HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
SALFORD COUNCIL ASSASSINATES HIGHER BROUGHTON COMMUNITY
 

Star date: 20th March 2012

THERE GOES THE NEIGHBOURHOOD

Of an original sixty Top Streets residents tracked by Salford Council, six have died waiting for the area to be regenerated. Over half have moved out of the neighbourhood or into rented houses, as bulldozers have flattened their previous homes.

Planning permission was approved last week for new houses on the demolition site; houses that none of the former residents could afford. Here the Salford Star tracks the assassination of a community…

Full story click here

 


Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford
Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford
Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford
Top Streets of Salford Top Streets of Salford Top Streets Demolition March 2012
Top Streets Demolition March 2012 Salford Top Streets Demolition Higher Broughton Salford 2012
click image to enlarge

THERE GOES THE NEIGHBOURHOOD – PART TWO

See Part Oneclick here

Welcome to the Top Streets of Higher Broughton. Here, there are just four families left, scattered on three deserted streets and surrounded by derelict terraces, blitz-style rubble and acres of grass crofts where houses used to be.

Over in the near distance, standing out like a bad joke at a funeral, is the new gaudy £7million `community hub'…

"Seeing the hub up and running is a dream come true for me as it brings some much needed and top quality community facilities to Broughton" said John Merry, Salford Council Leader, at its opening last year.

Trouble is, there's no original community left to use the thing. Over four hundred houses, or getting on for one thousand people, will have been cleared from the area by the time the bulldozers have gone.

In the Bottom Streets of Higher Broughton, 160 houses were demolished in haste in 2005, in order to build a sports pitch that, up until this year, still hadn't had a ball kicked on it. And in the Top Streets, 243 houses are in the process of being bulldozed. Already destroyed have been a stunning hundred year old dairy (see here), huge four bedroom houses and rows and rows of unique terrace houses, that even when empty have been used for tv and film sets (see here and see here).

Salford Council, which is determined to `transform' the area, has admitted that there is absolutely nothing wrong with the houses at all. They are not being bulldozed because they are slums or in disrepair. They are being knocked down only because there is "low demand for housing of this type".

This is the rhetoric used by the previous Labour Government and its now discredited Pathfinder project which was responsible for destroying tens of thousands of traditional houses all over the country.

Near the start of the regeneration of Higher Broughton, Salford Council commissioned the Dap Consultancy to do a report on the area. When it came to the community's views on consultation the report states that, while consultation mechanisms were in place, "they were not working… `No-one listens' was a common quotation by stakeholders. There is a perception that the Council are paying lip service to local stakeholders and residents and that it has yet to get a grip with the real issues facing the area."

Like everything else in Salford, the Council's answer was to bulldoze the problem, hoping the `real issues' would go away. 
 
The Council set up the Higher Broughton Partnership, a public-private venture company, with the Royal Bank of Scotland, Inpartnership and City Spirit to carry out the `transformation'.

A Salford Council survey at the very start of the Pathfinder process showed that over 60% of the Top Streets community wanted vacant houses in the area either `renovated and brought into use' or a `mix of demolition and renovation'. And only 23% of people surveyed wanted `substantial demolition' of the whole area of 243 houses.

In the event, when Salford Council went to get a Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO), it agreed to save and renovate only eight large houses in Devonshire Street.

After objections by the community, Salford Council agreed to renovate a further fifteen terraces on King Street, making a total of 23 houses, and Dylan Vince, Salford City Council's Programme Manager, included the details in his `Proof of Evidence' to the CPO inquiry in September 2006. 

"…between 8 and 12 residents expressed an interest in re-housing into refurbished and remodelled properties" he wrote, adding "In addition to the eight houses on Devonshire Street…It is anticipated that the remodelling and refurbishment of 15 existing houses will both provide sufficient stock to re-house those residents seeking this option and provide some additional stock to sell on the open market."

The Council's Major Project Co-ordinator, Barry Whitmarsh, formally included the proposals and more details in his `Proof of Evidence' to obtain the CPO in 2006…

"…The modified scheme retains fifteen existing properties on King Street" he wrote, adding that "these houses will be extended to create private rear garden space…secure car parking and service access will be provided to the rear of the houses."

Councillor Peter Connor, Salford Council's Lead Member for Housing Services signed a formal decision notice in September 2006 "that the modified layout entailing the retention of 15 remodelled and refurbished houses on King Street be confirmed as the intended."

Plans had been drawn up by architects Church Lukas for the King Street renovations and agreed by what was now a dwindling community, as the community lost faith in the great `regeneration' plans which had been ongoing for over twenty years, since the 1980s (Housing Action Area) and through the 1990s (Broughton SRB)…

Council figures show that in the three years leading up to the CPO, people in King Street accepted offers as low as £5000 for their houses, with an average of around £15,000. Subsequent Land Tribunals showed that people were underpaid by up to 42% for similar houses in the condemned area (see here).

But 23 houses were to be saved for people who wanted to live in one of the original terraces – 15 saved on King Street and eight on Devonshire Street.

By the time the bulldozers have finished trashing everything in site over the next month, there will be only six houses left in Devonshire Street. Not 23 houses saved at all. Just six. So what happened?

Firstly, following the granting of the CPO, the remaining residents were just left in limbo for over two years amongst boarded up houses and deserted streets.

A letter sent in July 2008 from Richard Wynne, Director of Property for Urban Vision acting on behalf of Salford Council, to Graeme Hogg of Inpartnership, revealed the situation "with the remaining residents being increasing vulnerable and some serious criminal and anti social behaviour incidents happening in the area."

In the same letter, Wynne admitted that the Council was coming under "increasing pressure to be seen to be doing something positive in the Top Streets area" but added that "The Partnership has, to my mind, always been rather reluctant to consider refurbishment and would prefer to concentrate on new build."

By April 2009 this was confirmed in a letter to residents that stated that it would cost "up to £130,000 per property" to refurbish them. This was almost double the Government estimate of £70,000 per property to do them up less than two years earlier. The cost even staggered local builders who agreed with the 2007 Government figure (see here).

Three residents, disgusted that the promised refurbishment of 23 houses wasn't going to happen, took out a High Court injunction prohibiting demolition of the affected Top Streets until it had been sorted out. But by October 2009 there were only eleven residents sticking it out in `demolition hell'…many forced out by the physical and mental conditions of living life in the shadow of the bulldozers.

A Salford Council report at the time (see here) spelled out life for one resident… "she is living in very poor and isolated conditions and has already been the victim of anti-social behaviour on a number of occasions" it stated "…recent events have taken their toll on her well-being leading to her being treated by her GP for anxiety…"

It continued: "Enabling this resident to move out of her property within a relatively short time timescale will minimise the risk of further injury to her physical and mental well-being."

The resident in question didn't want to move out of the area. Her "preferred option throughout the clearance process", the Report stated, "has been to move into a refurbished property within the new development". However "...the Council have made a decision that refurbishment is no longer viable in the area and the option is, therefore, no longer available."

In other words, this resident, along with others, was forced out of the area by the very regeneration that was supposed to benefit her. Others weren't so `lucky'…

A Salford Council report, tracking sixty Top Streets residents who were involved in the consultation Solutions Group, shows that six people died waiting for the regeneration of the area.

Out of the sixty residents who were tracked, 19 moved into Vincent Street, the only new houses built for original house owners in the Top Streets. Two of those people have subsequently died too, and still the regeneration isn't finished. Meanwhile the new houses on Vincent Street appear to be crumbling after only a few years (see here).

Of the original sixty residents, only four were still living in the Top Streets (27 moved to rented houses or out of the area completely), allowing Salford Council to go to the High Court pleading there was no demand for 23 refurbished houses, or even the eight on Devonshire Street. In the end, six houses were saved on Devonshire Street – out of over 400 in the Top and Bottom Streets of Higher Broughton.

A last minute representation from SAVE Britain's Heritage to Communities Minister, Eric Pickles, in October last year (see here), arguing that the terrace houses were "unique surviving examples of a working class Northern neighbourhood" amongst other things, was over-ruled. And the bulldozers have moved in.

Three of those four residents from the soon to be flattened streets will be moving into the refurbished houses on Devonshire Street, while the final resident, Guy Griffiths, is currently packing his bags, on pain of a visit from the Sheriff to physically boot him out (see here and see here).

Last week, Salford Council's Planning Panel approved plans for 80 new houses in the area – a mix of three, four and six bedroom housesnone of which will be affordable to anyone who used to live in the Top or Bottom Streets.

The planning documents for the new houses state that in the Top Streets alone there were 896 bed spaces before the area got flattened. Of those, maybe 24 people will live in the neighbourhood to see the `regeneration' complete. Over £20million of public money will have been spent in Higher Broughton by that time. Who exactly has it benefited?

On 18th June 2001, Moira Blood from Portico Housing Association, who was acting as liaison between the Wiltshire Street Residents Group and Salford Council, prepared a report for an early regeneration consultation. The final paragraph of the report states...

"There is a supposition on the part of the residents that any cleared land will be sold for development, providing modern, more expensive homes. If this happens, residents see very clearly that they will lose their homes and their status as owner/occupiers to permit other, more affluent, people to move in..."

Higher Broughton looks, to all intents and purposes, like the assassination of a community…

 

* See also Salford Star's history of the Higher Broughton regeneration from the printed Issue 4 - click here and follow the links

** See also how the community lost out financially in Salford Star's call for a Public Inquiry into Pathfinder activity in Higher Broughton from March last year - click here

Update: 22nd March 2012

See the last video shot in the Top Streets by Darktown Jubilee - click here

 


 

 

Exiled wrote
at 12:41:54 on 03 April 2012
It's absolutely terrible they've demolished all these houses when so many people are waiting for a house. These houses have stood for 110 years and would probably be good for another 110 with a little sympathetic work. It would be nice if somebody squatted in the houses that are still standing. I wonder how Salford Council would react to that.
 
adrian purdy wrote
at 21:48:04 on 22 March 2012
Brings tears to my eyes reading this artical ,i was born here and grew up in these streets along with many more people im connected to ,salford council should be in crown court on a charge of gross negligence and a vandalism ,salford council of late will be remembered for doing more damage to salford than ever adolf hitlers bombs ever could or did ,if ever theres a council that wants wiping away its them !
 
Stuart Smyth the kandy Kabin langworthy rd wrote
at 20:41:59 on 21 March 2012
We were up for regeneration in the second phase Of the langworthy!! Now were under Pendleton for Regeneration. This started more than twelve years ago!! what have we had done!! Flower pots on the safety railings outside the Cornerstone. #notholdingmybreathanymore!
 
Gareth L wrote
at 14:42:40 on 21 March 2012
It makes me sick to read of this councils antics. But what makes me sicker is that the people of Salford let them get away with it!
 
Sylvia Wilson wrote
at 09:18:09 on 21 March 2012
This is yet another example of the sheer greed of Councils who are still grasping and blagging more money from Government to continue the same mistakes they have done for past decades, only this time it is far worse than it has ever been on a mass scale. Councils formally under HMR, fail to understand that HMR does not exist anymore or realise that they now have to deal with a problem that THEY created... by using the alternative method of refurbishment to get these houses back on the market and getting the market going again... yet Councils are still determined to demolish homes that provide safe, adaptable (2 houses into 1), warm, affordable homes in a world of housing shortage and excessive Council waiting lists. The Councils put "what they want" for an area forward rather than listening to the needs of the residents, the gross waste of money spent, (which is not theirs) is spent like water, which includes using excess of our own tax money against us for Inquiries and High Courts, (if Councils had to pay this money out of their own pockets to gain our homes and destroy our Communities, it would never happen)! What many Councils are doing is following through on demolition, like Higher Broughton, or is putting all former acquired homes in HMR areas they have targeted, on hold for the foreseeable future until further funding becomes available for demolition, what they fail again to realise is that the directions from Government when HMR started 10 years ago was, "to improve areas of POSSIBLE deprivation and that DEMOLITION is to be a LAST RESORT"! It seems Councils have forgotten this directive and is now working on the assumption that is it is OK to force people out of their homes against their will and demolish good houses whenever they want to new build houses to put money in their own coffers at the expense of the residents. At the end of the day, they can put on their hats and coats and go home, we on the other hand, have to live in, and with, their mess and mistakes! This is not common sense nor is it a way forward.
 
Fadge wrote
at 18:58:45 on 20 March 2012
A typical saga of gross ineptitude and greed . All involved in this disgraceful and appalling deliberate destruction of a community deserve prison time .
 
caroline wrote
at 18:58:29 on 20 March 2012
does anyone think that greed can make people mad in the head.It is clear upgrading is best..and they have £ for brains and nowth but else..
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Giraffe
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SALFORD STAR SAVED AS £3,000 RAISED BY THE COMMUNITY
What a wonderful result which shows how much the Star is respected and how much the community wants it to continue. I was overcome... [more]
article: BUILE HILL PARK HOUSING IS ONLY WAY TO SAVE SALFORD MANSION STATES DEVELOPER
Had we had clowncillors with intelligence and integrity , the mansion would have been maintained as it should have been . Salford... [more]
article: BUILE HILL PARK HOUSING IS ONLY WAY TO SAVE SALFORD MANSION STATES DEVELOPER
As usual, Ray's comment against capitalism does little to answer my point about the £4million.As is unusual ,Mary's point does not... [more]
article: SALFORD PANTO ON THE PARK IN LOWER BROUGHTON
See Nadine's comment below - we think it's only pay on the day!!!... [more]
article: SALFORD PANTO ON THE PARK IN LOWER BROUGHTON
Hi is it ok to pay on the day ? ... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

THE MOODS PLAY MUSIC FROM THE NORTH AT BAND ON THE WALL

Star date: 12th December 2018

DON'T MISS THE MOODS AND CO THIS SATURDAY!

Music from the North
The Moods, Pleasures, Glove, Falling Ghosts and DJ Stephen Doyle
Saturday 15th December from 7pm
Band On The Wall £10

This Saturday, there's another brilliant Music from the North gig at Band On The Wall hosted by A1M Records, with Salford Star Best Band Award winners, The Moods and a full line-up of upcoming talent. Ian Leslie catches up with Paul Travis of A1M Records to get the gen.

Full details here...

SALFORD PANTO ON THE PARK IN LOWER BROUGHTON

Star date: 11th December 2018

SALFORD CINDERELLA PLUS DANCE TROUPES AND STALLS

Panto On The Park
Sunday 16th December 12noon-3pm
Green Grosvenor Park, Lower Broughton (suggested donation £1-£2)

This Sunday, 16th December, Up Ere Theatre Group will be performing their own version of Salford's Cinderella in a heated marquee at Green Grosvenor Park in Lower Broughton. There'll also be performances from dance troupes Salford Aces, Urban Angels and JD Dance, plus lots of stalls, face painting and more.

Full details here...

SALFORD STAR SAVED AS £3,000 RAISED BY THE COMMUNITY

Star date: 10th December 2018

NIGEL PIVARO CONCLUDES SALFORD STAR FUNDRAISING WITH SALFORD PRECINCT AUCTION

After two auctions, two exhibitions and a pop-up shop over just ten days, the immediate future of the Salford Star has been saved, with around £3,000 raised by the community.

At Salford Shopping Centre yesterday, over £1,000 was raised as actor and long time Salford Star contributor, Nigel Pivaro conducted an auction of Salford relics and memorabilia... "This isn't just about raising money for the Salford Star" said Nigel "It's also symbolic in terms of raising awareness of what we've done over the years...shining the torch where councils, developers and companies don't like it shone..."

Full details here...

ECCLES COMIC TONY KINSELLA DOES THE UNDERTONES

Star date: 9th December 2018

THE UNDERTONES GET OVERKILL

Tony Kinsella - More Jokes about Girls and Chocolate
Sunday 9th December
Bolton Socialist Club

Eccles comic Tony Kinsella debuts a show dedicated to The Undertones at the Bolton Socialist Club tonight. Ian Leslie checks out the laughs...

Full details here...

SALFORD STAR EXHIBITION, EVENTS AND AUCTION AND WITH NIGEL PIVARO

Star date: 8th December 2018

PICK UP BARGAINS, RELICS AND MORE IN SALFORD STAR EXHIBITION FINAL DAY AT SALFORD PRECINCT

Salford Star Exhibition, Auction and Event
With Nigel Pivaro, Simon Williams, Chris Flynn and Sandra Bouguerch
Sunday 9th December 10am - 4pm (events from 1:30pm/auction around 3pm)
Salford Shopping Centre (next to Lloyds Bank)

Tomorrow sees the final day of the Salford Star pop-up shop and exhibition, with an auction hosted by Nigel Pivaro of weird and wonderful Salford relics and bargain Christmas presents; plus street poetry from the spirit of Salford himself, Simon Williams, songs by the ace Chris Flynn and a Party On performance piece for all the family by artist Sandra Bouguerch.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx