HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
£19MILLION SALFORD COUNCIL PLANNING SCANDAL AS PRESSURE GROWS TO MAKE PROCESS TRANSPARENT
 

Star date: 27th May 2015 

£19MILLION AND 830 AFFORDABLE HOMES LOST TO SALFORD IN JUST 12 MONTHS

After years of the Salford Star documenting how developers in the city are avoiding paying planning fees and building affordable homes, the pressure is growing on Salford Council to make the process more transparent.

Salford has lost £19million in planning fees and 830 affordable homes in the last twelve months alone, as developers have submitted confidential reports showing that their schemes would not be `viable' if they had to pay the fees – even though in some cases they are forecast to make up to £24million profit. Now the Royal Borough of Greenwich is proposing to make the confidential viability reports public.

Full details here...


In the new print issue of the Salford Star, there is a three page investigative report detailing every single planning application submitted to Salford Council over the last twelve months in which developers have avoided paying planning fees totalling £19,275,553 and building 833 affordable homes.

Developers avoid paying the `Section 106' fees - which are for things like public realm, infrastructure, heritage, education, climate change and construction training – by claiming that their schemes wouldn't be `economically viable' if they had to comply.

Yet the Salford Star article shows that the way these `viability' figures are worked out - [an equation of A-(B+C+D+E)] - means that developers can make profits of up to £24million as part of the costs.*

In all the planning applications that cite `viability' issues, Salford Council's planning officers, the District Valuer and even, recently, planning councillors, have agreed with the developers' figures crying poverty. Yet no member of the public or press is allowed to view them.

The Salford Star constantly asked to see the `viability' assessments under the Freedom of Information Act but each time it has been turned down on the grounds of `commercial confidentiality' and, very strangely, `public interest'... "Having carefully considered that balance of public interest in this case, the Council has concluded that the public interest in maintaining the exceptions outweighs the public interest in disclosure".

Now pressure is growing on Salford Council to make the viability assessments public after the Royal Borough of Greenwich this month proposed to do exactly that.

"This is about transparency for local people" says Councillor Danny Thorpe, Royal Borough of Greenwich Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Transport "At the moment our hands are tied on affordable housing levels if the viability study shows a development won't work financially with the levels of affordable housing we want.

"This will now allow the whole process to be far more transparent – making the viability studies publicly available as part of the planning documents means the Royal Borough and residents alike can see precisely why a developer might claim they cannot meet our affordable housing targets" he adds "We believe we're the first local authority in the country to be doing this – looking at policy which insists on these studies being in the public domain."

Now the challenge is for Salford Council to follow suit. Assistant Mayor for Planning, Councillor Derek Antrobus, has called the loss of millions of pounds and hundreds of affordable homes in the city "a public scandal of immense proportions", while Conservative Party planning Councillor, Karen Garrido, recently asked at a planning meeting... "What's been going on behind the door, I don't know...I find it a quite sad state of affairs..."

As the article in Salford Star reported, the numbers of Salford households on the housing waiting list rose from 10,251 in 2013 to 11,498 in 2014, while latest figures show an average of 27 bids for every affordable flat that becomes available in the city and 38 bids for every affordable house. Yet, just 16 social rent properties were built and completed in the last financial year (2013-14).

The 830 affordable homes lost through `viability assessments' would almost cover the whole of Salford's housing needs for the next twelve months – while the £19million lost through developer avoidance would have more than wiped out all the cuts to the city's environment, community safety and leisure departments over the last four years.

Now Salford City Council must make these viability assessments public so that everyone knows exactly what is `going on behind the door'...


*The equation is A-(B+C+D+E)...

`A' is the `Gross Development Value', or income from sales, ground rents etc. From this total is then deducted land costs (B), building costs, including sales and marketing (C), interest costs (D) and developer's profit (E).

In the Council report cited in the article, a `developer's profit' of 20% was "assumed across all residential appraisals". The Council figures show that a developer building 600 high density apartments on a `premium' site, such as Salford Quays should make £24,019,200 profit.


• Read the full £19million Planning Scandal article in Salford Star print issue or in the electronic version (page 27) – click here

Anon wrote
at 1:03:45 AM on Wednesday, June 17, 2015
How can we have faith in the judgement of urban vision that the viability assessments submitted to them are sound? Which individual or individuals validate these reports and the many assumptions contained within? It will be very interesting to see what happens when Greenwich throws a light onto all this.
 
Andy Baz wrote
at 11:21:06 AM on Friday, May 29, 2015
Thievess and vagabondshttp://www.andybaz.mobi
 
UoS wrote
at 4:33:46 PM on Thursday, May 28, 2015
This is great coverage of a growing scandal. Though bad in Salford it is far, far worse in London where the consequences are more serious (as there is simply no affordable rent anywhere in London). The Star are just realising the consequences of leaving something as essential as housing up to 'the market' to determine. The poor are shafted!
 
Prisoner Irlam wrote
at 1:41:16 AM on Thursday, May 28, 2015
Might as well employ FIFA Seb Blatter , a great Team Leader that isn't accountable to anyone £19,000,000 how many Affordable Houses could be built with that nice bundle of Flash . Any one ready to blow the Whistle on this scam , that's short changing the Salford Tax payer time to ring 999!!!!!!
 
Salford lad wrote
at 1:41:11 AM on Thursday, May 28, 2015
Salford planning and regen is run by a rather yuppie style assistant director called Karen Hurst who like a loyal courttier oakin to the Elizabeathan era courts the grace and favour of the City mayor. Invariably this leads to ludicrous schemes ranging from fountains t Greengate irwell and her allegedly bending over to accommodate Peel Holdings regardless of whether any of this is of real benefit to the public of Salford. This officer and her colleagues influence on policy and planing decisions is compounded by the two mainstays of planning, Chris Findlay the Councile (un) planning officer and Mr "Salford" the ex journalist Cllr Antrobus. This effectively means that regardless of how many planning committees there may be in salford, regardless of their political make up, the decisions are based on the power and recommendation of these three. Having had first hand experience of the way they work my conclusion is God help Slford!
 
Alice wrote
at 10:52:10 AM on Wednesday, May 27, 2015
I hope as many people as possible get the 'Star in print' ..there is an article in it which details the collusion between Developers and the Council and the gives a breakdown of the loss in income and potential social housing. Worth a read and you will be shocked. It is almost unbelievable and makes me wonder about the motives of the Council. Does it prefer to be chums with the profit seekers rather than the people of Salford. I hope newly elected Councillors......Harry Davis for my area .....enquire about these dealings. I voted for your honesty and your sense of justice. Can you get some transparency for us.
 
Mike Kelly wrote
at 7:11:32 AM on Wednesday, May 27, 2015
Salford Council adopt a policy that makes it all transparent hahaha , they have made a whole new meaning to opaque and muddied.
 
Michael F in SalFord wrote
at 7:11:15 AM on Wednesday, May 27, 2015
Greater Council decision transparency would be good for politics. Even better would be putting into the Council 20 co-opted Councillors to replace deputy Mayors. The 20 drawn from proportional reflection of the Salford General Election results, ensuring UKiP, Greens, TUSC, Liberal, Labour and local Independent can get their points across. Chaired by an Elected Mayor that is not paid, siting as impartial chair. I think we will then see Salford get its due income to help save vulnerable services.
 
Paul Gerrard wrote
at 7:10:40 AM on Wednesday, May 27, 2015
Lost income and lost housing - a long running scandal of Labour Councils in cahoots with developers. Check out Radio 4 documentary from last night: 'The Affordable Housing Crisis' http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05vzysp
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: IS IRLAMS O’ TH’ HEIGHT THE HARDEST PLACE TO SPELL IN BRITAIN?
I don't understand why they got it wrong now, the farewell signage at the exit always said Irlams O' Th' Height.... [more]
article: THE DEATH OF SOCIAL RENT PROPERTIES IN SALFORD?
Millionaire Felse should stand in Langworthy for the Tories. A fight between political left and right will be good for us Salford.... [more]
article: IS IRLAMS O’ TH’ HEIGHT THE HARDEST PLACE TO SPELL IN BRITAIN?
Not forgetting of course that it also gets confused with that other part of Salford - Irlam. When I use my card in the Height Ald... [more]
article: THE DEATH OF SOCIAL RENT PROPERTIES IN SALFORD?
Hedley your are wrong. It not only takes 2 but £25,000 to have a Langworthy By Election. Labour cannot afford it and Langworthy i... [more]
article: THE TREEHOUSE CAFE OPENS IN LOWER BROUGHTON FOR THE SALFORD COMMUNITY
This is fabulous, great community spirit , I'm sure lots of us will visit and look forward to meeting the lovely staff .... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD HOMELESS MAN HAS TO GET LEG AMPUTATED TO HAVE A HOME

Star date: 23rd October 2017

SHOCKING INDICTMENT OF UNFAIR WELFARE SYSTEM

'For the first time in his life he became a priority...'

Pat Mullen was homeless for over twenty years and, as a single man with drug and alcohol issues, was always bottom of the list for housing. Because of his chaotic circumstances, Pat became ill and recently had to have a leg amputated. Only then could he get somewhere to live, as, for the first time in his life, he became a priority...

"If he hadn't had a leg amputated he would still be on the streets" says his brother, John "...No-one is listening."

Full details here...

THE TREEHOUSE CAFE OPENS IN LOWER BROUGHTON FOR THE SALFORD COMMUNITY

Star date: 22nd October 2017

SHOW STOPPER CAKES, OWN BLEND COFFEE AND COMMUNITY VIBE

The TreeHouse cafe opened last month on the corner of Lower Broughton Road and Cromwell Road, complete with own-blend coffee, show stopper home-made cakes and an interior full of upcycled and recycled furniture. The owners are keen to get involved with the community, offering a meeting space and children's activities.

Full details here...

IS IRLAMS O’ TH’ HEIGHT THE HARDEST PLACE TO SPELL IN BRITAIN?

Star date: 22nd October 2017

SALFORD ALDI STORE LATEST TO SPELL TH' HEIGHT WRONG

The Aldi store, which replaced the Co-op on Bolton Road, is the latest to get the spelling of Irlams o' th' Height wrong on its signs. Few people who don't actually live in the area get the name right, for some reason.

A local resident who couldn't get Aldi to put its sign right, wrote to the Salford Star and the store was contacted. A spokesperson responded: "We're currently correcting the sign." Why can no-one spell Irlams o' th' Height?

Full details here...

GREATER MANCHESTER ARTISTS AND GENTRIFICATION: SLAVES TO DEVELOPERS?

Star date: 22nd October 2017

ARTISTS' ALTERNATIVES TO BEING DEVELOPERS' PLAYTHINGS

Artists' Space and Gentrification - A Grand Alternative?
Saturday 28th October noon-2pm
Phoenix House, Manchester free

As developers use artists to help gentrify areas and run-down spaces, real artists are hitting back with Artists' Space and Regeneration, looking for alternatives to being slaves of fat cats. The event includes a short talk by Jane Brake and John van Aitken with the ace title, Joy and Division in Salford: The Artful Discourses of Gentrification.

Full details here...

EVENT CELEBRATES 30 YEARS OF WORKING CLASS MOVEMENT LIBRARY IN SALFORD

Star date: 22nd October 2017

RUTH AND EDDIE FROW REMEMBERED

'The Point is To Change It': Remembering Ruth and Eddie Frow
Saturday 11th November 2pm free
Working Class Movement Library

It's 30 years since the Working Class Movement Library moved from Ruth and Eddie Frow's home in Old Trafford to Jubilee House on the Crescent, Salford, and to commemorate there's going to be a special event celebrating the lives of the top socialist couple on 11th November, with booking advised asap.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx