HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
PARLIAMENT INVESTIGATES 'INEFFECTUAL' LOCAL GOVERNMENT SCRUTINY
 

Star date: 30th October 2017

IS DEMOCRACY FAILING IN SALFORD?

Today, Parliament's Communities and Local Government Committee is investigating 'Overview and scrutiny in local government', which is basically about the effectiveness of councillors gate-keeping local democracy.

Representations to the Committee have been absolutely scathing about the limp wristed approach to 'Overview and scrutiny', or O&S. The minutes of the last such session at Salford City Council record just three lines of notes from a meeting totally devoted to the Swinton Lions loan; while, this week, O&S will scrutinising the mushrooming borrowing at the Council. Will O&S councillors understand it? Do they care?

Full details here...


Overview and scrutiny committees in local government are supposed to be forums for councillors to hold the leaders and Cabinets of councils to account. But Parliament's Communities and Local Government Committee looking at these Overview and scrutiny committees, or O&S, has been hearing of their inept existence.

At the last session of the Committee, halted by the General Election, one letter of written evidence was received from someone who wished to remain anonymous...

"I find that there are perhaps three types of Members in a Local Authority" he wrote "One, those that are content to receive the 'salary' and do little; Two, those that see it as a sounding board to further a political career and have little time for the well-being of the populace, and unfortunately a lowly Third, those whose desire is to better the services for the people whom they represent..."

Now, normally this could be written off as the 'green ink brigade' but this guy states that his wife was actually the chair of a scrutiny committee at his local council!

Meanwhile, evidence from the Local Government Research Unit at De Montfort University added that "Although whips are not supposed to be employed in O&S it is clear from research that a self-imposed whip can operate with councillors from ruling groups often reluctant to challenge, criticise and question executive members from their own party...

"Majority and minority group councillors have indicated that executive accountability, because of party loyalty and discipline can, if left unchecked, turn scrutiny into a meaningless ritual" the University explained.

On 16th October, the Committee resumed its hearing with Chair, Labour MP Clive Betts, opening the sessions... "We have asked people about their views on overview and scrutiny" he said "There have been some pretty derogatory comments in with the evidence we have received, saying that it is ineffectual and passive. Those words have been used. It was described as a 'pleasant little talking shop' and something to keep councillors employed who have not got any executive functions. Is that a fair summary of what actually goes on?"

'No, no, no' replied those with a vested interest... 'Yes, yes, yes' replied those with no vested interest...Today, there's another load of councillors and bureaucrats giving evidence, including the only local person, Susan Ford, Scrutiny Manager at Greater Manchester Combined Authority.

Meanwhile, on 1st November, Salford City Council's O&S Board meets. The agenda for this week's session includes the minutes of the last meeting, devoted almost entirely to the £60,000 loan given to Swinton Lions, and agreed by Deputy Mayor, John Merry in secret at a non-executive meeting where no other councillors were present.

The scrutiny of the loan was held with the 'exclusion of the public' and the minutes record just three lines of what was discussed... "Councillor Merry attended the meeting to outline the circumstances leading to the decision that he had taken in relation to Swinton Lions Rugby Club. He and Councillor Hinds, as Lead Member for Finance and Support Services, responded to questions from members." Transparency at its finest!

This week's O&S has a Treasury Management Strategy Mid Year Review that shows some truly scary financial figures, particularly if anyone can make head or tail of what's going on...

Buried in the report to the Board are tables showing a rise in capital expenditure this year, from £68.7million to £110.2million, and the borrowing requirement rising from an original estimate of £29million to £69.1million.

Another table shows the 'operational boundary for external debt' for the year rising from an original estimate of £471.6million to £780.8million; while a different table showing 'authorised limit for external debt' puts the total debt limit rising from £571.6million to £851.3million.

In all these figures are sums included for sorting the tower block cladding, for building the Embankment at Greengate, the RHS Garden in Worsley and the crippling PFI payments. Basically if the interest rates go up more than expected, the Council could be knackered...

The report ends that "Members are requested to note these changes detailed in
appendix 2"...which are completely different figures from those shown previously in the gobbledygook.

...Do the councillors sat on the O&S Board have the financial knowledge and understanding to challenge any of this? Can they challenge it? Is there a will to challenge it? Do the councillors care? Are the officers who prepare these reports making them deliberately confusing?

There is loads of evidence to the Parliament Committee on the problem of 'one party councils' and the unhealthy closeness of senior officers to the political leadership. It's summed up by Professor Copus of De Montfort University giving oral evidence to the Committee on 16th October...

"For officers in particular, it is also fair to say that there is sometimes a problem" he states "They will often be career-minded people who operate within a hierarchical
organisation. If their position within that hierarchy is such that they are not taken as seriously or powerfully as they might be, then scrutiny can suffer as a consequence, in terms of access to information.

"Some officers might be reluctant to provide members with information that enables
them to challenge either the leadership or indeed senior officers above them" he adds "All those sorts of dynamics come into the process..."


The Parliamentary sessions continue, with the brief: "The Committee will therefore seek to establish whether the overview and scrutiny model is meeting its objectives and to highlight examples where scrutiny has worked well, and instances where it has not. Local authorities have significant discretion on how they deliver the scrutiny function, and the Committee will consider how decision-makers can best be held to account..."

To see more written and oral evidence – click here

Main photo shows Clive Betts MP in action...

Truth 4 Langworthy wrote
at 12:58:14 PM on Tuesday, October 31, 2017
I travel through Langworthy every day and am gob smacked to hear so many people unhappy with Salford Council. I demand truth on housing, schools, social care, bin emptying and to be told the facts on what local people are getting for the high rents and high council tax. Truth. Now. Today. As we have the right to know. No cuckoo here just honest Michael J. Felse demanding Truth First in Langworthy to showcase the best way ahead for all Salford people.
 
wrote
at 9:48:37 AM on Tuesday, October 31, 2017
"If I was a councillor" Felse lives in a parallel universe or, as we know it, cloud cuckoo land.
 
Michael James Felse wrote
at 1:22:07 AM on Tuesday, October 31, 2017
I would reveal all if I was a Councillor. I hope the Council call the Langworthy Election I would ask 10 electors to help me prove the residents in Salford have a right to demand all the facts.
 
Joe O'Neill wrote
at 10:50:57 AM on Monday, October 30, 2017
The Panels are controlled by Labour the Chairs on 95% of the committee's are Labour, the reality we the electorate of Salford through chronic apathy have allowed this to happen there are no checks or balances. But no matter how much the issues are raised no one gives a toss, Sad the state of Local politics,
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SALFORD COUNCILLORS COULD BE CUT IN BOUNDARY COMMISSION REVIEW
I could name three from my ward that should be culled.... [more]
article: SALFORD CITY MAYOR MISLEADING STATEMENTS ON DEVELOPER CASH
Is it possible the Star could get a hold of the facts and figures of how many times the Council has challenged developers (if at a... [more]
article: OVER 1500 SALFORD PEOPLE SIGN PETITION AGAINST BUILDING IN BUILE HILL PARK
Here's an idea. On May 3rd you have a vote. Find out which councillor is on your side and vote for them. If they support this deve... [more]
article: SALFORD CITY MAYOR MISLEADING STATEMENTS ON DEVELOPER CASH
Sorry if my little piece is slightly off, it's with me pissing my self reading Mr Dennett's love child complaining of bullying. T... [more]
article: SALFORD PHOTO ARCHIVE GIVEAWAY
Hi Paul. I lived for my first 8 or so years on Pine Street off Hough Lane in Lower Broughton (1966-74) All very long gone obvious... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD MINERS REMEMBERED AT AGECROFT MEMORIAL

Star date: 22nd April 2018

RESPECT PAID TO IRWELL VALLEY MINERS

Yesterday, former miners, families and trade unionists gathered at the Agecroft Colliery monument to pay respects to those who lost their lives down the pits...

"Today means everything, it's the only way we can pay back what they did for you" said Jackie Rimmer, whose father died down Agecroft Colliery in 1963.

Full details here...

SALFORD CITY FC WIN PROMOTION TO VANARAMA NATIONAL LEAGUE

Star date: 22nd April 2018

SALFORD CITY ONE STEP AWAY FROM FOOTBALL LEAGUE

Salford City FC became champions of the National League North yesterday, despite losing 2-1 to Boston United. Harrogate Town's defeat at Bradford Park Avenue means that no-one can now catch the Class of '92 club.

Full details here...

SALFORD COMMUNITY WOOD CARVING CLUB OPENS AT ECCLES CENTRE

Star date: 22nd April 2018

EXHIBITION OF SALFORD WOOD CARVINGS OPENS NEW UNEMPLOYED ARTS CLUB

An exhibition of ninety wood carvings, featuring everything from birds to animals, to wood spirits and politicians, has opened at the Salford Unemployed and Community Resource Centre.

The exhibition will kickstart a new Salford Unemployed Arts Club based at the Centre, where anyone who is unemployed or disabled can meet and try wood carving or any other creative activity.

Full details here...

NEW SALFORD ‘CLEAN’ COMEDY NIGHT HUGE SUCCESS IN IRLAMS O’ TH’ HEIGHT

Star date: 22nd April 2018

CAN 'CLEAN' COMEDY WORK IN SALFORD? ABSOLUTELY!

This week saw a trial 'clean comedy' night at The Vine Cafe in Irlams O' Th' Height, with five comics wowing the sold out venue, and not a swear word or lewd reference in earshot...

"It had to be right kind of acts" explained organiser Sally Griffiths, as the mix of new performers and professionals pulled off the clean comedy night with aplomb (ooh, er, missus...).

Full details here...

COSMIC SHAMBLES RELEASE DEBUT SINGLE IN SALFORD

Star date: 21st April 2018

GRUNGY PSYCHEDELIA FROM COSMIC SHAMBLES

The name of the band kind of describes the sound of Cosmic Shambles, a band that released its debut single, All Over Now, via Salford City Radio. The Shambles range from grungy to psychedelia, as Ian Leslie discovers...

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx