HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
FINAL BARTON MOSS TRIAL ENDS WITH NOT GUILTY VERDICTS
 

Star date: 27th April 2016

CALLS FOR PUBLIC INQUIRY AS FINAL THREE BARTON MOSS CHARGES QUASHED

After hundreds of charges brought by the Crown in relation to the Barton Moss anti-fracking protests of 2013 and 2014, the final three cases were heard today at Manchester Magistrates Court where the judge delivered `not guilty' verdicts on charges of aggravated trespass.

Now, with the overwhelming number of charges either dropped or quashed, there's a growing call for a Public Inquiry into the policing and cost of the response to the Salford protests...

Full details here...


Barton Moss Not Guilty Verdicts Barton Moss Not Guilty Verdicts
click image to enlarge

"The results today must add to the increasing demand for a Public Inquiry into the method of policing and cost to the public purse..." Simon Pook, solicitor

Today at Manchester Magistrates Court, `not guilty' verdicts were announced for three protectors charged with aggravated trespass at the Barton Moss anti-fracking protests which raged during the latter part of 2013 and early 2014.

Annabel Newfield, Stephen Jefferies and Laura Parkes participated in the slow walk demonstration on 18th February 2014 at the IGas exploratory drilling site in Salford, when they were pulled from the crowd and arrested during one of the nastiest police operations throughout the whole protest (see Salford Star report from the day - Salford Residents Shock at GMP Policing click here).

The judge was shown footage, taken by both the police and an anti-fracking livestreamer, heard evidence from police officers present at the time and concluded that the prosecution case `contradicted the evidence' before him.

In common with previous Barton Moss cases and, given the right to peaceful slow walk protests in front of delivery lorries, the charges centred on whether the accused were engaged in `unreasonable behaviour', resisting efforts by the police to `encourage' them to walk by leaning back into officers; or whether the police were actually pushing them down the lane that led to the IGas site.

In giving evidence, the TAU's [Tactical Aid Unit] officer Bevan and other officers conceded that the TAU were brought in at certain points in the protest to increase the pace of the slow walks... "That's the only reason we would be deployed" said Bevan "To speed things up."

The officers also conceded that the three were not swearing or being abusive in any way, although PC Bolt insisted that Annabel Newfield was resisting walking... "It was a constant lean with her full body weight"...

Annabel's solicitor sardonically replied "She's not a sizeable lady is she? She shouted at you to stop pushing her."

Meanwhile, the court heard that former serviceman and current firefighter, Stephen Jefferies, had gone to the protest wearing an army beret and medals in an effort to "break down the stereotype of protesters" and had tried to engage the police in dialogue throughout the slow walk, until he was arrested...

"All the prosecution has shown is that he didn't walk quickly enough and that doesn't amount to unreasonable behaviour" argued his barrister, Richard Brigden.

Passing `not guilty' verdicts, the judge said that at no point did he see any of the defendants leaning backwards and that there was "no consistency" in the pace of the walk that the police imposed. He concluded that all three defendants were of good character and that "I broadly accept their evidence".

The `not guilty' verdicts bring to a close the Barton Moss trials, which have seen the vast majority of charges either dropped or quashed. Indeed, a report into the policing at Barton Moss by John Moores University and York University - titled Keep Moving! - concluded that the Greater Manchester Police operation "was driven by interests other than public order and crime prevention".

It added that the operation "served to physically clear protesters from the site, to deter others from attending the camp and to reinforce the construction of protesters as violent criminals and thereby legitimise the intensity of the policing operation".

According to the report's statistics of court cases related to Barton Moss, up until February this year there was a conviction rate of only 26%, while the conviction rate for public order offences nationally is as high as 96%. It all leaves a lot of questions unanswered...

Richard Brigden, of leading human rights chambers Garden Court North, has, together with Simon Pook of Lizar Solicitors, defended the right to lawful peaceful protest and held the state to account for its actions.

"I welcome the result today, it further highlights the overwhelming theme of innocence" Simon Pook told the Salford Star after today's verdicts "The results today must add to the increasing demand for  a Public Inquiry into the method of policing and cost to the public purse."

The sentiment was underlined by Stephen Jefferies outside court this afternoon...

"It's been a long two years, like a dark cloud hanging over me because I have had to answer to a judge but I also have to answer to my employer as firefighter as well, so the fear of losing my job has been constantly there in the background and given me sleepless nights" he explained.

"I'm pleased but it's tinged with a bit of annoyance that it's actually taken this long, especially with the money it's cost" he said "It seems to me that there wasn't much of a case against us, as was shown today. But they still relentlessly pursued it at public expense.

"I think when David Cameron says that no expense will be spared in the pursuit of fracking, this is what he means, that he will pursue every single protester and take them through court to try and scare them off from doing it again" he added "Justice was done today, although there are some people who were found guilty and will feel that they've had an injustice, as they are equally as innocent as us."

Annabel Newfield felt the same emotions... "It's been two years and three months since we were arrested at Barton Moss and it just seems so ridiculous that we even got arrested in the first place" she said "It just felt really stupid that they took my freedom. I'm incredibly happy with this verdict, which is a just verdict, because we didn't do anything wrong. We just exercised our peaceful right to protest."


To read the Keep Moving! Report click here

Or see the Salford Star article on the report in print issue 11 click here for the electronic version



wrote
at 12:18:11 AM on Friday, April 29, 2016
THREE CHEERS for Simon Pook and his colleagues at Lizars Solicitors THREE CHEERS to the SALFORD STAR and the 2 STEVES for their work in covering the Anti Fracking movement,,, THREE CHEERS to the PROTECTORS who endured the daily onslaughts by GMP thugs THREE CHEERS to the supporters who fed , watered , and generally made the protectors welcome , comfortable , and supported John Defo Catterall On behalf of the admins of the FB page..... Say No To Fracking On Barton Moss

Jane Smith wrote
at 10:47:25 AM on Thursday, April 28, 2016
Glad that the results show the truth, that peaceful protection of the land, should not be met with extreme violence from the G.M.P. Some protectors were seriously harmed, and need compensation. Preston New Road, is one of the other proposed fracking sites, will the police continue, their use of violence to defend the right of private companies to industrialise our countryside and poison our land, water and air?

Jim wrote
at 10:46:43 AM on Thursday, April 28, 2016
GMP are rotten http://www.policebrutality.co.uk and the courts are just as bad.

Diane Steels wrote
at 4:14:07 AM on Thursday, April 28, 2016
So glad that we got the right result for the final cases. to have these trials hanging over everyone for the past 2 years has been disgraceful . As has the total waste of taxpayers money to police the protest and again to fund the cases brought. We will NEVER stop until Fracking is banned. Thanks go to The Salford Star for their excellent coverage throughout the campaign.

Robert Davies wrote
at 4:14:02 AM on Thursday, April 28, 2016
The Police are no longer fit for purpose, even Andy Burnham has hinted that in parliament, this decline seems to have originated since the Miners strikes, when they were paid for by us but used by the corporations and government to push their own agendas. Meanwhile, while 80 or so police were forcing a dozen or so protesters up the road, burglaries were being refused attendance with excuses that "there isn't the manpower". The police force needs rebanding and reminding who pays them, the council tax payers.

Fran Jones wrote
at 1:26:54 AM on Thursday, April 28, 2016
Great news. This bullying from companies wanting to destroy our water, aided by the police that we pay to protect us not harrass us or intimidate us, has to change.. Brave protesters!

James Larkin wrote
at 4:11:30 PM on Wednesday, April 27, 2016
Well done Sakford Star bringing the news to the public attention. It is clear to those who have followed the prosecutions that the Police Crime Commissioner is a puppet to Greater Manchester Police and acted to justify states repression of peaceful practice. Two word FRACK OFF!

Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: IS IRLAMS O TH HEIGHT THE HARDEST PLACE TO SPELL IN BRITAIN?
I don't understand why they got it wrong now, the farewell signage at the exit always said Irlams O' Th' Height.... [more]
article: THE DEATH OF SOCIAL RENT PROPERTIES IN SALFORD?
Millionaire Felse should stand in Langworthy for the Tories. A fight between political left and right will be good for us Salford.... [more]
article: IS IRLAMS O TH HEIGHT THE HARDEST PLACE TO SPELL IN BRITAIN?
Not forgetting of course that it also gets confused with that other part of Salford - Irlam. When I use my card in the Height Ald... [more]
article: THE DEATH OF SOCIAL RENT PROPERTIES IN SALFORD?
Hedley your are wrong. It not only takes 2 but 25,000 to have a Langworthy By Election. Labour cannot afford it and Langworthy i... [more]
article: THE TREEHOUSE CAFE OPENS IN LOWER BROUGHTON FOR THE SALFORD COMMUNITY
This is fabulous, great community spirit , I'm sure lots of us will visit and look forward to meeting the lovely staff .... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD HOMELESS MAN HAS TO GET LEG AMPUTATED TO HAVE A HOME

Star date: 23rd October 2017

SHOCKING INDICTMENT OF UNFAIR WELFARE SYSTEM

'For the first time in his life he became a priority...'

Pat Mullen was homeless for over twenty years and, as a single man with drug and alcohol issues, was always bottom of the list for housing. Because of his chaotic circumstances, Pat became ill and recently had to have a leg amputated. Only then could he get somewhere to live, as, for the first time in his life, he became a priority...

"If he hadn't had a leg amputated he would still be on the streets" says his brother, John "...No-one is listening."

Full details here...

THE TREEHOUSE CAFE OPENS IN LOWER BROUGHTON FOR THE SALFORD COMMUNITY

Star date: 22nd October 2017

SHOW STOPPER CAKES, OWN BLEND COFFEE AND COMMUNITY VIBE

The TreeHouse cafe opened last month on the corner of Lower Broughton Road and Cromwell Road, complete with own-blend coffee, show stopper home-made cakes and an interior full of upcycled and recycled furniture. The owners are keen to get involved with the community, offering a meeting space and children's activities.

Full details here...

IS IRLAMS O TH HEIGHT THE HARDEST PLACE TO SPELL IN BRITAIN?

Star date: 22nd October 2017

SALFORD ALDI STORE LATEST TO SPELL TH' HEIGHT WRONG

The Aldi store, which replaced the Co-op on Bolton Road, is the latest to get the spelling of Irlams o' th' Height wrong on its signs. Few people who don't actually live in the area get the name right, for some reason.

A local resident who couldn't get Aldi to put its sign right, wrote to the Salford Star and the store was contacted. A spokesperson responded: "We're currently correcting the sign." Why can no-one spell Irlams o' th' Height?

Full details here...

GREATER MANCHESTER ARTISTS AND GENTRIFICATION: SLAVES TO DEVELOPERS?

Star date: 22nd October 2017

ARTISTS' ALTERNATIVES TO BEING DEVELOPERS' PLAYTHINGS

Artists' Space and Gentrification - A Grand Alternative?
Saturday 28th October noon-2pm
Phoenix House, Manchester free

As developers use artists to help gentrify areas and run-down spaces, real artists are hitting back with Artists' Space and Regeneration, looking for alternatives to being slaves of fat cats. The event includes a short talk by Jane Brake and John van Aitken with the ace title, Joy and Division in Salford: The Artful Discourses of Gentrification.

Full details here...

EVENT CELEBRATES 30 YEARS OF WORKING CLASS MOVEMENT LIBRARY IN SALFORD

Star date: 22nd October 2017

RUTH AND EDDIE FROW REMEMBERED

'The Point is To Change It': Remembering Ruth and Eddie Frow
Saturday 11th November 2pm free
Working Class Movement Library

It's 30 years since the Working Class Movement Library moved from Ruth and Eddie Frow's home in Old Trafford to Jubilee House on the Crescent, Salford, and to commemorate there's going to be a special event celebrating the lives of the top socialist couple on 11th November, with booking advised asap.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx