and Salix Homes"…
 
The new `preferred option' was then presented to residents as a future that would see `85% of the existing homes retained and improved' and `just 15% of the estate demolished'. This is only true, of course, if you count every flat in the two big high rise towerblocks, Canon Hussey Court and Arthur Millwood Court, as a property in its own right. What they didn't shout about was that 60% of low rise homes (46 properties) on the estate were to be demolished.

The majority of residents, the consultants report explained, were actually `happy' with Option 1, with no major changes at all, just improvements to everyone's homes. But, as a further report by Salford Council noted, this option (keeping all social housing) was seen as "potentially harmful to the wider regeneration of the area". The `preferred option' of 60% low rise demolition "complements the redevelopment of Chapel Street into the future". 

Chapel Street is, of course, right next to Manchester city centre, and is seen as being the new up market `centre of Salford'. A view underlined by the majority of developers consulted who argued that they would only get involved if the whole estate was bulldozed…

Lo and behold, when the `preferred option' with its large amount of demolitions was put to the Government for PFI funding, it was rejected as it was "not transformational enough"… no doubt, because there was still some social housing left standing for poor people!

Community consultations – don't you just love 'em?

Ladies and Gentlemen. Break out your Monopoly boards for the winners of THE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION OF THE YEAR AWARD PART 3…

SALFORD CITY COUNCIL, SALIX HOMES and the CENTRAL SALFORD URBAN REGENERATION COMPANY

Applause…

If anyone from these organisations would like to make a speech please fill in the Comments box below

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

mad salix wrote
at 06:52:33 on 11 January 2010
Great award! You can also add that in the last `Islington Update' newsletter it says that 87% of residents were happy with the way they had been consulted, although almost half of them (46%)didn't understand `how the Preferred Option had been arrived at'!!! It's got the council and developers paw prints all over it!!! These consultations are complete shams...
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SALFORD MP SHOULD BE DESELECTED AFTER KEEPING TORIES IN POWER SAYS CONSTITUENT
Slurp, thè real hypocrits are Labour Mps,such as Stringer,Mann and Hoey who are clearly "useful idiots" for the Tory Right!... [more]
article: SALFORD MP SHOULD BE DESELECTED AFTER KEEPING TORIES IN POWER SAYS CONSTITUENT
Labour is led by a man who has voted against his own party's line over 600 times in his parliamentary career. But when someone e... [more]
article: SALFORD UNIVERSITY SACKS TOP PROFESSOR FOR FAILING TO CHASE MONEY
I have had the pleasure of being taught by Jim for the past two years and found him to be the most approachable, helpful, and down... [more]
article: SALFORD UNIVERSITY SACKS TOP PROFESSOR FOR FAILING TO CHASE MONEY
Years ago An old boy of my school who had risen to a very high place in the health service estates section told me what a bunch of... [more]
article: SALFORD UNIVERSITY SACKS TOP PROFESSOR FOR FAILING TO CHASE MONEY
Appalling that some jobsworth could end a career by ticking a box! Well done prof for standing up for education over profit! Hope ... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD UNIVERSITY SACKS TOP PROFESSOR FOR FAILING TO CHASE MONEY

Star date: 20th July 2018

PROTEST AT THE LOWRY AS STUDENTS GET DEGREES

Yesterday, as students received their degrees at The Lowry, Professor James Newell and UCU supporters were outside raising awareness of how the University of Salford sacked him, after 27 years service, for basically failing to chase money in what has become a national cause against the marketisation of education.

Almost 3,500 people have signed a petition calling for Professor Newell's reinstatement, as he told the Salford Star that marketisation "is the essential issue that underlies the exorbitant fees that students have to pay..."

Full details here...

SALFORD SCHOOL SHUTS AS PARENTS AND PUPILS PROTEST HEAD TEACHER SUSPENSION

Star date: 19th July 2018

HARROP FOLD CLOSES FOR THE DAY DUE TO PROTEST

As pupils and parents prepared to protest the suspension of Harrop Fold head teacher, Drew Povey, and three other staff, the school closed today citing the "distressing effect on our students".

Some pupils, parents and members of the community did show up outside the school gates anyway, with one parent saying the suspensions were "unjust...He needs to be here doing his job".

Full details here...

SALFORD MP SHOULD BE DESELECTED AFTER KEEPING TORIES IN POWER SAYS CONSTITUENT

Star date: 19th July 2018

CALLS FOR GRAHAM STRINGER TO BE DESELECTED FOR 'TREACHERY'

On Tuesday night, Blackley and Broughton MP, Graham Stringer, was one of four Labour Party MPs who voted with the Tories on the latest Brexit proposals, allowing Theresa May to scrape to victory by three votes and avert a possible General Election.

Here, a constituent of the Salford MP and Labour Party member, gives her personal opinion, joining the call for Graham Stringer to be deselected...

Full details here...

PEPPA PIG COMMUNISM GRAFFITI GOES SUBVERSIVE IN SALFORD

Star date: 18th July 2018

'COMMUNISM IS FOR THE CHILDREN' SAYS SUBVERSIVE PEPPA PIG

Bizarre graffiti art has appeared near Salford Central Station depicting two delighted looking Peppa Pigs by the slogan 'Communism is for the children'. The art has led to much amusement and bemusement but is probably related to China banning the popular kids' cartoon.

Full details here...

SALFORD TOWERBLOCK CLADDING RESIDENTS UNITE TO TACKLE PENDLETON TOGETHER

Star date: 18th July 2018

SPRUCE COURT AND THORN COURT TENANTS GET ORGANISED TO FIGHT BACK

"We're sick to death of being treated like dirt..."

Last night, tenants from Spruce Court and Thorn Court met to share concerns over dangerous cladding, fire safety, security and other issues, as they united to take on towerblock manager Pendleton Together and Salford City Council, which owns the blocks.

"They try to ignore what we're saying" insisted one tenant "They're complacent... we're sick to death of being treated like dirt...".

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx