Star date: 26th April 2012 


Part 2 of the Salford Star Mayoral Challenge. Today the candidates give their views on everything from the Salford riots, to Chimney Pot Park, to democracy, Greengate, Chapel Street and, of course, the infamous Higher Kersal Lake project. And would they go to jail to defend Salford?

Click here to find out…

Salford Star Mayoral Challenge City of Salford sign Salford Riots Sumer 2011
click image to enlarge


Yesterday the Salford Mayor candidates disclosed what salary they would take and their most dastardly plans for the city. They also gave their views on Peel Holdings, Eccles, the Quays Cranes and Council secrecy. To read The Salford Star Mayoral Challenge: Day One – click here.

Only six of the ten candidates who want to be Mayor of Salford could be bothered to fill in the Salford Star Mayoral Challenge, thirty questions that aimed to go beyond campaign propaganda and find out where they stand politically, what their personality is like and how much they actually know about Salford and its issues. Here are the six candidates who took the Salford Star Challenge…

Ian Stewart – Labour Party (LP)
Joe O'Neil – Green Party (GP)
Norman Owen – Liberal Democrat Party (LD)
Michael Moulding – Community Action Party (CAP)
Michael Felse – English Democrats (ED)
Pat Ward – Independent (I)

There were policy questions, campaign questions, some fun questions and even a few trick questions chucked in to see how they would respond. They each had no more than four lines to reply, to stop reader boredom creeping in. Here's how the candidates responded to six more questions…

QUESTION 1: Would you go to jail to defend a principal in support of Salford?

Norman Owen (LD): Yes.

Pat Ward (I): That is a very difficult question. I'm a law-abiding citizen and always have been and I don't foresee any issue that would coax me to fall out of the realms of the laws of the land.

Ian Stewart (L): As an Elected Mayor I would always seek to work within the Law in the interests of the People of Salford and their Families.

Joe O'Neil (GP): I don't even have a parking ticket, don't want to give an answer I may not have the guts to go through with. I hope I would if needed.

Michael Felse (ED): No. It is not my intention to visit at Her Majesty's pleasure, they are not nice places. However, like any responsible citizen of Salford I will go an extra mile to stand up for what is right for our neighbourhoods. That does not need any of us to consider jail terms it just needs justified unstoppable determination.

Michael Moulding (CAP): Yes I would and I have come close a few times.


QUESTION 2: Are too many of Salford's resources being poured into projects like Chapel Street, Media City, Greengate, Salford Reds etc?

Pat Ward: Yes. There are not enough jobs being created for Salford people from these big projects as promised. We need to be prioritising current businesses and investing in our current assets.

Joe O'Neil: Yes, yes, yes.

Ian Stewart: If any candidate tells you they know the answer to that question – I seriously advise caution. Again EM [Elected Mayor] would need to know, 'what has been' and 'what is', to be able to evaluate the question and no Candidate has any experience of decision making on these issues. If elected I would do a ROI 'Return On Investment' analysis taking in to consideration the social as well as the economic impacts.

Michael Moulding: Absolutely YES! The latter Salford Labour's cronyism at its worst!

Michael Felse: Yes. Temptation to make Salford glitzy smacks of Councillors who became bored, sitting too many hours in the Civic Centre chamber, drinking tea and eating biscuits. They get caught up in dream lands instead of taking priorities seriously like 12,000 empty properties with 14,000 on a housing waiting list. 

Norman Owen: With the Labour majority they have ploughed roughshod over the opposition parties and done what they have wanted to do. Also they have taken control of community committees. What chance have you got? They will put money where they want.

QUESTION 3: Were the `upside down' houses in Chimney Pot Park good for Seedley and Langworthy?

Ian Stewart: That's for the people of Seedley and Langworthy to say. An Elected Mayor would need to listen to the people and learn from any previous good or bad judgments made. Genuine consultation and involvement of residents is crucial to develop ownership/success.  Some mistakes in past but lots of good practice developed too. An Elected Mayor can learn from others in Salford and beyond.
Joe O'Neil: No.

Michael Felse: No. The forces of business interest came too strongly into the frame. The end result is good for the people that were able to move in, rather like Media City inward movers and expected movers into the new Chapel Street apartments. What was lost are family generations, what was gained is fiscal progress.

Michael Moulding: No because the original houses should never have been knocked down in the first place. But they look different. I like them.

Norman Owen: People were robbed of their homes and paid a pittance for their houses, thanks to John Merry and Hazel Blears.

Pat Ward: As I have said before, we need to be building on existing land without taking away the green areas. Housing is required within Salford, upside down or not.

QUESTION 4: What were the causes of last year's Salford riots? What sentence would you have given to the little old ladies nicking food from Lidl?

Norman Owen: There would of been no sentence, I would have give her £20 for food.

Michael Felse: The cause came from embedded within the despondent society, bringing civil wrong, destruction and opportunism that took advantage of unrest.  It was not the correct way to vent anger, neither is it right to ignore these riots happened. The sentence is for the ladies to engage in better ways to force a real change.

Michael Moulding: Criminality pure and simple. Hopefully my anti-poverty strategy for the city will mean that these ladies will not need to steal. If they are hungry I will help them.

Ian Stewart: Too serious and complicated an issue for glib, ill-informed answers. My guts tell me that we need to: alleviate poverty, deprivation, and strengthen communities. Diminish the influence of: those promoting self-interest, gang culture/organisation and peer pressure. We must promote: education, welfare, health, decent jobs and wages and appropriate and relevant crime and disorder systems.

Joe O'Neil: We have a society that is divided; the kids have nothing the city is full of teenage mums with no future. The causes? Us. PS. the sentencing was standard knee jerk Tory policy.

Pat Ward: The riots were a combination of social problems, boredom and general upset at the way the less fortunate are treated. Theft is theft and we can't justify breaking the law even for "little old ladies".


QUESTION 5: How would you hold yourself up for account if elected Mayor?

Joe O'Neil: The public decide at the ballot box. Open debate and try to make the town hall open space for all views.

Norman Owen: The people will judge that after a time of office.

Michael Moulding: My door will always be open. Besides my weekly surgeries I am happy to hold monthly press briefings. Ask me any questions you want!

Pat Ward: I intend to make decisions based on a full consultation with all those affected, councillors, Salford citizens etc. using the experience I have already gained from the previous leader's mistakes. Good or bad decisions will be mine and I will take full responsibility for them.

Ian Stewart: An Elected Mayor will make him or herself accountable to the People of Salford in the first instance through democratic elections every four years. In between elections the City Mayor can promote initiatives such as 'Meet the Mayor' and other formal events. But there is no substitute for personal contact with real people within our own communities. I have a good track record on this. 

Michael Felse: The Mayor must be accountable to Salford people, as must Councillors. I will hold public surgeries, including at the Civic Centre, welcoming the public.  In addition I will create a public press resource that will include a Mayor's given right to council staff that allows them to make public interest whistle-blowing.


QUESTION 6: Are plans for the Higher Kersal lake good or bad?
This is actually a trick question – there's no such thing as Higher Kersal Lake. The only lake in Higher Kersal is the glacial lake that's underneath the new Unity Quarter houses, former flooded site of Kersal High School playing fields. So what do our candidates think? Would they pretend they knew about the Higher Kersal Lake project?

Norman Owen: I think the people of Higher Kersal should decide this.

Pat Ward: I went to Kersal last weekend and it is still a good neighbourly community. Lake Kersal looks like it is going to be a good way of involving all age groups in the community and any initiatives that promote community cohesion, I support.
Ian Stewart: Don't know enough about it at this point to comment. If Elected Mayor, I would adopt same consultative approach as outlined above.

Joe O'Neil: Sorry, out of touch on this one, can't give you an honest answer.

Michael Felse: Kersal has a lake! Excellent news for the Mayor's lake fishing annual contest and place for ex Councillors to pontificate over their errors while casting a rod. I support a fixed retirement age for Councillors of 70, seeing 20% of Salford's Councillors take early retirement at the age of 68 to attract young visionaries.

Michael Moulding: Any created habitat is good even if it's not natural.

The Salford Star Mayoral Challenge Part Three - click here















EX Liebor voter , all traitors . wrote
at 2:11:16 PM on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Ripped Off . I assume from your strange comments that you are politically naive . We have never had Socialism in Salford . These Labour traitors are so right-wing they would be comfortable in thatchers pocket . They are Bliar's Nu-Liebor Traitors , conservative throughout . There is nothing to choose between the CON/LIB/LAB Traitors , and we should kick them all into the gutter . Such a great pity that we do not have a Socialist alternative for Mayor .
Nachtschlepper wrote
at 11:06:37 AM on Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Did they rip off your brain? There is no such thing as Socialism in Salford.
Ripped off wrote
at 3:46:16 PM on Friday, April 27, 2012
Regarding the housing robbery and a fair few other things in Salford. Socialism is just one mans way to screw over the many, and tell them that it's for the greater good.
Nachtschlepper wrote
at 8:49:15 AM on Friday, April 27, 2012
Dr Duke is spot on, we do need a real socialist candidate. Why do people not see the need for this? Maybe the truth is that anybody running for mayor is just another self seeking politician out to serve his or her own needs and not those of the people.
gary duke wrote
at 5:18:10 AM on Friday, April 27, 2012
I think we should take Norman Owen's radicalism with a pinch of salt. It was his party after all who promised that they wouldn't raise tuition fees for students, indeed that they would scrap them. Where are students today? The Liberals and the Tories once in power tripled tuition fees and cut student numbers. They also scrapped the Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA) which was a lifeline to many sixth form and college students from disadvantaged backgrounds. Go on Norman, promise the earth. Given his party's track record in power, the key here is in my opinion, to reverse every thing he promises or says and you'll get his real policies. As for the Community Action Party's candidate's view that the riots were 'pure criminality', I'd like to see the evidence he bases his simplistic and tabloid analysis on. We need a real socialist candidate for mayor who'll provide a voice and policies for the disadvantaged and ordinary working people instead of the already wealthy corporate interests. Sadly there isn't a socialist candidate standing.
Ian OBrien wrote
at 4:52:28 AM on Friday, April 27, 2012
"Criminality pure and simple. Hopefully my anti-poverty strategy for the city will mean that these ladies will not need to steal. If they are hungry I will help them." I love the word 'hopefully'. Here is a sheister who is already making comments he can refer back to in two years time. 'I said hopefully, it is there in black and white!!' And can he come back and clarify his statement I wonder? The little old ladies were criminals, and nothing more? Then he admits that there is a 'need' to steal. Come on mate, stop talking bollox. Not a single on of you so far has said a single honest word. No wonder Salford is going to hell. You are all incompetent spongers!
dlp6666 wrote
at 4:52:08 AM on Friday, April 27, 2012
Winston Smith - I know it's easy to by cynical about this, but media like the Salford Star are trying to get people to think BEYOND the rosette. When Salfordians do this and go beyond outdated tribal loyalties, then we can look forward to real change. But of course, they have to THINK and then VOTE!
EX- Liebor wrote
at 4:49:37 AM on Friday, April 27, 2012
NotaDonkey and Winston. Be assured . There is a lot of anger about the way this City has been run into the gutter by the Town Hall Traitors . There is a mass undercurrent of anger against the CON/LIB/LAB traitorous shites at both local and national level . People realize it is TIME FOR CHANGE ,albeit long overdue . Time to kick the CON/LIB/LAB scum back into the sewers they crawled from , to rot , as we Betrayed Salfordians rot in this Deadcity ... .
Notadonkey wrote
at 11:09:19 PM on Thursday, April 26, 2012
GO NORMAN! It is a pity that noboby has ever stood up and spoken out about this robbery before. No wonder that Merry was against an elected major though. He knew that the long knives were coming out again. Unfortunately Ian Stewart will probably get in with the "donkey rosette", Hinds will carry on smirking like a man who dropped an SBD as he got out of a lift and Blears will be buying some more £200 towels.
Not Impressed wrote
at 11:09:14 PM on Thursday, April 26, 2012
Such a pity we do not have a mayoral candidate of the honesty , integrity , decency , vision , and commitment of Dennis Skinner , Arthur Scargill, Dave Nellist , Eric Heffer , Terry Fields ...
Winston Smith wrote
at 8:39:40 AM on Thursday, April 26, 2012
Question 5: If council elections are anything to go off, all you need to do to be Mayor of Salford is be the Labour candidate. 'Meet the Mayor'!?! What for? It should just be called "Meet Another Member Of The Labour Party". Represent the people? Yeh, right.
EX-liebor voter wrote
at 8:02:27 AM on Thursday, April 26, 2012
Norman Owen is spot on with his statement that people were robbed of their homes and paid a pittance for their houses , thanks to Merry and Blears . Consider all the other areas in this city where decent people have received the same treatment , and with VOA collusion , undervalueing property in some instances by a staggering 42% . This is far more than ineptitude. This is deliberate policy . ALL to suit big business developers interests . This inept lot have a lot to answer to the People of Salford . Question : Which Mayoral candidate will investigate this skullduggery ?
Brian Francis Kirkham wrote
at 6:08:04 AM on Thursday, April 26, 2012
Nice work on the 'Kersal Lake' Question ! Shows how just out of touch some of this lot are...No sense of where they are...Will they do anything for votes?
Please enter your comment below:
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
Recent comments
Hi Paul. I lived for my first 8 or so years on Pine Street off Hough Lane in Lower Broughton (1966-74) All very long gone obvious... [more]
Phil,I am allowed to comment on things that happen in my city.Why can't these facts and figures be public. If no one has anything ... [more]
Oriflamme Raised, I don't know where you get off on bullying me like this. Personally I think that it is pretty despicable of you.... [more]
I agree with Oliframe that we need to take a close look at Labour activists. This is why I appeal to not vote Labour this May to s... [more]
Paul Dennett, is a politician, lets be honest here, you cannot expect him to tell the truth. All politicians never ever tell the t... [more]


Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome


More articles...


Star date: 21st April 2018


Happy Days
Friday 25th May – Saturday 23rd June
Royal Exchange, Manchester. £17

In his plays, Samuel Beckett wrestles with the idea that all human life is meaningless and purposeless, and the possibly ironic title, Happy Days, gets explored in this new production at the Royal Exchange starring Maxine Peake. It's described as an 'existential masterpiece'.

Full details here...


Star date: 20th April 2018


The number of Salford councillors could be cut in a sweeping review of the city by the Local Government Boundary Commission for England..."The review will re-draw ward boundaries across the city as well as deciding how many councillors should be elected to the council in total" said a spokesperson for the Commission.

Salford currently has three councillors per ward but, with new wards possibly emerging as the city grows, this might be cut to two per ward.

Full details here…


Star date: 19th April 2018


In the latest issue of Salford Council's propaganda mag, Life in Salford, Salford City Mayor, Paul Dennett, has denounced the "myth" that "developers don't contribute money to the city. It's simply not true" he says.

Yes, they do contribute some money but they also avoid millions of pounds in payments and provision of affordable housing. Indeed, Salford Star analysis shows that developers avoided almost £5.5million in payments last year, as the Mayor only tells half the truth.

Full details here...


Star date: 18th April 2018


Today, in St Peter's Square Manchester, around half a dozen campaign groups took part in a Disabled People Against the Cuts national day of action calling for Universal Credit to be stopped and scrapped.

Chalk slogans covered the square, speeches were made condemning the affect of the discredited benefit and a giant letter was handed into Manchester City Council calling for 'No evictions' as a result of Universal Credit payment delays.

Full details here...


Star date: 18th April 2018


A coach load of Save Our Nursery campaigners will be heading to Parliament next Wednesday 25th April for a meeting with MPs in the Palace of Westminster and to urge the Government to be flexible over its new funding formula.

It is also hoped that Labour Party Leader, Jeremy Corbyn, will pressure Theresa May to respond at Prime Minister's Question Time on the same day.

Full details here...


written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx