Star date: May 2nd 2012


In the final part of the Salford Star Mayoral Challenge the candidates give their views on everything from ASDA in Swinton to trade unions, green issues and Charlestown and Lower Kersal NDC. And do they agree that they are all power crazed, egotists?

Click here to find out…


Previously the Salford Star Mayoral Challenge gave the candidates a chance to tell the electorate their views on what salary they would take, their most dastardly plans for the city, Peel Holdings, Eccles, the Quays Cranes, Council secrecy, the riots, Chimney Pot Park housing, Chapel Street, affordable housing, Buile Hill Mansion, Barbara Spicer, asylum seekers, Media City and poverty.

To read The Salford Star Mayoral Challenge: Day One – click here.

To read The Salford Star Mayoral Challenge: Day Two – click here.

To read The Salford Star Mayoral Challenge: Day Three – click here.

To read The Salford Star Mayoral Challenge: Day Four – click here.

Only six of the ten candidates who want to be Mayor of Salford could be bothered to fill in the Salford Star Mayoral Challenge, thirty questions that aim to go beyond campaign propaganda and find out where they stand politically, what their personality is like and how much they actually know about Salford and its issues. Here are the six candidates who took the Salford Star Challenge…

Ian Stewart – Labour Party (LP)
Joe O'Neil – Green Party (GP)
Norman Owen – Liberal Democrat Party (LD)
Michael Moulding – Community Action Party (CAP)
Michael Felse – English Democrats (ED)
Pat Ward – Independent (I)

They each had no more than four lines to reply, to stop reader boredom creeping in. Here's how the candidates responded to the final six questions…


QUESTION 1: Should ASDA be built on Swinton Precinct?
This question relates to the proposals to build a new ASDA, despite there being two big supermarkets almost next door and despite the fact that it's partly to be built on the site of an old burial ground…

Pat Ward: Whilst Asda could generate employment, polls suggest it would affect existing small businesses causing more unemployment than the employment it would generate, so my initial reaction would be no.

Norman Owen: Who's going to stop it?

Michael Felse: No. The time has come to ask people what they want and I will push this one back onto the drawing board then turn the board upside down. I feel Swinton already has mistakes caused by wrong decisions and we cannot allow ASDA progress to come back and bite away what is sacred. If I am wrong prove it.

Ian Stewart: Again criteria should be 'In who's interests would such developments take place?' If they are in the interests of residents and their families - they should be approved. If they are not in the interests of residents and their families then within the scope of the regulations they can and should be rejected. 

Joe O'Neil: Hard question - the precinct is dead we need the jobs but we must ensure all the small businesses survive, we need to offer local shopping not Peel's Trafford centre.

Michael Moulding: Over 313 resting souls including a World War 1 soldier who sacrificed his life, including victims of the 1885 Clifton Pit Disaster or to have them dug up for Asda? Over my dead body!


QUESTION 2: How would you cope with a probable two thirds Labour majority constantly blocking your plans, unless you are in the Labour Party of course?

Norman Owen: I am made of stronger stuff than two thirds Labour majority.

Michael Moulding: I will stand up to them, take them on and argue the case. I will campaign in their heartlands for what I believe is right! Take the fight to them.

Pat Ward: I would expect the cabinet to agree with plans that are beneficial to Salford and if they are blocking plans just because they can, the cabinet will be held accountable by their electorate.

Michael Felse: An important question which has different answers depending on the level of resistance but I expect all Councillors to toe the line where the public vote has instructed them to act in the best interests of Salford. If a scenario brought a constant blocking then I will dissolve the Council, forcing an all out election.

Joe O'Neil: Highlight any blocks to the public and named votes on all issues .Show the public every week who was blocking what.

Ian Stewart: I don't accept the premise of this question!  If I am elected I would seek to work in partnership with the Council. I believe this would be in the best interests of the People of Salford and their Families. However, legally the buck stops with the Elected Mayor. Part of my skills lie in being able to get people to work together for the greater good of the City.


QUESTION 3: How important are Salford's green spaces– would you fight to save them from developers?

Ian Stewart: All important! Always have fought for them - always will. I support the 'Mossland Strategy' and would like to develop Salford as a 'Garden City', bringing together all the brilliant community 'Green Initiatives'. Developing the concept of 'Adopt a Garden' for the 700+ people waiting for Allotments. This would assist the elderly, disabled and others who have difficulty looking after their own gardens

Joe O'Neil: 100%

Michael Felse: One of my top 6 pledges is a Green Belt Charity run by local people. It will be a partnership with Cooperatives UK (for legal support) and have authority to legally challenge any planning that endangers Salford. It will receive a grant up to £1million (start up investment) as a fresh Green Belt vision for Salford.

Pat Ward: There are so many brown field sites in Salford that are in need of regeneration, I do not think it is necessary to take new/green spaces until we have no alternative. Yes I would fight to save them.

Norman Owen: Yes.

Michael Moulding: My green credentials are second to none! YES, YES and YES!


QUESTION 4: What do you think of the Salford NDC's `succession strategy'?
The Charlestown and Lower Kersal New Deal for Communities was a £53million disaster – and now it's gone does any candidate actually know or care what's happening in the area? There is a `succession strategy' but it's harder to find than a diamond in a pig's butt…

Michael Felse: If something is left to decay it can die, one would argue we can be proud of New Deal for Communities. Not all of it was good but the here and now will tell us we have a vibrant future for communities influenced. Life in Salford for the families will never be the same. The succession lesson is hear people.

Michael Moulding: I have not briefed myself on it but will do!

Ian Stewart: I am aware of history and demise of New Deal for Communities. It was exclusive to certain areas of the City should have been city-wide. Strategic decision making should be made by resident's at the most local level achievable. If elected, I would need to work hard to 'get up to speed' on current NDC Succession Strategy and how it sits with the public, before making any considered suggestions.

Pat Ward: On the polls that have been carried out, this has been a good thing for Charlestown and Lower Kersal, but £53m cannot be awarded to every community.

Joe O'Neil: Not much.

Norman Owen: Closer scrutiny and uncertain future regarding finance and mainstream involvement. Many questions have to be asked in this area.


QUESTION 5: What are your views on trade unions?

Michael Moulding: Absolutely necessary to protect workers rights and employment. Been a member of Unite, Unison and PCS.

Joe O'Neil: Today we need them but worried of the influence on Labour and how your money flows through.

Norman Owen: As an ex shop steward and convener in TASS, they are good in the workplace but should not interfere in local politics and the mayoral election. UNITE SHOULD NOT RUN THIS CITY.

Michael Felse: My first job (aged 15) was at the local coal mine, where my father, brother and uncles worked. My uncle had his back ripped out through national coal board neglect. My father died of dust on his lungs; my brother of a heart attack after respiratory illness.  Personal experiences tell me Trade Unions have a place. 

Pat Ward: There will always be a place for trade unions because there are always going to be injustices in the work place.

Ian Stewart: Lifelong UNITE and Coop Party Activist and advocate for the most vulnerable - proud of it!  Gained my education through the Trade Union and Cooperative Movement. 20 years a TGWU Organiser, Secretary UNITE Parliamentary Group, Vice Chair of Parliamentary Joint TU Group. Trade Unions can be a 'Force for Good'. Look forward to working productively with TUs and other Partners if elected.


QUESTION 6: Do you agree that anyone who says `Vote For Me!' is an arrogant, careerist egotist who's not worth voting for? Are you a power crazed tosser?

Joe O'Neil (GP): Ask me again after the election. I served with the Liberal democrats for four years, little power but god it felt good to say I helped people. But I can think of a few tossers…

Ian Stewart (L): "O wad some Power the gift tae gie us, to see oursels as ithers see us!" Translation of Robert Burns quote above: "It doesn't matter what I think of myself, it's what the People of Salford think that's important.

Norman Owen (LD): No, just a Joe Bloggs in life. Trying to do my best.

Michael Felse (ED): No and No. But reserve my opinion on political parties in Salford that have represented Salford for 20years of neglect or individuals in the Mayoral who take support for granted. Nowhere to be seen is my fair comment when they use post office or misguided souls to deliver leaflets on a candidate's behalf.

Pat Ward (I): I am not asking people to do something I wouldn't do myself and that is to "VOTE FOR ME". Not arrogant or egotistical…passionate about my city.

Michael Moulding (CAP): It depends who it is. I don't want the power for myself I just want to be able to help as many people as I can.

This ends the Salford Star Mayoral Challenge and now it's make your mind up time. Are any of them worth bothering with? Vote takes place tomorrow, Thursday May 3rd.













Irwell Running Through Me wrote
at 21:00:39 on 03 May 2012
10,000 words Michael? And yet here you cannot string together ten sentences? Do you see a box on this page, like on Twitter, which says there is a limit on how many words you type? I would be very surprised if you had written 10,000 words in your entire life, much less on one subject. Well, for the record, I know what your partys right wing immigration policy is, and I know it is people like you that my grandad lost a leg fighting in the World War 2. I also knew, as we all did, that you never stood a snowballs chance in hell of getting anywhere in this election. However, while you thought you were in with a shout, I thought it would be good fun to hear what baloney you came up with on the subject of immigration. As it happened.....it wasn't.
Bob Jones wrote
at 21:00:10 on 03 May 2012
Mr Felse, Where were you educated as you have a very poor understanding of the English language, try using a comma instead of a full stop. Please also note two spaces should be used after a full stop. I pity Salford if you are elected how will you be able to communicate with ministers of the government, they will probably think you are a labour councilor, but then you are a socialist are you not?
Michael Felse wrote
at 14:09:46 on 03 May 2012
and as I head off to vote let me add reply to the objector on my Q4. Not sure what the anti is but suspect it is about the impact of New Deal. Like many experiments on our community it has ups and downs. I do not defend New Deal I simply accept it went its course. The problem was the experiment was forced on Salford. My solution would all be about what is the best long term for Salford communities. New Deal had some good points but sustainability longevity was not built into the programme. It should have left local communities buzzing with success. It has not. The good part was the live activities but the after party is a headache. We have to give local people the time and authority to put in place new control of their community. My ending note as a Salford resident is that I hate politicians who mess with our lives. I wish for today is real change becomes Salford.
Michael Felse wrote
at 14:09:02 on 03 May 2012
Thank you to all comments, been canvassing 18/7 this last week and extremely pleased to have talked with people in every ward. I have learned more about the needs in Salford this last week than I can print on here, but believe me most share the straight to the point views of Salford Star bloggers. The question on immigration is a long answer I would love to put into print (my usual input into such Qs is >10,000 words as I did in my objection to the Boundary change that could otherwise see Salford name lost. In short on Immigration I support a points system, such as is used in Australia and Canada. My augment on that approach includes FULL score for people at risk of torture or death. I want negative points for any person convicted of drug pushing, terrorism, human trafficking and a block on allowing any Pedophiles into our country. I do not support an "open door" policy on anyone of any crime being given a welcome sign into our country. This is what I stand for as my right to protect family and friends.
Winston Smith wrote
at 10:29:40 on 03 May 2012
I think the question (for voters, not candidates!) is who to vote for if you do not want yet another Labour politician contributing to Salford's demise? Who stands the best chance?
Sick of being Ripped-Off wrote
at 10:29:29 on 03 May 2012
But Mike Molding will only take a mayoral salary of £35,000. He will also give Spicy the boot , saving over £200,000.p.a. for essential services .The CEO role will be abolished . We cannot carry on in this rotton city by letting the same inept mobsters rip us all off year after year . A thorough investigation is essential into the antics of the mobsters , their cosy big business relationships , the regeneration farce , and the cheating of people of the full value of their homes . The obscenely high coucil tax rip-off must be slashed . Mike will do this . I agree that most of these politician-turds are only after the Money Trough , but there are exceptions .
Bob Jones wrote
at 05:44:18 on 03 May 2012
Ian Stewart how the fuck can you expect anyone to vote for you, you simply cannot give a straight answer, i don't think you are sitting on the fence you just simply appear to have the fence post stuck well and truely up your arse. FFS just answer the question you have been asked, stop quoting bull, start talking in full.
Serious?? wrote
at 20:07:32 on 02 May 2012
Michael Felse-Question 4 How the hell can you expect anyone to vote for you if you think that?
Irwell Running Through Me wrote
at 15:06:23 on 02 May 2012
At this point I would like to make it quite clear that I do not have an axe to grind with Mr Felse, personally. And as the mayoral candidates go he has shown himself to be on a par. By which I mean that in all of these questions, over all of these days, none of them have done anything but spout the same old tired out mantras. If there is a single reader of this publication who has been convinced by a single one of them, that they are anything other than the usual bunch of self serving little careerists trying to get their arses into a cushy job so they can fill their boots - please do tell us here. They are reading this, so at least you will know they are hearing you (because once in office you will never get a chance to communicate with them again). But Mr Felse. Oh dear, oh dear. You are clearly reading these pages, you are engaging with the publication, and yet having been asked directly, over two days, for clarification on some of your own and your parties, very important issues to the people of Salford, i.e. immigration, you have continually snubbed me. You have not even bothered to evade the questions with the usual, Question Time, pseudo political bullshit. You have simply refused to respond. Now, mate, it is all very well trying to grab votes by pretending to be a 'friend' of the Salford Star, and by association the people of Salford, but this kind of blatant snubbing of the electorate is highly insulting, at the very least. If you have nothing to hide, and your party politics are sound - or at least genuinely democratic - then you would have responded, surely? Or am I not good enough to warrant a response? Because if that is the case now, what can the people of Salford - the black, white, yellow green and brown people of Salford sir, the Salford born, the immigrated, and those asylum seekers and refugees who may one day be in possession of a vote themselves - what can they expect of you in office? I had hoped to prove that your party are merely opportunist cowards and toerags. I think your silence has done that for me. I would like to say again, to the readers of the Salford Star - what do YOU think, of this shower? Do YOU think they will put your best interests first, or will they put Peel first? Lets have it out, at least for the brief time these Quislings may actually here us. Thats my two bob. Lets see if any of them deign to respond. I doubt it though, which just goes to show how little they think of us.
EX- Liebor , all traitors wrote
at 15:04:03 on 02 May 2012
Are any of them worth bothering with ? Good question , and time will tell . One thing is certain . The CON/LIB/LAB TRAITORS are not worth bothering with . A vote for them just means more of the same bullshit , waste , squander , dereliction ,more obscene-salaried Spicey, more contempt for the electorate ,more extortionate council tax rip-off . Only the candidate promising to slash council tax gets my vote . Time for real change in this Deadcity .
Please enter your comment below:
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
Recent comments
from 1956 Salford councillor "What we need is for us to Clear the unfit properties and build new modern homes with all in door a... [more]
If they stopped importing more people, these properties wouldn't be required. But that's what people vote for, so on their own hea... [more]
Message for Joseph De Biaise, Hi Joseph, you were in the same year as me at St Andrew's.If you are looking for pics from School.Wh... [more]
I expect blunderbus and his mates to get a lot more grief from the Irlam crew. They are just as well organised but not as mouthy a... [more]
Bob the regular,why shouldn't people,regardless of material circumstances,live in decent homes? Turns out you are a prig and sno... [more]


Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome


More articles...


Star date: 21st January 2019


Tonight a Special Community Committee Meeting took place for Irlam and Cadishead to discuss the Greater Manchester Spatial Framework which proposes 1,600 houses to be built in the green belt near Irlam Station.

Passionate opposition speeches from the community covered all issues, from infrastructure to pollution, affordable housing to loss of Grade 1 agricultural land and the unstable site proposed for development. Not one single person present spoke in favour of the proposals.

Full details here...


Star date: 21st January 2019


Star Wars characters landed in Eccles Shopping Centre at the weekend and raised £132 for the Autistic Society of Greater Manchester. Alongside Darth Vader were Stormtroopers, a Wookiee, Jedis and more.

Full details here...


Star date: 20th January 2019


Manchester Meltdown 4
Wednesday 23rd January
The Peer Hat, Manchester

Four ace bands feature in Manchester Meltdown 4 this Wednesday, including two bands, Four Candles and Matthew Hopkins, who played at the Eagle Inn Salford Star Benefit last November. Ian Leslie chats with Matthew Hopkins' Julia about tales of mystery, magic and prostitution.

Full details here...


Star date: 20th January 2019


Salford's Margaret McHale turned one hundred this week as her six children and relatives gathered for a huge party at The Broughtons Care Home. Born in Hanky Park, Margaret moved around central Salford, to Ellor Street, Warburton Street and finally to Littleton Road, as part of the slum clearances.

A proper Salford lass, Margaret worked on Lancaster Bombers during the war and as a machinist in Strangeways, and, as the family partied with residents and staff, there were a zillion anecdotes that will echo with loads of local families.

Full details here...


Star date: 20th January 2019


Electricity North West, the region's power network operator, is looking to take on young Salford people and has places for craft apprenticeships, which include overhead line workers and cable jointers, and higher level apprenticeships, which include roles such as design and control engineer.

Full details here...


written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx